채팅을 사용하려면 로그인하십시오.

Show your profitable account here.

arpan366
Mar 12 2018 at 11:26
게시물31
FxMasterGuru posted:
arpan366 posted:
Kindly have a look:

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/arpan366/pps-eventstrategy/2419114 (broker error in Nov17)
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/arpan366/icm-mr-daily/2419110
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/arpan366/pps-harmonics/2419112

Any comments would be appreciated. Thanks.


@arpan366

Well, my only observation - since you asked - is that the longest running account (without any ''broker error'') has not made ANY net profit since September of 2017, i.e. for the past 6 months. Is it good...? I am sure about that, but definitely better than losing...



Thanks a lot for the observation. I guess easy to pick a losing period period (definition of a drawdown) for any strategy and highlight it but it has made about 2.5% in the last 3 months with minimal drawdowns...and about 22% since Sep17 with a drawdown of < 5%. I agree that it should have been better but in my defense i reduced risk after the 6% drawdown in a month and so the recent gains are much smaller in comparison (on a % basis but higher on a return/drawdown basis).

The broker error (Pepperstone - was definitely not expecting this) happened for a month. Without it, all months are +ve (~5% average each month) with drawdown < 5%.

AniLorak
Mar 12 2018 at 11:26
게시물920
Hulan posted:
3 months age account
 
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/Hulan/smart/2442879


A good graph! By the way, are you trading manually or using a Robot there?

Loic Hellard
challenger
Mar 12 2018 at 11:27
게시물129
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/challenger/pulse/2452711

0.9% DrawDown
only 50 positions . 49 wins
only Gold trading.
safe and stable.

AlphaSkyCapital
Mar 12 2018 at 14:31
게시물14
uplinktrading posted:
AlphaSkyCapital posted:
Our trading accounts...

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/AlphaSkyCapital/broadway-dar/2449595

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/AlphaSkyCapital/broadway-20-dar/2449608


No scalping, no grid or martingale strategies.


Good job guys! Keep it up


Thank you, we try😉

FxMasterGuru (FxMasterGuru)
Mar 12 2018 at 14:33
게시물1607
togr posted:
FxMasterGuru posted:
Hulan posted:
3 months age account
 
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/Hulan/smart/2442879


This one is tricky... 100% win rate (100 win out of 100 trades) with only 5% DD... But don't fall for it.

This account is probaly a Grid or a lucky 'Hope & Pray' strategy which is DISCONNECTED from MyFxBook during drawdowns.

The account's last update was on March 02, i.e. 10 days ago, so probably it is in a major DD, and waiting for the recovery when the trade(s) will be closed in profit and the account will be reconnected to MyFxBook showing another picture perfect win with minimal DD...


yeah such unreal results always happens on scam brokers.


@togr

You are right. Weltrade is a Belize registered (''regulated'') off-shore broker, so just this fact is enough to raise suspicion when an account shows 100 wins out of 100 trades... So probably these results are ''hand-crafted'' to lure in new clients to run the ''Holy Grail'' strategy available only through this broker...

Nevertheless, even if these results were shown on an ASIC or FCA regulated broker account I would be highly suspicious of hidden major DDs easily achieved by simply disconnecting the account from MyFxBook while there are open trades.

Please click "Vouch" if you liked my post. If not, just put me on your Blocked list. :o)
Mike K (mikekhod)
Mar 13 2018 at 06:52
게시물52
@ Fxmasterguru & Togr
You guys are super experienced and all.....but pls stop trying to discount someones work because it seems better than what you have been able to make so far. I mean that with all the respect but everytime i check out this forum you two seem to bash on other good systems :\

I am one of the 5-10% left in the world. Good people who love money for self and to help others. but NOT a sellout to money.
vontogr (togr)
Mar 13 2018 at 09:18
게시물4862
mikekhod posted:
@ Fxmasterguru & Togr
You guys are super experienced and all.....but pls stop trying to discount someones work because it seems better than what you have been able to make so far. I mean that with all the respect but everytime i check out this forum you two seem to bash on other good systems :\

@mikekhod
The thing is there are only a few good systems published. And if you scroll back you can see I dont mind to say someone else system is good.
Problem is fake accounts, heavy martingale accounts, fresh accounts. These do not belong here, I may these should not be anywhere not to confuse people.

FxMasterGuru (FxMasterGuru)
Mar 13 2018 at 09:20
게시물1607
mikekhod posted:
@ Fxmasterguru & Togr
You guys are super experienced and all.....but pls stop trying to discount someones work because it seems better than what you have been able to make so far. I mean that with all the respect but everytime i check out this forum you two seem to bash on other good systems :\


@mikekhod

I do appreciate your respect and I do understand your concerns, however, ''Togr'' and me got our HIGH VOUCH SCORES exactly for the reason you mentioned: i.e. for pointing out weaknesses or major flaws of posted strategies and exposing scam accounts. So unlike you, most MyFxBook members DO APPRECIATE our insights and critiques, and that is why they had rewarded us with their vouches.

So why do members APPRECIATE our posts...?

Well, because our evaluations have saved numerous newbies from making costly mistakes by signing up for DOOMED ''account management'' schemes with flawed strategies which seemed ''good'' for them at first sight.

In summary, it is not about ''ego'' or ''trolling'' or ''bashing'', but it is a ''public service'' for less experienced traders, and any critique from us is open for discussion.

Please click "Vouch" if you liked my post. If not, just put me on your Blocked list. :o)
fxinvesta
Mar 13 2018 at 19:15
게시물107
mikekhod posted:
@ Fxmasterguru & Togr
You guys are super experienced and all.....but pls stop trying to discount someones work because it seems better than what you have been able to make so far. I mean that with all the respect but everytime i check out this forum you two seem to bash on other good systems :\


When you are small in mind, you can only criticize others. here only ask for some rules and simply show the account, but frustrated traders do not want to see it ... this is the only truth

Risk comes from not knowing what you're doing.
goyankees85
Mar 13 2018 at 20:27
게시물118
FxMasterGuru posted:
mikekhod posted:
@ Fxmasterguru & Togr
You guys are super experienced and all.....but pls stop trying to discount someones work because it seems better than what you have been able to make so far. I mean that with all the respect but everytime i check out this forum you two seem to bash on other good systems :\


@mikekhod

I do appreciate your respect and I do understand your concerns, however, ''Togr'' and me got our HIGH VOUCH SCORES exactly for the reason you mentioned: i.e. for pointing out weaknesses or major flaws of posted strategies and exposing scam accounts. So unlike you, most MyFxBook members DO APPRECIATE our insights and critiques, and that is why they had rewarded us with their vouches.

So why do members APPRECIATE our posts...?

Well, because our evaluations have saved numerous newbies from making costly mistakes by signing up for DOOMED ''account management'' schemes with flawed strategies which seemed ''good'' for them at first sight.

In summary, it is not about ''ego'' or ''trolling'' or ''bashing'', but it is a ''public service'' for less experienced traders, and any critique from us is open for discussion.


 Congrats on being Captin save a margin call, but don't you find it ironic that you are saving people from the same thing you continuously experience? lol When was the last time you made a withdrawal. You post more then you trade and talk about VOUCH scores as if it can be converted to something worth anything.

My avatar explains "social trading" perfectly.
주제가 잠겼습니다