Myfxbook Autotrade

ottawatrader posted:
Hi traders,

on Autotrade, did any use Ninjatrainer on live account? How were the results? The provider keeps adding deposits for one reason.
Thanks.

Ninjatrainer seems to be a PAMM account so it is expected a large amount of deposits and withdrawals. Currently, this provider is one of the best in profit. Because it has grown a lot in short time it could crash his account anytime like other providers did in the past.

Invest with care

Aimak posted:

ottawatrader posted:
Hi traders,

on Autotrade, did any use Ninjatrainer on live account? How were the results? The provider keeps adding deposits for one reason.
Thanks.

Ninjatrainer seems to be a PAMM account so it is expected a large amount of deposits and withdrawals. Currently, this provider is one of the best in profit. Because it has grown a lot in short time it could crash his account anytime like other providers did in the past.

Invest with care

Thanks Aimak. I wish fxbook would show the number of live account vs the no of subscribers.

For me Ninjatrainer was ok for the last month - most of his trades ended positive - only my Broker (BlackBull) its not the best for AT as my earnings from each trade are quite low. But I just check that and maybe change to a better Broker in some month.

Anyone know why Lucky Pond and Elite PAMM are no longer trading? Their last trade was around 25 April and nothing since then.

I was following Lucky Pound last year and he was doing okay but yeah seems he's not actively trading, but seems to be putting money in and out of his account.

I think we need more traders to be provider here. There are only 2 or 3 of them trading regularly.

arislan posted:
I think we need more traders to be provider here. There are only 2 or 3 of them trading regularly.

I second your suggestion. Doubling the number of providers would be very interesting.

arislan posted:
Anyone know why Lucky Pond and Elite PAMM are no longer trading? Their last trade was around 25 April and nothing since then.

The user name of behind Lucky Pound is warlock279

Searching in google results in some forums with recent posts from him but I cannot read Russian and the machine translation is not helping much.

Anyone can give me some opinion about Atlas trader? thanks

elsa85 posted:
Anyone can give me some opinion about Atlas trader? thanks

one of the best out there...no question there

yaw this works, gotta see why slippage is always in my favor in demo acc. Please share if you use it on real acc. Such good slippage for real?

rob559 posted:

elsa85 posted:
Anyone can give me some opinion about Atlas trader? thanks

one of the best out there...no question there

You think Atlas is good? I dont think so. Just look at his monthly profit vs max DD. The ratio is 1: 3.4 . Thats not even close to good for me. The only thing going in his favor is longevity of the account. His DD is over 10% about 20% of the time. He was doing pretty well and consistent until December 2016, since then results are all over the place. 3 months of 0% profit and one month 18% and DD constantly hovering in 5-10% range. Thats too up and down for me, I prefer more consistent performance with a better profit: DD ratio even if the profits are lower.

Hi guys and gals,

I tried searching the threads but couldn't find the answer to my question so apologiesi if this has already been answered.

I'm looking to become a provider on autotrade towards the end of the year but I'm still not sure what providers earn.

What would say someone with 10-20 subscribers earn compared to 100+ or at the higher end 1000-2000+ on a monthly basis?

Thanks in advance :)

Neel

neelpatel posted:
Hi guys and gals,

I tried searching the threads but couldn't find the answer to my question so apologiesi if this has already been answered.

I'm looking to become a provider on autotrade towards the end of the year but I'm still not sure what providers earn.

What would say someone with 10-20 subscribers earn compared to 100+ or at the higher end 1000-2000+ on a monthly basis?

Thanks in advance :)

Neel

Hey Neel,

AutoTrade FAQ section has an example scenario.

Read through this section of the forum to establish the mindset of an investor. There are many post with investors expressing what they are looking for in a system with which to invest. Your question suggests you are focusing to much on what you'll earn versus what it takes to draw in the real money.

Best Regards,

Greg

crazyinv posted:

rob559 posted:

elsa85 posted:
Anyone can give me some opinion about Atlas trader? thanks

one of the best out there...no question there

You think Atlas is good? I dont think so. Just look at his monthly profit vs max DD. The ratio is 1: 3.4 . Thats not even close to good for me. The only thing going in his favor is longevity of the account. His DD is over 10% about 20% of the time. He was doing pretty well and consistent until December 2016, since then results are all over the place. 3 months of 0% profit and one month 18% and DD constantly hovering in 5-10% range. Thats too up and down for me, I prefer more consistent performance with a better profit: DD ratio even if the profits are lower.

like martingale😀😀😀

OnTheEdge posted:

Hey Neel,

AutoTrade FAQ section has an example scenario.

Read through this section of the forum to establish the mindset of an investor. There are many post with investors expressing what they are looking for in a system with which to invest. Your question suggests you are focusing to much on what you'll earn versus what it takes to draw in the real money.

Best Regards,

Greg

Hi Greg,

Thanks for the advice. I've looked at the AutoTrade FAQ section and have briefly gone through the posts to see what investors are looking for from the systems. I appreciate that different investors have different risk appetites and requirements ( low drawdowns and a steady stable monthly return being at the top of the requirements) therefore these concerns have definately been at the forefront when it comes to fine tuning the EA :)

After seeing the example scenario in the AutoTrade FAQ I wanted to ask current providers what their experience has been as real world results can be very different to ideal scenarios.

Kind regards,
Neel

Can you limit symbols with autotrade? If I didn't want copy gold trades, is there a setting to turn that symbol off? SignalStart has these settings.

DAICON posted:
Can you limit symbols with autotrade? If I didn't want copy gold trades, is there a setting to turn that symbol off? SignalStart has these settings.

yes you can

Javenur posted:
Hi!
Myfxbook send me message - my account fits the criteria of AutoTrade program, now I can get rich, 'unlimited income with zero effort'
I read all FAQ, search in google, but can't find answer for my question - how myfxbook pay autotrade provaders?? Bank transfer or something like that available? My broker Alpari have not any Partnerships programm.

where is your system ?

i can't find it at auto trade section ?