Advertisement
sPhantom Auto Trader (tarafından sPhantom)
| Kazanma : | +694.0% |
| Düşüş | 91.94% |
| Pipler: | 1266.4 |
| Tradeler | 261 |
| Kazandı: |
|
| Kaybetti: |
|
| Tür: | Gerçek |
| Kaldıraç: | 1:400 |
| Trading: | Otomatik |
sPhantom Auto Trader Tartışma
Aug 20, 2011 zamanından beri üye
587 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 21:39
UncleSteve posted:
wow, not so hot today...
wait and see before complaining...
and again... if you are so smart to know the trade was opened in the wrong direction... why did you need an EA?
:)
Sep 23, 2013 zamanından beri üye
45 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 21:47
borncorp posted:
Does anybody know why I am missing one of the current trades?
at the moment, I'd be just as glad...
"Press On" has solved and will always solve, the problems of the Human Race
Sep 23, 2013 zamanından beri üye
45 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 21:48
Actually I retract that, it seems to be turning around...
"Press On" has solved and will always solve, the problems of the Human Race
Jun 03, 2013 zamanından beri üye
79 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 21:48
borncorp posted:
Does anybody know why I am missing one of the current trades? I am using IBFX on the US with risk 20.
Sphantom: http://imgur.com/ihJndIk,skjGYSC#1
Mine: http://imgur.com/ihJndIk,skjGYSC
I have emailed them before, they recommended IBFX AU, FXCM & Fxpro only. I am using FXCM, it works well in demo and live.
Apr 13, 2011 zamanından beri üye
159 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 22:52
Hi Team,
First time poster.. Thought its about time we had a chat about brokers.. Is anyone monitoring the open/close prices of the trades? I am using the same broker as Sphantom and prices are off by up to 2 pips.. VPS is with CNS and has low latency.
I see a few of us experienced a small loss today.. mine is solely due to late opening and closing short of the TP
any other comments? anyone make small profit today?
Nick
First time poster.. Thought its about time we had a chat about brokers.. Is anyone monitoring the open/close prices of the trades? I am using the same broker as Sphantom and prices are off by up to 2 pips.. VPS is with CNS and has low latency.
I see a few of us experienced a small loss today.. mine is solely due to late opening and closing short of the TP
any other comments? anyone make small profit today?
Nick
Aug 20, 2011 zamanından beri üye
587 iletiler
Jan 16, 2014 at 23:04
I'm break even today. (well tiny profit)
Mar 15, 2010 zamanından beri üye
30 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 00:09
NikX posted:
Hi Team,
First time poster.. Thought its about time we had a chat about brokers.. Is anyone monitoring the open/close prices of the trades? I am using the same broker as Sphantom and prices are off by up to 2 pips.. VPS is with CNS and has low latency.
I see a few of us experienced a small loss today.. mine is solely due to late opening and closing short of the TP
any other comments? anyone make small profit today?
Nick
I'm also using the same broker and the same VPS as you. And I also ended with some losses on the second trade. This is the first time it has happened though. In the past, the second trade has always ended up with more profit than the first.
To get rich by consistent and safe means...
Jul 20, 2012 zamanından beri üye
87 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 01:56
I had a loss, but not the sPhantom EA's fault. I was using a trailing stop EA that couldn't handle the two negative trades together. Needless to say, I have removed the stoploss EA.
"Risk means more things can happen than will happen."
Aug 20, 2011 zamanından beri üye
587 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 02:08
Anubis posted:
I had a loss, but not the sPhantom EA's fault. I was using a trailing stop EA that couldn't handle the two negative trades together. Needless to say, I have removed the stoploss EA.
always a bad idea to interfere with an EA.
Apr 13, 2011 zamanından beri üye
159 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 04:56
therichonedemo1 posted:NikX posted:
Hi Team,
First time poster.. Thought its about time we had a chat about brokers.. Is anyone monitoring the open/close prices of the trades? I am using the same broker as Sphantom and prices are off by up to 2 pips.. VPS is with CNS and has low latency.
I see a few of us experienced a small loss today.. mine is solely due to late opening and closing short of the TP
any other comments? anyone make small profit today?
Nick
I'm also using the same broker and the same VPS as you. And I also ended with some losses on the second trade. This is the first time it has happened though. In the past, the second trade has always ended up with more profit than the first.
Right so heres what i Found apon examining the charts.. Please note I am looking into the difference in brokers.
Sphantom IBFX account closed out 21pips so far this month
My IBFX account closed out 16.8 pips
vantage FX closed 19.9
IBFX AU (myfxbook) 15.8
Roboforex (myfxbook) 20.9
Hot Forex (myfxbook) 18.9
XM (myfxbook) 18.7
Traders way (myfxbook) 18.1
xm (myfxbook) 17.4
thats just the first few i looked at, obviously we have to think about VPS also but IBFX is by far the bottom of the pile. I have a vantage account so will be switching over next week to see what happens!
