เพื่อใช้การแชท โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบ
กลับไปที่รายชื่อ

FXCM คะแนนรีวิว


คะแนนรวม: 3.5 / 5

คะแนนโหวตทั้งหมด: 332
แพลตฟอร์ม
1
ราคา
1
บริการลูกค้า
1
คุณสมบัติ
1
1 - แย่ที่สุด 5 - ดีที่สุด

FXCM การสนทนา

Michael N Chin (reddragontrader)
Nov 18 2014 at 08:17
1 โพสต์
ggjr61 posted:
Execllent customer service. Too many requotes - but that is mostly likely due to ECN model. Taking MT4 platform offline on Sundays is a little bit of a headache. But I think this is the best broker in the market.


I see a lot of mixed reviews here for FXCM. I don't know about how they were like before today. However, I feel they are the best by far that I have used and the lowest spreads I've ever seen. They recently started a new fee schedule but it's negligible overall and still way cheap either way you slice it against other brokers. Also, the simplest and most straightforward forex-only platform in my opinion. Customer Service is Excellent!

wilsonolivos
Nov 04 2014 at 19:48
3 โพสต์
This broker has helped me to earn money with my strategy.

Mario (medisoft)
Oct 03 2014 at 00:03
21 โพสต์
The broker has good customer service (fast response), fairly good deposit methods, but is horrible for withdrawals. If you don't live on US or have big bucks (10,000 or more), it is very expensive to withdraw.

The only two methods are credit card (limited amount), and wire transfer (expensive!)

Also, I had a problem with them. I placed two orders on different pairs, at some point the trades were closed... not with stop, not with take profits... they couldn't tell me why they were closed (they were closed on profit), and when I talked to them about the problem, the decided unilaterally to 'reopen the trades' just at the same price they were closed. I didn't asked that, I only asked why they were closed.

Finally I closed the trades again with a little less profit, and I tryied to withdraw my funds (only 116 usd)... with the surprise that I can only withdraw 50 usd using my CC (the same I used to fund my account), the rest I must use wire transfer (with 35USD fee or more)


David Masaryk (D3M0115H3R)
May 16 2014 at 02:18
2 โพสต์
Is anyone trading the indices with FXCM? especially German DAX ? Need some feedback from live trading...
I'm trading only on the demo acc, and sometimes is there huge difference between live and demo trading.

So, if is somebody trading DAX30, pls let me know, or write here some info :) THANKS.

Irishmist
Jan 14 2014 at 22:02
136 โพสต์
I have been trading actively with FXCM for the past 4 months although I have been on & of with this broker since 1999. Spreads are awesome on the AUD/NZD, AUD/USD & NZD/USD. Swaps are very fair. Slippage is minimal now that I use Beeksfx which has its VPS location at Equinix NY data center where FXCM hosts its MT4 servers.

The customer support is unprecedented as they will attend to any problem regardless how small it is & they will see that it is resolved

I am about to increase my level of investment with this broker as I know my funds are safe with the largest FX Broker on the planet.

I only hope that they will drop the spread on the Eur/USD.

Overall I rate this broker as 8 out of 10


Mevoila
Dec 13 2013 at 15:33
1 โพสต์
I opened an active trader account by this broker. I agreed for an account with commissions (and lower spreads). Costs were to be 60 USD for 1 Million USD traded. But my account is in EUR. They then decided that costs would be 60 EUR for 1 Million EUR traded. I agreed. I then noticed that costs were actually 60 EUR for 1 Million USD traded (I only trade GBP/USD). I complained. They then explained to me that costs would be 60 EUR per Million, it would not matter if it would be 1 Million EUR, 1 Million YEN, 1 Million EUR, AUD... and so on. I refused. They then offered that costs become 50 EUR per Million of XXX. I accepted. But they went on withdrawing 60 EUR per Million !!! I complained and claimed for reimoursement. They refused and explained that changing my tarification would require time, without precision. I fill totally laught and scammed, so I closed the account.
FXCM ARE SCAMMERS

unholy_ghost
Oct 18 2013 at 17:58
10 โพสต์
read my response to halalfx to find out why i never experience any fu%@ing slippage with my 2 brokers.

BUT you don't have to believe me. just do what i did: fu$#ing try them out and find out for yourself. do your due diligence and start trading with institutional execution performance.



HeikinAshi posted:
I you like 50/80 pips slippage on EURUSD with the excuse that 'there was not enough liquidity' (seriously, they told me not enough liquidity on EURUSD...), this broker is for you. Happened to me a good number of times, not just once or twice.

