Please FIX the wrong %DD. It ıs not reflecting the truth!! Abstimmergebnisse
Please FIX the wrong %DD. It ıs not reflecting the truth!! Diskussion
Sep 15, 2011 at 10:51
2,035 Angesehen
16 Replies
forex_trader_36599
Mitglied seit May 13, 2011
1341 Posts
Sep 15, 2011 at 10:51
%DD is not correct in any account
Sep 24, 2011 at 00:24
I agree. Why not add daily Equity Drawdown % as a second statistic underneath the current daily Balance drawdown %?
This statistic is equally as important. A system may look safe with a closed trades drawdown of just 10% but may be high risk with actual open equity drawdowns of 60%. Is this currently displayed anywhere other than visually on the chart?
This is critical to comparative analysis of the risk and safety of different systems.
This statistic is equally as important. A system may look safe with a closed trades drawdown of just 10% but may be high risk with actual open equity drawdowns of 60%. Is this currently displayed anywhere other than visually on the chart?
This is critical to comparative analysis of the risk and safety of different systems.
Mitglied seit Jul 30, 2011
71 Posts
Sep 28, 2011 at 11:08
Absolutely, I totally agree, this is a very very good way to judge how reliable systems are and if they are actually applying the strategy they boast.
Riding waves always leads to a fall
Oct 05, 2011 at 07:20
A parallel issue to this is the delay in showing the latest drawdown figures visually on the chart.
The chart only updates each day if a trade is closed on that day - so if no trades have been closed there is no chart information shown. This is a problem as a system may be slipping into deeper equity drawdown each day which is hidden until a trade is closed and the chart updates.
It would be good for the chart to update each day even without a closed trade so we can see that even if the balance line remains static the yellow line is changing to reflect the varying equity amount.
The chart only updates each day if a trade is closed on that day - so if no trades have been closed there is no chart information shown. This is a problem as a system may be slipping into deeper equity drawdown each day which is hidden until a trade is closed and the chart updates.
It would be good for the chart to update each day even without a closed trade so we can see that even if the balance line remains static the yellow line is changing to reflect the varying equity amount.
forex_trader_36599
Mitglied seit May 13, 2011
1341 Posts
Oct 05, 2011 at 07:52
agree!
soulfire posted:
A parallel issue to this is the delay in showing the latest drawdown figures visually on the chart.
The chart only updates each day if a trade is closed on that day - so if no trades have been closed there is no chart information shown. This is a problem as a system may be slipping into deeper equity drawdown each day which is hidden until a trade is closed and the chart updates.
It would be good for the chart to update each day even without a closed trade so we can see that even if the balance line remains static the yellow line is changing to reflect the varying equity amount.
forex_trader_34364
Mitglied seit Apr 18, 2011
239 Posts
Oct 08, 2011 at 18:52
personally one time i had an account which monitored it in myfxbook , i had 60% DD but at the end of the day all trades closed it profit , it on myfxbook control panel DD was 2% .
forex_trader_32776
Mitglied seit Mar 28, 2011
1008 Posts
Oct 25, 2011 at 12:00
daily_martingle posted:
personally one time i had an account which monitored it in myfxbook , i had 60% DD but at the end of the day all trades closed it profit , it on myfxbook control panel DD was 2% .
exactly.
I think real time drawdown is right around the corner.
Since we have live data quotes in the Footer Tool Bar, MFB is streaming real time. This was the needed ingredient to add Real Time DD statistics.
I know that some brokers quotes will not match this stream, and perhaps we'll need a Warning: sign mentioning that ' This system's data feed does not match our Real Time Feed, therefore statistics are not 100% accurate.'
The other concern would be that the users system could avoid updating while in excessive DD, and then update their system once the DD period is over. If this is the case, MFB would have to run all preexisting trades against historical data to configure 100% accurate statistics..... any other ideas?
forex_trader_34364
Mitglied seit Apr 18, 2011
239 Posts
Oct 25, 2011 at 13:44
ForexScam posted:
daily_martingle posted:
personally one time i had an account which monitored it in myfxbook , i had 60% DD but at the end of the day all trades closed it profit , it on myfxbook control panel DD was 2% .
exactly.
I think real time drawdown is right around the corner.
Since we have live data quotes in the Footer Tool Bar, MFB is streaming real time. This was the needed ingredient to add Real Time DD statistics.
I know that some brokers quotes will not match this stream, and perhaps we'll need a Warning: sign mentioning that ' This system's data feed does not match our Real Time Feed, therefore statistics are not 100% accurate.'
The other concern would be that the users system could avoid updating while in excessive DD, and then update their system once the DD period is over. If this is the case, MFB would have to run all preexisting trades against historical data to configure 100% accurate statistics..... any other ideas?
sure
like zulutrader. no one cant escape from DD , they are monitoring your account even your pc in turned off , or your MT4 platform is closed
forex_trader_36599
Mitglied seit May 13, 2011
1341 Posts
Oct 25, 2011 at 13:52
the update frequency is the key. for updating accounts MFB dont need the trader computer due it has the investor pass. so the issue is the MFB should scan all accounts frequently and the BETA version accounts should be used.
forex_trader_32776
Mitglied seit Mar 28, 2011
1008 Posts
Dec 09, 2011 at 20:25
bump
Jan 08, 2012 at 14:35
I really love the suggestion of adding DD (in % and pips) will help a lot to understand the 1) reliability of ths ystem 2) it helps the trader tighten or loosen his SL (case by case). 3) Trader gets lot of valuable information based on how far the trade travellend in opposie direction before it moves to this direction.
It should be better if it added at the real time rather once in a day.
It should be better if it added at the real time rather once in a day.
Mitglied seit Jul 31, 2009
1444 Posts
Jan 19, 2012 at 08:39
I'm glad to say this feature is in its final stages and should be released in the next or the following version release. Not sure if the development team will have enough time to squeeze in all of the above suggestions, however the main drawdown issue will be definitely resolved 😄.
forex_trader_32776
Mitglied seit Mar 28, 2011
1008 Posts
Jan 20, 2012 at 03:57
Way to Go Ethan !😀 We're all pleased with your efforts.
*Kommerzielle Nutzung und Spam werden nicht toleriert und können zur Kündigung des Kontos führen.
Tipp: Wenn Sie ein Bild/eine Youtube-Url posten, wird diese automatisch in Ihren Beitrag eingebettet!
Tipp: Tippen Sie das @-Zeichen ein, um einen an dieser Diskussion teilnehmenden Benutzernamen automatisch zu vervollständigen.
