Featured Signal Providers
Tradency évaluation
Tradency
www.tradency.com/
Score total : 4.2/10
Total des votes : 46
Rentabilité
 
 
Plateforme
 
 
barème des prix
 
 
Service à la clientèle
 
 
0 - Pire   10 - Meilleur
Discussion au sujet de
Précédent 1 2 3 4 5 Suivant
anacon

Membre depuis Feb 17, 2011  8 messages anacon Feb 25 2011 at 10:15
Hi everyones,
Can I manage my account through the website or it is required to use MT4 or other trading platform? I see one of their tutorials and its platform seems to be the Trading Station of FXCM. Any opinion about the systems they are offering?
Thanks!

magma

Membre depuis Oct 23, 2010  6 messages magma Feb 25 2011 at 10:17
It's web based tradency platform.

anacon

Membre depuis Feb 17, 2011  8 messages anacon Feb 28 2011 at 11:06
Thanks Magma, so I have to open a broker account through them, right?
Do you know what is the best or at least a reasonable broker for trading through Tradency?

magma

Membre depuis Oct 23, 2010  6 messages magma Feb 28 2011 at 19:31
Personally, my account with FXCM it's called FSS but you can go to Alpari, FXDD and few others.

This is a golden advice: don't open real account now! open trial account with the same amount you have (I think FXCM will let you choose the amount) it's not as easy or profitable as it looks like!!! after 4 months of signing up I just started making (small) profit and I will need 4 to 5 months to cover my losses.

The idea behind the tradency is much butter than the other automated platforms because you can choose a currency pair from one provider and another from another provider but that's not enough.

There are a lot of things you need to control it yourself.

Excalibur

Membre depuis Dec 22, 2010  6 messages Excalibur Feb 28 2011 at 20:09
I demo tested FXCM, Alpari, FXDD and FXOpen all using Tradency at the same time. FXCM had the best results, followed by Alpari and FXDD. FXOpen did not work at all for me.

After testing Tradency for months, I opened a live account with FXCM. In the last two weeks I have made over 10% return. I still have a demo (separate from live) where I test strategies. I have been very lucky lately, pushing the strategies to the limit and have made a lot of paper money. My demo account is up 50% in one week however I am very analytical and spend a fair amount of time at it.

The demo results are exactly the same as the live results.

Is anyone aware of another similar system that does as well or better?

magma

Membre depuis Oct 23, 2010  6 messages magma Feb 28 2011 at 20:43

Excalibur posted:
    I demo tested FXCM, Alpari, FXDD and FXOpen all using Tradency at the same time. FXCM had the best results, followed by Alpari and FXDD. FXOpen did not work at all for me.

After testing Tradency for months, I opened a live account with FXCM. In the last two weeks I have made over 10% return. I still have a demo (separate from live) where I test strategies. I have been very lucky lately, pushing the strategies to the limit and have made a lot of paper money. My demo account is up 50% in one week however I am very analytical and spend a fair amount of time at it.

The demo results are exactly the same as the live results.

Is anyone aware of another similar system that does as well or better?




Finally, there is somebody making money out of the tradency platform!

I tried to find another platform but it seems the tradency is best among them (although there are a lot of missing features)

There are some major issues with tradency strategies, for example:
1- a strategy could be very very profitable this month but next it will keep losing trades till the last $ in your account (why is that, each strategy should be monitored by the owner and tradency)

2- Except very few strategies all of them will go -50 or -150 pip then will make + 15 to 20pip profit in each trade (what is that!!)

Excalibur

Membre depuis Dec 22, 2010  6 messages Excalibur Feb 28 2011 at 21:00
After careful evaluation and discussions with FXCM and Tradency, you need to use only strategies that are above a T-score of 9. The higher the better. I have tried to evaluate currency correlations, diversity of currency pairs, etc. but in the end its really just the best T-score that matters. Of course some strategies make a lot but then they risk a lot. I think you could potentially do well using Tradency but need to be careful. Only 1-2% of the strategies they offer are good but I hope that changes. Until it does I am going to stay with them but I'm always looking for other choices.