The TradingStation is quite good, but very unstable. Often you'll get a bugged out candle with a 900 pip wick, so if you use kumo it messes it up.

Contrary to what was said earlier, I have bad experience with their customer service. Always making excuses regarding slippage, and even about stop loss that was hit while price action was 10 pips away from the stop (happened twice, and I checked price action on other brokers too to be sure).

Their real strength is DailyFX, but really you'd better run away from them.

unholy_ghost
Oct 18 2013 at 17:56
10 โพสต์
halalfx

what they told you is pure BS. just as Kazuya Mishima says, it appears that FXCM is still up to their dirty old tricks.

bottom line: this is NOT NORMAL and there is no justification whatsoever for this kind of terrible execution to occur.

the brokers i use are: LMAX and RJOBrien (UK) AND--let me write this in capital letters so that it finally dawns on all of you who are reading this--NEVER DO I EXPERIENCE ANY SUCH ISSUES BECAUSE I GET INSTUTIONAL GRADE EXECUTION QUALITY.

is it starting to sink in?

furthermore, i used to trade from asia, so quite far from their servers at Equinix in NY/London and guess what... was my execution speed slow, sluggish, unresponsive? NOT! it was the fastest order execution (market orders) i ever had experienced.

i can't say it enough: these 2 are by far the better brokers out there. WHY? because there never is any issue, customer service is top notch and they never feed you any BS. EVER!

bottom line, you can concentrate on trading, on what matters, without having to worry about spikes, will your order be executed fast enough without slippage, etc... and isn't it that what we all want from our brokers?

if the answer is 'yes', then you know what you should do at this point --> switch to a broker that will give the quality of execution you want, just like i did after getting bamboozled by most retail brokers out there.

it's up to you in the end.

and for god's sake, do yourself a favor: STOP USING MT4--it's a POS!

there is so much better software out there that will let you connect via FIX to the servers of the 2 brokers i just mentioned: for ex you have Sierra Charts and even better, MotiveWave. compare the latter to MT4 and you should finally realize that as long as you use MT4 you are just dicking around and asking for trouble.

anyway, like i said, you need to up your game.

best of luck.

halalfx posted:
Peace for all..Just some updates about fxcm..I already breakeven with them..now I am trading on profits..thank GOD :-) so I contact the customer service about my account history that is not accurate..as some history are missing..they said it was on purpose on the MT4 so as to improve the speed..what??

Kinda weird because my other brokers never delete some history just to improve the speed. Oh well, I still can access my history from myfxcm portal but since many performance monitoring sites, like myfxbook, fxstat, etc use direct feed from MT4...trying to monitor that account now via these sites would be inaccurate.

So I have deleted fxcm from my portfolio until I figure out how to get the performance straight.

GOD Bless
HalalPips

Abdul H. Jaffar (halalfx)
Oct 18 2013 at 16:49
10 โพสต์
Peace for all..Just some updates about fxcm..I already breakeven with them..now I am trading on profits..thank GOD :-) so I contact the customer service about my account history that is not accurate..as some history are missing..they said it was on purpose on the MT4 so as to improve the speed..what??

Kinda weird because my other brokers never delete some history just to improve the speed. Oh well, I still can access my history from myfxcm portal but since many performance monitoring sites, like myfxbook, fxstat, etc use direct feed from MT4...trying to monitor that account now via these sites would be inaccurate.

So I have deleted fxcm from my portfolio until I figure out how to get the performance straight.

GOD Bless
HalalPips

I trade where the opportunities are and I take what is given
Kazuya Mishima
HeikinAshi
Oct 18 2013 at 08:17
1 โพสต์
I you like 50/80 pips slippage on EURUSD with the excuse that 'there was not enough liquidity' (seriously, they told me not enough liquidity on EURUSD...), this broker is for you. Happened to me a good number of times, not just once or twice.

The TradingStation is quite good, but very unstable. Often you'll get a bugged out candle with a 900 pip wick, so if you use kumo it messes it up.

Contrary to what was said earlier, I have bad experience with their customer service. Always making excuses regarding slippage, and even about stop loss that was hit while price action was 10 pips away from the stop (happened twice, and I checked price action on other brokers too to be sure).

Their real strength is DailyFX, but really you'd better run away from them.

โปรดเข้าสู่ระบบเพื่อแสดงความคิดเห็น
Compare Forex spreads in real time สเปรดฟอเร็กซ์