To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Do you know if there is a list

nick3232
Dec 10 2018 at 15:05
162 zpráv(a,y)
very interesting ,thanks for this thread

vontogr (togr)
Dec 10 2018 at 15:07
4862 zpráv(a,y)
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.

niceGLer
Dec 11 2018 at 06:11
167 zpráv(a,y)
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.

FXF TradingGroup (FxFTradingGroup)
Dec 13 2018 at 11:16
6 zpráv(a,y)
niceGLer posted:
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.


I suppose you can take positive slippage into consideration. Some brokers do not have positive slippage while others do.

jamesgwyther
Dec 14 2018 at 11:40
289 zpráv(a,y)
hmmm thanks for the replies guys.

vontogr (togr)
Dec 14 2018 at 12:32
4862 zpráv(a,y)
niceGLer posted:
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.


It needs testing on real accounts. But to answer it simply, the better the ratio of successful traders
the better the execution, spread and sllipage

Adribaasmet
Dec 23 2018 at 08:31
947 zpráv(a,y)
FxFTradingGroup posted:
niceGLer posted:
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.


I suppose you can take positive slippage into consideration. Some brokers do not have positive slippage while others do.


Slippage is always risky, when we don’t whatever it will be, positive or negative.

FXF TradingGroup (FxFTradingGroup)
Dec 24 2018 at 07:46
6 zpráv(a,y)
Adribaasmet posted:
FxFTradingGroup posted:
niceGLer posted:
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.


I suppose you can take positive slippage into consideration. Some brokers do not have positive slippage while others do.


Slippage is always risky, when we don’t whatever it will be, positive or negative.


You can't deny that slippage occurs in almost all live accounts. Some brokers keep the positive slippage for themselves while the traders pay negative slippage. Since he's asking about the verification of honesty amongst brokers, this is one which I can provide him with in his consideration.

Adribaasmet
Dec 24 2018 at 13:20
947 zpráv(a,y)
Basically I avoid high voltage news sessions like NFP, FOMC! As a result, most of the time I don’t face slippage problem. No doubt, it’s an irritating issue.

niceGLer
Dec 24 2018 at 15:11
167 zpráv(a,y)
FxFTradingGroup posted:
Adribaasmet posted:
FxFTradingGroup posted:
niceGLer posted:
togr posted:
jamesgwyther posted:
togr posted:
of brokers and the percentage of traders losing money with them?
I believe the average is about 75% but today I have seen ad for broker who advertise 86% of the traders is losing money with that broker :)
Isn't it appealing to join?


Why would it be different with different brokers though?


Brokers are different,
the very same trade on 2 different brokers could be positive on one broker and negative on the second.


How do you verify that a broker is honest, what comes to slippage? It is qjite straightforward to gauge spread but not so,with the slippage. I am talking about market makers, and don't know if other kinds of brokers can cheat as well. I had a luck to begin my trading with a spread of 0.2 pips, but I didn't quite realise how important spread Aand extra costsa are. Small sums are adding up.


I suppose you can take positive slippage into consideration. Some brokers do not have positive slippage while others do.


Slippage is always risky, when we don’t whatever it will be, positive or negative.


You can't deny that slippage occurs in almost all live accounts. Some brokers keep the positive slippage for themselves while the traders pay negative slippage. Since he's asking about the verification of honesty amongst brokers, this is one which I can provide him with in his consideration.


Thanks. I haven't thought this way. The same is that the brokers have to state their percentage of losing players. The more winning traders the better. Together with spread slippage becomes an issue as the holding period length shortens. Usually ppl don't have patience for long term trades so it might be a good metrics.

Prosím, přihlašte se pro vložení komentáře.