Mar 15, 2010 zamanından beri üye
30 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 05:45
Sphantom IBFX account closed out 21pips so far this month
My IBFX account closed out 16.8 pips
vantage FX closed 19.9
IBFX AU (myfxbook) 15.8
Roboforex (myfxbook) 20.9
Hot Forex (myfxbook) 18.9
XM (myfxbook) 18.7
Traders way (myfxbook) 18.1
xm (myfxbook) 17.4
thats just the first few i looked at, obviously we have to think about VPS also but IBFX is by far the bottom of the pile. I have a vantage account so will be switching over next week to see what happens!
From their Myfxbook, their account has closed with 7 trades and 50 pips. Where did you get those numbers from?
My IBFX account closed out 16.8 pips
vantage FX closed 19.9
IBFX AU (myfxbook) 15.8
Roboforex (myfxbook) 20.9
Hot Forex (myfxbook) 18.9
XM (myfxbook) 18.7
Traders way (myfxbook) 18.1
xm (myfxbook) 17.4
thats just the first few i looked at, obviously we have to think about VPS also but IBFX is by far the bottom of the pile. I have a vantage account so will be switching over next week to see what happens!
From their Myfxbook, their account has closed with 7 trades and 50 pips. Where did you get those numbers from?
To get rich by consistent and safe means...
Apr 13, 2011 zamanından beri üye
159 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 05:47
therichonedemo1 posted:
Sphantom IBFX account closed out 21pips so far this month
My IBFX account closed out 16.8 pips
vantage FX closed 19.9
IBFX AU (myfxbook) 15.8
Roboforex (myfxbook) 20.9
Hot Forex (myfxbook) 18.9
XM (myfxbook) 18.7
Traders way (myfxbook) 18.1
xm (myfxbook) 17.4
thats just the first few i looked at, obviously we have to think about VPS also but IBFX is by far the bottom of the pile. I have a vantage account so will be switching over next week to see what happens!
From their Myfxbook, their account has closed with 7 trades and 50 pips. Where did you get those numbers from?
Sorry Guys.. THIS WEEK!!!
Mar 15, 2010 zamanından beri üye
30 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 07:58
Yea my account has only made 17.2 pips this week.
To get rich by consistent and safe means...
Jan 16, 2014 zamanından beri üye
14 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:11
Does sPhantom close both trades when the one below reaches the TP?
Jan 16, 2014 zamanından beri üye
14 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:11
It;s very tempting to close them manually after they break even / small loss. What do you think / do?
Jan 27, 2013 zamanından beri üye
427 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:11
My trades were closed for a small profit, just little bit above break even, but official link of sPhantom from myfxbook still have the trades open. I have the Hide_TP_SL=true, maybe this was the reason.
Jan 16, 2014 zamanından beri üye
14 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:11
HAHA, sPhantom closed both at exactly break even (at least for my account) :).
Happy with the result, could be worse.
I user RoboForex ECN Pro account - great conditions.
And I'm not affiliated with them :) (I know I just created my account today, thanks for reminding me. People have to start posting from somewhere :) ).
Regards,
Alex :)
Happy with the result, could be worse.
I user RoboForex ECN Pro account - great conditions.
And I'm not affiliated with them :) (I know I just created my account today, thanks for reminding me. People have to start posting from somewhere :) ).
Regards,
Alex :)
Sep 23, 2013 zamanından beri üye
45 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:12
willgart posted:UncleSteve posted:
wow, not so hot today...
wait and see before complaining...
and again... if you are so smart to know the trade was opened in the wrong direction... why did you need an EA?
:)
You got the wrong guy.
I said "not so hot" and it wasn't so hot.
It was someone else a few posts ago who said it was in the wrong direction. I have no such knowledge. EURUSD H1 looks like an inscrutable dog's breakfast to me.
"Press On" has solved and will always solve, the problems of the Human Race
Oct 22, 2013 zamanından beri üye
11 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:12
Well, the thing is that whenever SPhantom opens 2 trades they end up being one bad and one good. My account with IBFX US only opens 1 trade and it ends up being the bad one. Where the hell can I get a US broker that is compatible with this EA? Anybody with a US account had both trades executed succesfully?
forex_trader_172269
Jan 16, 2014 zamanından beri üye
1 iletiler
Jan 17, 2014 at 08:12
It would be nice if sPhantom would share some insight about the recent trade. I'm fairly new to forex and trade myself only on demo account. Thats why I use sPhantom while learning and been very happy with my decision. Few things I've noticed today while looking at the charts (see attached):
Market tested 38.2% Fibbonaci resistance level which held and later on formed a bearish hammer. From my personal knowledge this candle stick signals to short your positions. Next candle stick moved rapidly towards resistance and once hit a trade was opened. Most of the time rapid movement signals a spike. Cause at that time we knew already that resistance held the first time.
Please do not get me in a wrong way. I'm just trying to understand why bearish hammer was ignored and 38.2% fibbonaci level not taken in to consideration.
I have to say well guessed when to close both trades sPhantom!
Market tested 38.2% Fibbonaci resistance level which held and later on formed a bearish hammer. From my personal knowledge this candle stick signals to short your positions. Next candle stick moved rapidly towards resistance and once hit a trade was opened. Most of the time rapid movement signals a spike. Cause at that time we knew already that resistance held the first time.
Please do not get me in a wrong way. I'm just trying to understand why bearish hammer was ignored and 38.2% fibbonaci level not taken in to consideration.
I have to say well guessed when to close both trades sPhantom!