I was just looking at zipsignals do you have any experience with them using a signal like Ace -fxtrade?

magma

Membre depuis Oct 23, 2010  6 messages magma Feb 28 2011 at 21:38
you are right, I have some rules for selecting strategies:
1- must be 9+ T-Score or 8 and increasing (green triangle)
2- must be 3 max open position at time, the best 2
3- Draw down must not exceed 200pip for the last 2 months (and be careful for 0 draw the account must be big enough for -200pip)
4- winning trades must be at least 90%
5- Rinse and repeat every weekend !!!

I'm also looking for signals provider, I found several almost all of them were scam but there is one claiming +1000pip every month! (the fx guru com) 2 months ago it was free but now it's paid site but till now I don't know if it's scam or not

Excalibur

Membre depuis Dec 22, 2010  6 messages Excalibur Mar 01 2011 at 23:23
So yesterday I decided to try zipsignals with Ace -Fxtrader on a demo account with FXCM. After running it this afternoon, I am down buy $1500 on $100k. It does not look pretty. The trial runs 10 days.

Could you please clarify the significance of the red or green triangle? I am not sure how that would impact choosing a strategy. For instance, I would choose a T-Score of 9.91 with a red triangle over a T-Score of 8.65 with a green triangle? Thoughts?

I agree that controlling max open positions would be valuable but I would not eliminate a strategy just because it opens 4 positions if it has a great T-Score.

'Rinse and repeat every weekend' is so true.

There are few startegies that meet your criteria except my personal favorite Firemoon.

When you review strategies, do you use 30, 60, 90 days.....180 days etc? I usually start with 30 days then work up to 24 months and then down to the last 7 days.


magma

Membre depuis Oct 23, 2010  6 messages magma Mar 01 2011 at 23:55
I have only one strategy in my account 'firemoon'! I don't know it's not showing up when I apply my rules.

to explain about the 4 max op let's give real example

PowerGrid (GBPUSD) P/L: 3200 for the past 30days
FireBird (CADJPY) P/L: 2700 for the past 30days

Now which one you will choose, most people will say the first one, correct?

But I will go for the second because the first one will open 4 positions (so it's like selecting 4 strategies together) it's like that there are 4 employees working for you to get you 3200 while in the second scenario it's only one employee. got it?

I judge strategies based on their performance up to 90days but I check beyond the 90days to see the performance.

Anther thing I do is to select more than one strategy for each pair, for example instead of 2 lots for Tiverlustek (NZDUSD) I choose 1 lot for Tiverlustek and 1 for Tactico

by the way, what strategies you are using.

p.s. hope that the programmer of Antisthenes (AUDUSD) can solve the issue of the loosing trades sad]

Précédent 1 2 3 4 5 Suivant
EIA Crude Oil Stocks change (1h 1min)
Flash: FOMC highlights – BBH(9 min ago)
EURUSD 1.33938 GBPUSD 1.56607
USDJPY 95.031 USDCAD 1.01972
Outils Communauté Commentaires Plateforme Société Assistance
Calendrier économique Communauté Courtier Widgets A Propos Questions fréquentes
Forex Market Systèmes Expert Advisors Caractéristiques Blog Aide
Forex Volatility Most Popular Systems Fournisseurs de signaux API Twitter Contactez-nous
Forex Correlation Stratégies VPS Services Portable Facebook Signalez-nous une erreur.
Spreads des Brokers Forex Concours EA Programming Traductions    
Forex Broker Quotes Forex Charts PAMM Brokers RSS    
Forex Broker Swaps Communauté Outlook Rebate Programs      
Nouvelles en continu Forex   Trading Platforms      
Forex Broker Volume          
COT Data New          

Plan du site  |   Termes et conditions  |   Politique de confidentialité
©2012 Myfxbook Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
HIGH RISK WARNING: Foreign exchange trading carries a high level of risk that may not be suitable for all investors. Leverage creates additional risk and loss exposure. Before you decide to trade foreign exchange, carefully consider your investment objectives, experience level, and risk tolerance. You could lose some or all of your initial investment; do not invest money that you cannot afford to lose. Educate yourself on the risks associated with foreign exchange trading, and seek advice from an independent financial or tax advisor if you have any questions. Any data and information is provided 'as is' solely for informational purposes, and is not intended for trading purposes or advice.