Does anyone use EA/robot to trade ?

Aug 26 at 05:11
234 개의 뷰
20 Replies
Dec 19, 2020 부터 멤버   게시물1
Aug 26 at 05:11 (편집됨 Aug 26 at 03:30)

Does anyone use EA for trading? How effective is it? I use EA for trading, profit about 4-5%/month :((

Aug 19, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물6
Aug 26 at 11:40

Hi, I’m using an EA, and it’s bringing me over 200% a week.

Precision. Discipline. Results.
May 08, 2020 부터 멤버   게시물2
Aug 28 at 09:25
harrydoan posted:

Does anyone use EA for trading? How effective is it? I use EA for trading, profit about 4-5%/month :((


4-5% per month is good if you can do it consistently. Minimal 2 years. 

Jun 10, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물29
Aug 28 at 12:24

+1 to that. Whenever I evaluate an EA, I want 24+ months OOS with max DD capped; ‘200% a week’ usually reads like martingale or grid unless proven otherwise

Aug 22, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물1
Aug 29 at 08:52

does EA really work? 

Aug 19, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물6
Aug 29 at 11:41

Yes

Precision. Discipline. Results.
Apr 18, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물7
Aug 30 at 10:33
keelly posted:

does EA really work? 


Yes EA really work as long as the tests you're doing are relevant (backtest and forward test).This is what I'm doing with all my robots (EA) and result are good (monthly average about 100%) with a correct avg DD of 15% (Max DD 53%).

Smart trading starts with smart risk limits.
May 08, 2020 부터 멤버   게시물2
Aug 30 at 11:03
ChrisKoool posted:
keelly posted:

does EA really work? 


Yes EA really work as long as the tests you're doing are relevant (backtest and forward test).This is what I'm doing with all my robots (EA) and result are good (monthly average about 100%) with a correct avg DD of 15% (Max DD 53%).


Do you offer PAM service or copy trade?

Aug 18, 2019 부터 멤버   게시물99
Aug 30 at 11:11
mr_Douller posted:

Hi, I’m using an EA, and it’s bringing me over 200% a week.


200% a week? That’s wild. You must be halfway to your first trillion by now, right? Let us know when Forbes calls.

Adapt, analyze, and achieve — one trade at a time.
Apr 18, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물7
Aug 30 at 13:35
Slashes posted:
ChrisKoool posted:
keelly posted:

does EA really work? 


Yes EA really work as long as the tests you're doing are relevant (backtest and forward test).This is what I'm doing with all my robots (EA) and result are good (monthly average about 100%) with a correct avg DD of 15% (Max DD 53%).


Do you offer PAM service or copy trade?


Hello Slashes,


Yes copy-trading trading is allowed from https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ChrisKoool/vantage-2394/11551121Feel free to ask if any question.


Chris

Smart trading starts with smart risk limits.
Apr 18, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물7
Aug 30 at 13:38

Sorry, the link above is wrong.Here is the correct one : https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ChrisKoool/vantage-2394/11551121


Smart trading starts with smart risk limits.
Jan 26, 2015 부터 멤버   게시물37
Aug 30 at 13:52

Sure, I use my own EAs that run my strategies. I believe it is the best way to trade, because it makes reliable back testing possible. Frequent optimization and out-of-sample testing makes the reliability of a strategy so much higher.

"Markets are constantly in a state of uncertainty and flux and money is made by discounting the obvious and betting on the unexpected" - George Soros
Apr 18, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물7
Aug 31 at 08:58
Pupsik posted:

Sure, I use my own EAs that run my strategies. I believe it is the best way to trade, because it makes reliable back testing possible. Frequent optimization and out-of-sample testing makes the reliability of a strategy so much higher.


I totally agree @Pupsik.


Also when a strategy is not going exactly where we expect initially, we can easily figure out what happened and fix it to make it not happen again.

Smart trading starts with smart risk limits.
Aug 31, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물1
Aug 31 at 09:53

very correct

Aug 18, 2019 부터 멤버   게시물99
Aug 31 at 10:13
Slashes posted:
harrydoan posted:

Does anyone use EA for trading? How effective is it? I use EA for trading, profit about 4-5%/month :((


4-5% per month is good if you can do it consistently. Minimal 2 years. 


Exactly. 4-5% a month consistently is solid and far more realistic than those “200% a week” claims 😅


My signal is just like that. Been running since 2022. My EA trades XAUUSD exclusively, and over the last 3 months it’s gained about 18%. Over the last 12 months, it made exactly 100%. Overall gain is 911% - made over the course of 3.5 years.


Not flashy, but it proves that steady, disciplined trading with proper risk management really adds up over time, especially compared to unrealistic promises. My signal is available in my profile if anyone wants to view the stats or copy the trades directly—full transparency so you can check the performance before deciding to follow.


Adapt, analyze, and achieve — one trade at a time.
Jan 26, 2015 부터 멤버   게시물37
Sep 02 at 12:22
mr_Douller posted:

Hi, I’m using an EA, and it’s bringing me over 200% a week.


Inpressive! Is this a commercialy sold EA or one that you coded your self?

"Markets are constantly in a state of uncertainty and flux and money is made by discounting the obvious and betting on the unexpected" - George Soros
Sep 01, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물1
Sep 05 at 08:32

The discussion about EAs is fascinating! I use one for forex trading, averaging 3-4% monthly—steady but not spectacular. Curious about those 200% weekly claims, though! For learning more about EAs, I recommend checking out tutorials on Instagram. You can use i2mate.co to download those videos or audio for offline study. It’s a free, easy-to-use tool—just paste the instagram URL, choose your format, and download. Perfect for building a trading resource library!

Jun 10, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물29
Sep 05 at 09:19

Agreed, especially if you can show it over 24 months with low DD. Anyone claiming ‘200% a week’ should post a verified, track-record-connected system; otherwise, risk management says hard pass

Apr 18, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물7
Sep 05 at 10:20
ortellius posted:

Agreed, especially if you can show it over 24 months with low DD. Anyone claiming ‘200% a week’ should post a verified, track-record-connected system; otherwise, risk management says hard pass


I agree, high performance always means high risk !

Smart trading starts with smart risk limits.
Jul 28, 2025 부터 멤버   게시물9
Sep 05 at 21:51
harrydoan posted:

Does anyone use EA for trading? How effective is it? I use EA for trading, profit about 4-5%/month :((


EA is actually very good for trading because it helps you overcome your emotion s and get a full control but you must change your EA once a while. 

로그인 / 가입하기 to comment
You must be connected to Myfxbook in order to leave a comment
*상업적 사용 및 스팸은 허용되지 않으며 계정이 해지될 수 있습니다.
팁: 이미지/유튜브 URL을 게시하면 게시물에 자동으로 삽입됩니다!
팁: @기호를 입력하여 이 토론에 참여하는 사용자 이름을 자동으로 완성합니다.