forexma posted:
    Regarding your trading methods.... all I can say is OUCH and.... scary.
Your last trades 3x4 lots... held for 7 days.... w/o SL, more than 300 pips floating loss before you take 2-3 pips profit. It's a ticking time bomb. Pretty bad RR, something like 100:1.


No comment.
Any further questions or a P.S.?

ranesh posted:
    Tradingcompany posted:
    stevetrade posted:
    Why is there no update on this since last Friday?
Equity is at 55% as well.


please don mind the 55%, that is a bug from myfxbook


It's NOT a myfxbook bug. I confirmed this with Ethan (myfxbook support for those of you who don't know him). He said that the 55% equity shown here is ACCURATE as published at the last update. The only thing they are still working on, which most of us who've been on myfxbook for quite a while are aware of, is the equity 'curve' updating process.

The only way to remove all doubt about this account before any other conclusion is arrived at, is for it to be updated one more time. So if a withdrawal has indeed been made as claimed, it will appear here and if the equity indicated here as 55% is indeed incorrect as claimed, it would be possible to confirm that too.

There are 2 possible scenarios:

1. This account got margin called
2. He made a withdrawal as claimed either when the equity was @ 55% or even less than that, in order to save the remaining equity from getting wiped out.

Lets give him the benefit of the doubt and throw in 1 more scenario:

3. Everything he has stated here is TRUE. But only another update can substantiate that.

The ball is now in his court.

P.S: I'm surprised that the 'self appointed' CFP (Chief of Forum Police) has not pounced on this as he does with others in order to protect naive investors who get reeled in hook, line and sinker by traders who initially show MASSIVE monthly gains only to blow up accounts shortly thereafter.



I like u cos u always know how to criticize, what happens when i update it, anything for me? for the records, i just updated Tradincompany which u are criticizing margin call, men u really have to think b4 u post https://www.myfxbook.com/portfolio/trading-company/75115

Tradingcompany posted:
    
ranesh posted:
    Tradingcompany posted:
    stevetrade posted:
    Why is there no update on this since last Friday?
Equity is at 55% as well.


please don mind the 55%, that is a bug from myfxbook


It's NOT a myfxbook bug. I confirmed this with Ethan (myfxbook support for those of you who don't know him). He said that the 55% equity shown here is ACCURATE as published at the last update. The only thing they are still working on, which most of us who've been on myfxbook for quite a while are aware of, is the equity 'curve' updating process.

The only way to remove all doubt about this account before any other conclusion is arrived at, is for it to be updated one more time. So if a withdrawal has indeed been made as claimed, it will appear here and if the equity indicated here as 55% is indeed incorrect as claimed, it would be possible to confirm that too.

There are 2 possible scenarios:

1. This account got margin called
2. He made a withdrawal as claimed either when the equity was @ 55% or even less than that, in order to save the remaining equity from getting wiped out.

Lets give him the benefit of the doubt and throw in 1 more scenario:

3. Everything he has stated here is TRUE. But only another update can substantiate that.

The ball is now in his court.

P.S: I'm surprised that the 'self appointed' CFP (Chief of Forum Police) has not pounced on this as he does with others in order to protect naive investors who get reeled in hook, line and sinker by traders who initially show MASSIVE monthly gains only to blow up accounts shortly thereafter.



I like u cos u always know how to criticize, what happens when i update it, anything for me? for the records, i just updated Tradincompany which u are criticizing margin call, men u really have to think b4 u post https://www.myfxbook.com/portfolio/trading-company/75115



You have stated that the 55% Equity shown here (Trading Company2) is a myfxbook bug. Myfxbook says that there is NO bug and the 55% Equity shown here is ACCURATE and is CORRECT as per the last update published here.

You want to know what's in it for you to update this account? You'll be proving that you have not lied to the community here.

Whether you decide to update this account or not is your call. The final conclusion by the community here about your credibility will depend on that.

I don't wish anyone's accounts to go 'crash, boom, bang', which is why I have clearly ended my 2 posts earlier today on your 2 different accounts by saying that you should be given the benefit of the doubt UNTIL we arrive at any conclusion.

Also, I don't go around to other traders threads to criticize them. I respond only to those who come to 'my' thread and leave negative and useless posts on 'my' thread just like you FIRST came to 'my' thread to leave a negative post.

Decision time for you - it's not my reputation or credibility that's at stake here.

ranesh posted:
    Tradingcompany posted:
    
ranesh posted:
    Tradingcompany posted:
    stevetrade posted:
    Why is there no update on this since last Friday?
Equity is at 55% as well.


please don mind the 55%, that is a bug from myfxbook


It's NOT a myfxbook bug. I confirmed this with Ethan (myfxbook support for those of you who don't know him). He said that the 55% equity shown here is ACCURATE as published at the last update. The only thing they are still working on, which most of us who've been on myfxbook for quite a while are aware of, is the equity 'curve' updating process.

The only way to remove all doubt about this account before any other conclusion is arrived at, is for it to be updated one more time. So if a withdrawal has indeed been made as claimed, it will appear here and if the equity indicated here as 55% is indeed incorrect as claimed, it would be possible to confirm that too.

There are 2 possible scenarios:

1. This account got margin called
2. He made a withdrawal as claimed either when the equity was @ 55% or even less than that, in order to save the remaining equity from getting wiped out.

Lets give him the benefit of the doubt and throw in 1 more scenario:

3. Everything he has stated here is TRUE. But only another update can substantiate that.

The ball is now in his court.

P.S: I'm surprised that the 'self appointed' CFP (Chief of Forum Police) has not pounced on this as he does with others in order to protect naive investors who get reeled in hook, line and sinker by traders who initially show MASSIVE monthly gains only to blow up accounts shortly thereafter.



I like u cos u always know how to criticize, what happens when i update it, anything for me? for the records, i just updated Tradincompany which u are criticizing margin call, men u really have to think b4 u post https://www.myfxbook.com/portfolio/trading-company/75115



You have stated that the 55% Equity shown here (Trading Company2) is a myfxbook bug. Myfxbook says that there is NO bug and the 55% Equity shown here is ACCURATE and is CORRECT as per the last update published here.

You want to know what's in it for you to update this account? You'll be proving that you have not lied to the community here.

Whether you decide to update this account or not is your call. The final conclusion by the community here about your credibility will depend on that.

I don't wish anyone's accounts to go 'crash, boom, bang', which is why I have clearly ended my 2 posts earlier today on your 2 different accounts by saying that you should be given the benefit of the doubt UNTIL we arrive at any conclusion.

Also, I don't go around to other traders threads to criticize them. I respond only to those who come to 'my' thread and leave negative and useless posts on 'my' thread just like you FIRST came to 'my' thread to leave a negative post.

Decision time for you - it's not my reputation or credibility that's at stake here.


Now u are making it sound as if u are sorry, lol, and please why dont u unlock ur trading details just like i did if u hv nothing to hide, as for me?

ranesh posted:
    Don't be so quick to get your wires crossed... I have absolutely NOTHING to be sorry about.

It's starting to look like you're trying to divert from the topic at hand and dodge the decision you have to make.

You don't want everyone here to conclude that you have lied about your 55% equity being a myfxbook bug do you?

P.S : talking about open trades I wonder why you suddenly decided to hide your open trades here on 'Trading Company2' right before you stopped updating this account.


U mustbe silly by thinking that i hide open trades, silly you, trading4 is also on fxpro, so for me to update trading2, i need to cancel trading4, so dont be stupid, just like i said, u really need fnd something better to do, cos u are really diverting my attention from trading now to answering ur stupid posts