Group by magic numbers Önerisi | Myfxbook’ın Forex Forumu

Oct 25, 2010 zamanından beri üye 6 iletiler

Nov 02, 2010 at 17:34

Oct 25, 2010 zamanından beri üye 6 iletiler

We have a system that has several optimizations, but each optimization trades by it's own magic number. So basically, it's all the same system, but there are 10 different magic numbers. (There's actually several strategies, each with multiple optimizations. So it's hard to see how profitable each trading strategy is)

Would it be possible to create a 'Magic Group', and define which magic numbers are in that group, and then be able to see performance for that group?

fpuschmann

Oct 09, 2010 zamanından beri üye 56 iletiler

Nov 02, 2010 at 17:39

Oct 09, 2010 zamanından beri üye 56 iletiler

nice idea

bkesic

Nov 02, 2010 zamanından beri üye 2 iletiler

Nov 02, 2010 at 17:56

Nov 02, 2010 zamanından beri üye 2 iletiler

I would also have benefit from this feature

Siitari

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

Nov 11, 2010 at 06:56

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

A must.

Less effort, better results.

Siitari

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

Dec 09, 2010 at 12:19

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

Bumb.

Grouping magic numbers would be a very good feature.

Less effort, better results.

GridsForPips

Jun 16, 2010 zamanından beri üye 205 iletiler

Dec 09, 2010 at 13:42

Jun 16, 2010 zamanından beri üye 205 iletiler

Isn't that just using 'Custom analysis' and choose the magicnumbers you want?

Cheers

Soeren

Always get cashback -

aj901512

Mar 07, 2010 zamanından beri üye 60 iletiler

Dec 09, 2010 at 16:01

Mar 07, 2010 zamanından beri üye 60 iletiler

GridsForPips posted:
Isn't that just using 'Custom analysis' and choose the magicnumbers you want?

Cheers

Soeren

No. I think he means combining several magics into one (group)...

aaa

Siitari

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

Dec 10, 2010 at 06:25 (Dec 10, 2010 at 06:26 düzenlendi)

Jul 21, 2010 zamanından beri üye 111 iletiler

aj90151 posted:

GridsForPips posted:
Isn't that just using 'Custom analysis' and choose the magicnumbers you want?

Cheers

Soeren

No. I think he means combining several magics into one (group)...

I presume this was exactly what was intended in the first post and that's how I meant it too. So instead of several magic numbers you have them all in one group and this group acts like one magic number. And you could make many groups.

That would be neat for portfolio trading and/or for a system that uses many magic numbers.

You could for example, if you have several different scalpers, group them all together to form a 'Scalpers' group(they could also be seen separately at the same time).

You could have an EA that uses several magic numbers and group them all together(especially useful in portfolio trading if you have several such EAs).
This way you could easily see the overall behavior/effectiveness/etc. of each EA.

Less effort, better results.

GridsForPips

Jun 16, 2010 zamanından beri üye 205 iletiler

Dec 10, 2010 at 09:52

Jun 16, 2010 zamanından beri üye 205 iletiler

Then this one's got my vote 😄

Cheers

Soeren

Always get cashback -

someguy

Aug 10, 2009 zamanından beri üye 33 iletiler

Dec 10, 2010 at 14:41

Aug 10, 2009 zamanından beri üye 33 iletiler

Just had to check, this was actually part of my original suggestion to implement analysis of magicnumbers way back in August 2009. I also suggested, then, that there should be way to see performance per magicnumber that haven't been properly implemented yet. You still have to select every magicnumber one after one and write down their gained pips and so on in a excel sheet to do proper comparisons.

https://www.myfxbook.com/community/suggestion-box/filtering-trades-magicnumber-for-mt4/219,1

Never interfere manually in trades by a automated system