Discusión Caesar@IcMarkets

Jussi_Jantti posted:
What has happened today morning? I do follow your system on two accounts, on two different brokers. Both had the same error: after closing the position several trades were opened and closed immideately, which of course ment losses. It is not about a broker or server - so it must come from your end sending the signals?

Good you please give an explination.
Besides, the positions were close on loss when your position was clearly on profit.

Which way you follow this system?

Check this for this problem
https://blog.simpletrader.net/caesar2-multiple-trades/

togr posted:

Jussi_Jantti posted:
What has happened today morning? I do follow your system on two accounts, on two different brokers. Both had the same error: after closing the position several trades were opened and closed immideately, which of course ment losses. It is not about a broker or server - so it must come from your end sending the signals?

Good you please give an explination.
Besides, the positions were close on loss when your position was clearly on profit.

Which way you follow this system?

Your signal copier is not working. I wrote to support and there is no help!!
Simple trader copier is hroble!! If you give contract to provider service for copying signal, I have a great system which copying 1000 customers in instance with very nominal fee per customer.
Regards,
Dhiraj

Your signal copier is not working. I wrote to support and there is no help!!
Simple trader copier is hroble!! If you give contract to provider service for copying signal, I have a great system which copying 1000 customers in instance with very nominal fee per customer.
Regards,
Dhiraj

as the guys behind connectforex.com are not responsible for performance and apparently can't do anything about slippage issues, we have to communicate to the trader directly. So here is my feedback:
horrible execution. i cancel my subscription now. There is not ONE broker except RVD(could be demo) in the members area executing Caesar 2 trades without constantly negative slippage (difference between master and my slave).

15/09/2014 C2@ICM Master:
13 trades
+21.2pip

my FxPIG ECN + BeeksFx NY4:
13 trades
-58.7pip
-79.9pip slippage

people don't understand that giving away their master password for being a private sub is a severe security risk. i hope you all sleep well at night

I don't understand what you are saying... on connectforex I use EA so I don't need to give my password. Slippage is acceptable for me.

bmigette posted:
I don't understand what you are saying... on connectforex I use EA so I don't need to give my password. Slippage is acceptable for me.

connectforex is fine. i talked about being a private sub on Caesar VPS with the 33% profit share. post edited

dhiraj posted:

togr posted:

Jussi_Jantti posted:
What has happened today morning? I do follow your system on two accounts, on two different brokers. Both had the same error: after closing the position several trades were opened and closed immideately, which of course ment losses. It is not about a broker or server - so it must come from your end sending the signals?

Good you please give an explination.
Besides, the positions were close on loss when your position was clearly on profit.

Which way you follow this system?

Your signal copier is not working. I wrote to support and there is no help!!
Simple trader copier is hroble!! If you give contract to provider service for copying signal, I have a great system which copying 1000 customers in instance with very nominal fee per customer.
Regards,
Dhiraj

My signal copier is working. You are personally using it. That's enough I am disconnecting you.
You perhaps wanted to say simpletrader copier had an issue.

dhiraj posted:
Your signal copier is not working. I wrote to support and there is no help!!
Simple trader copier is hroble!! If you give contract to provider service for copying signal, I have a great system which copying 1000 customers in instance with very nominal fee per customer.
Regards,
Dhiraj

That simpletrader issue stop spamming MFB forum OMG

cyberryder posted:
people don't understand that giving away their master password for being a private sub is a severe security risk. i hope you all sleep well at night

Yes it might be a problem to give password to you.

None of my followers have ever issue with this. You are not one of them so go spam elsewhere.

i've no more else to share. i'll be quiet now 😉

togr posted:

dhiraj posted:
Your signal copier is not working. I wrote to support and there is no help!!
Simple trader copier is hroble!! If you give contract to provider service for copying signal, I have a great system which copying 1000 customers in instance with very nominal fee per customer.
Regards,
Dhiraj

That simpletrader issue stop spamming MFB forum OMG

Dear All readers,
I would like to clarify on my previous comments in this forum. My comments were solely on the copier technology of simple trader and not on Von's trading system. I am very happy with his excellent trading and I am admirer of him and recommended him to my friends to follow him. If any one is offended with my comments, then I am very extremely sorry for that and ready to take any punishment you want. I do not want to harm anyone.

Von has helped me for very quick response and resolving the issue and he gave more help than any one else in the current traders in the forum.

best Regards,
Dhiraj

cyberryder posted:
people don't understand that giving away their master password for being a private sub is a severe security risk. i hope you all sleep well at night

This makes no sense. Having master password allows signal provider to trade your account. However signal provider can't withdraw your money. So where is the risk?

Slippage is part of the cost of signal copying. BTW my slippage is almost zero and I don't have private sub.

Nice work Tomas. Ignore the Trolls.

Thanks a lot Phil.
It seems to be very human nature to spit on everything shiny;)

FxPhil posted:

cyberryder posted:
people don't understand that giving away their master password for being a private sub is a severe security risk. i hope you all sleep well at night

This makes no sense. Having master password allows signal provider to trade your account. However signal provider can't withdraw your money. So where is the risk?

Slippage is part of the cost of signal copying. BTW my slippage is almost zero and I don't have private sub.

Nice work Tomas. Ignore the Trolls.

Hi FxPhil.

What broker and VPS are you using for the signal copying..?

Thanks to inform

regards

Ahmed

ahmedfouad posted:

FxPhil posted:

cyberryder posted:
people don't understand that giving away their master password for being a private sub is a severe security risk. i hope you all sleep well at night

This makes no sense. Having master password allows signal provider to trade your account. However signal provider can't withdraw your money. So where is the risk?

Slippage is part of the cost of signal copying. BTW my slippage is almost zero and I don't have private sub.

Nice work Tomas. Ignore the Trolls.

Hi FxPhil.

What broker and VPS are you using for the signal copying..?

Thanks to inform

regards

Ahmed

There are 2 sources of slippage. 1: Price slippage due to lack of sufficient broker liquidity at close time causing the close price to slip down the brokers book even if no time/tick slippage has occurred. Tomas's many private sub accounts show that broker price slippage not an issue with ICMarkets. 2: Time/tick slippage between master closing tick and slave receiving the close signal & closing on the next tick. While a good VPS will reduce this time/tick slippage, normally VPS delay is not significant. My testing shows the signal copier service is where most time/tick slippage occurs.

With a good combo it is possible to get averaged basket pip gains that are very close to the master's gain. Simplest way to avoid losing money to either of rhe 2 possible sources of slips is to let Tomas do it as then you make money, which is the goal. Right?

Should add 3rd source. 3: Broker's price feed is not the same as ICMarkets. 4: Broker's spread is wider than ICMarkets. Believe these last 2 can be a major cause as ICMarkets EURUSD spread is tightest I know. If your broker has wider spreads, then your observed slippage may be just that brokers wider spread or their different price feed.

The biggest problem with ST slippage is the Basket CLosure functionality built within MT4... It doesn't exist

MT4 limits 1 closure at a time. * 1 broker request at a time. The fact that a Trade Copier Server tries to sync each trade doesn't work for Grid Baskets.

We honestly need ST to add a feature for Grid traders to Send only 1 signal to the Follower to Close the whole basket instead of trying to sync each individual trade with the master account when it liquidates the whole basket. Reports of 5+ second delays or more because of this problem.

@FxPhil is your ClosureEA4Caesar working? I imagined you would have to remove the ST EA on the first trade closed. PM if you like.

@togr It is truly unacceptable how successful traders are treated on any FX site.