Share Posts by allanneagle
| Previous 1 2 3 Next |
|
Fair point on the decompiled EA and I am glad to hear you will be posting the source code (although simply making the MQ4 downloadable instead of the EX4 would be the better option). I didn't think you had anything to hide at all and hope I did not imply that.
And fair point on the 'optional' part. I guess I just didn't really like the fact that my pages now have this very obvious and highly visable red mark against them when I know I have done nothing wrong and I myself have nothing to hide.
I am concerned about fake data and appreciate the efforts to try to counteract it. I also appreciate......
|
|
Guys. As much as I love the site and the work you are doing on it, I have to say that requiring us to make a trade with a specific comment in order to gain the 'Trading Privileges' verification has not been thorougly thought out.
I had no problem providing my investor password so you could verify the trades I have uploaded. Excellent idea to counteract fack uploads.
I had no problem running an EA to further confirm the trades are legitamite ... EVEN THOUGH the source code for this EA is not apparently available and so I cannot verify what you are actually able to do in this EA. Trust goe......
|
|
I like the idea of having backtests excluded from systems and that could easily be done with a 'live/demo/backtest' setting. Only when setting t0 backtest would you get the ability to import the report and once it is a backtest then it can't be changed to anything else.
|
|
Not at all. I appreciate your support.
In fact you have said the same thing I am after but in a different way :)
|
|
I think it would be nice to have the ability to upload a Strategy Tester report to show off the analysis. I understand that nothing beats forward testing, but backtesting analysis would be great too.
|
|
A pip graph is a great idea, but I am not sure how accurate it could be. Consider this scenario ...
I place a buy order, the market goes up 50pips before my order is closed. I have earned 50pips right?
Nope. I can have it show that I have earned 150pips.
At 10pips I close 1/5th of the order giving a 10pip profit.
At 20pips I close another 1/5th giving me extra 20pips (plus the previous 10pips for a total so far of 30pips)
Do this every 10pips and that 50pip movement netted you 150pips.
Now there is nothing wrong with trading that way, but from an investors point of view would you go for the......
|
|
I thought this is how it worked now. Does 1 portfolio not equal 1 trading account?
|
|
Would it not be better to run the EA on a seperate account?
However, having an analysis table that can be grouped by EA would provide valuable information for single accounts running multiple EA's
|
|
[quote]pavelr posted: don't you agree that from investor's point of view, it is a valuable information?
[/quote]I absolutely agree. It would be fantastic to be able to see all the previous transactions that relate to the same trader/system, and that is why I suggested being able to reset an account.
Perhaps instead of removing all the old trades, they could simply be flagged as 'other account trades' so a historical record is kept ... or perhaps the ability to have multiple accounts belonging to the same discussion thread?
And I would also like to see other opinions also (and as someone who......
|
|
If anybody is after an MT4 Indicator or EA, I am available as a coder. Some of my previous work is published on my site <a href="http://theguruonline.biz">theguruonline.biz</a>
|
