Haitrader's Посты - Страница 2

Victor in Торговые системы May 22, 2011 at 10:28

I always wondering about such threads: Mr. Lee does so much effort to clarify all confusing issues and to explain how honest and sucessful they are.I have no idea, who speak the truth, but I have always the same question:If somebody is so sucessful in trading, why he is not able to open an 10000 USD real account, trade his strategy and publish the investor password? So everybody could analyze the trade history and make sure that the trades and the development of the balance is true and not manipulated.But nearly nobody who has to sell something, want to do it. It' curious, isn't it?

10USDto1K_USD in Торговые системы May 22, 2011 at 09:55

You can forget such an EA, if it is an EA? Why?.......... 362 trades with 2.39 pips per trade win ... with a 608 $ account. The average lot size is 0.6 ..... so 1 trade which goes 100 pips in the wrong direction will blow up the account...... that's not trading, that's gambleing !

dbFX Real in Торговые системы May 21, 2011 at 12:12

I don't know both of you, but one point is at least worth to think about: you have no public real acccount here and your demo accounts are less than one month old and , let me call it, not very promising.To show sucess, the only way is to show a real account, demo accounts say nothing about trading success, they help to develop a good strategy but most demo accounts which are shown here, will fail under real conditions.So it is very easy: show Solar a real account which is at least 2 months old, with a balance of more than 1000 USD andevrybody will know, who speak the truth !

dbFX Real in Торговые системы May 21, 2011 at 08:21

"Arguing with you is completely pointless" ........ and then you start arguing........ LOL .......it is really difficult for me to decide what's more bullshit: your trading system or your posts 😲

dbFX Real in Торговые системы May 20, 2011 at 17:34

You disregard the main point: all can accept critic, by people which show experience and sucessful trading. It's like in a job, respect is created by sucess ..... you only shout without showng us your sucess.... but I understand, you are too sucessful and therefore therefore there is no need for a proof ... I like people with such a huge ego

dbFX Real in Торговые системы May 20, 2011 at 16:00

You definitely see enough in the system stats...... best trades, worst trades, win/loss ratio....... the system is worthless without any chance for sucess..... surprising, that he has always critcial remarks on other systems (i.e FGB) or traders... where is the consistency about which he is talking ?

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 17, 2011 at 17:10

Although I sometimes complain about the strange behaviour of FGB.......today no trades

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 17, 2011 at 04:37

One point is true: if FGB-team wins the other users of FGB are also in win, but only for these actual trades.For example: regarding all trades, which were closed by FG on 05/16 FGB-team had a loss of 121.5 pips, my account had a loss of 209.4. Small difference of 87.9 pips in one day !The FGB-team wins in April in total 177 % which sounds huge, which is 440.6 pips. That means if you have only 5 days in a month like the 05/16 your earning is 0 pips compared to 440.6 pips in the same month.Beside this, perhaps you can explain me:1. Why the entries were always nearly the same as by the FGB-team,...

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 16, 2011 at 17:35

You are right, complete different exits, my loss -178 pips

Catch the loss in Торговые системы May 16, 2011 at 09:42

That''s my very new system. It is whether a martingale nor grid system. Every trade has an external (safety) stoploss (200 pips) and an internal stoploss which is much nearer as well as a trailing stop.Based on several very positive backtests I have started demo today. The target is at least 10% return/month based on 10.000 Euro account with a DD less than 5%. It is the evolution of my EA which runs on ny real account "freedom" since 24/04.

PC_E_U_Max_OCM_Mod1daa_GT1 in Торговые системы May 15, 2011 at 12:16

Is this EA really worth to discuss?With a deposit of more than 300.000 USD and a trading lot size of 0.1 Lot for the first trade in a grid/martingale system, how clever the EA has to be ? Imagine with this system you need 30.000 USD to trade 0.01 lot ! But I agree, that there is no reason to sell this EA. Better to take the free available Indo EA (also grid/martingale) and you will have similiar results.

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 14, 2011 at 16:18

that's what I Say: 709 pips from 6 April ....... and my 399 pips from24 April .....that's the truth

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 14, 2011 at 10:07

Not without manual interventions or stop system:my Alpari UK Real 1:500 ..............no intervention........ pure FGB ...... 34 Trades :+ 399.5 pips ........ that is definitely the truth

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 14, 2011 at 09:50

I agree with you, that no bot is perfect, like human traders. Everything is a question of probabilities ...... in forex trading ..... as well as poker for example. The challenge for a bot is to filter out opportunities which have bigger chances to win as to loose. And that is what FGB try do do, it try to detect reliable breakouts. And such breakout-systems needs volatility and FGB has good capabilities to detect them. But ....... to measure the strength of the breakout and to detect the loss of strength is quite poor in FGB, that means the exits are often too late. And this has for my opinio...

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 13, 2011 at 05:21

I'm also on Alpari UK real and demo account. And you are right, the entrys are nearly the same and also the exits, but for my opinion FGB did a big mistake in regard to confidence, beause they closed the trades manually yesterday with a big profit, but the EA closed by itself 4 trades with a total loss of -173.8 pips.And I'm still waiting for a explanation from the FGB-Team here !

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 13, 2011 at 04:50

The explanation of FGB is definitely wrong. The slave of a signalcopy master EA can never close earlier than the master. Why? Because it got no signal from the master. The slave read continously the list of the trades of the master and adapt his own trades. Your account has nothing to do, when your trades were closed earlier. It is always the action on the master account.Only a later closing could be possible, in some cases, like " trade context is busy", requotes etc.

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 12, 2011 at 17:53

It is very curious and now I'm pretty sure that the FGB-Team close trades manually. I have always nearly the same openings but sometimes as today complete diffenrent closings. The FGB-team ended in profit in huge profit, my trades ended in huge losses.And exactly this is the problem of the EA. The entries are quite good.....but the closings are often awful ! For my opinion it is nthing bad to close the trades manually, but they should communicate the weak point of the EA and encourage the customers also to close the trades manually.

Forex Growth Bot in Торговые системы May 10, 2011 at 17:54

FXdome,in theory it works when you put Kenny's EA on a second start (Kenny's EA is very good), but of course you create a conflict with FGB.If the trade is closed by Kenny's EA, FGB doesn't see this. FGB is still thinking, that the trade is going on. The consequence is that you have to restart the FGB after each hit of Kenny's EA.You can do this if you are allways in front of your screen, but you cannot leave FGB alone any longer. So be cautious, if you want to test FGB and trailing stop EA on real account.

[email protected] in Торговые системы May 08, 2011 at 11:50

as forcasted.... account deleted

FGT-Real01 in Торговые системы May 08, 2011 at 11:41

The result for a real account looks quite impressive, but let's take a closer look on the performance of the FGT-EA:the deposit is: 152577 $ the EA started at 05/24/2010the earning up to now is: 30981 $The Gold price on 05/24/2010 was 1182 and today 1495 that means a difference of 3130 pips !1 pip = 10 $ for one lot that means with only 1 Lot bought at 05/24/2010 I would be up 31300 $ today without any EA.And with an account of more than 150 K$ I could trade more than 1 Lot without any risk.Please correct me, if I'm wrong.

EURUSD	1.07599	GBPUSD	1.25452	AUDUSD	0.66091
USDJPY	153.053	USDCAD	1.3685	USDCHF	0.90475

Сообщения от Haitrader