MIDAS KASHIN 토론

aslan9 posted:
Vladimir, once again thank you for your PAMM account (for ability to earn with you). I have added about 30K. Hope, we will earn with you a lot of funds!

I will do my best, friends!

@aslan9

I don't usually comment on stuff here but I really felt compelled to comment out of dire concern. If you really did put money, a staggering $30,000 on Gainsy because you were convinced that this PAMM account of Vladimir can give you the returns you dream of, then I hope I'm wrong. But this 'Live' PAMM account is very very FISHY.

First there is already a SCAM warning about Gainsy - guess what's it about? They don't issue withdrawals. The complaints are coming from people who invested on certain PAMM accounts with an 'almost Perfect' track record. If this is true then it seems that Gainsy can fake account history so they can Scam people into opening live accounts and investing huge amounts. Then when it's time to trade, it doesn't really perform, and when it's time to withdraw, they don't issue withdrawals.

Don't you find it fishy that though everyone is saying that Vladimir should change broker, all he says that he's got good experience with Gainsy? A really serious professional trader wouldn't want to get too attached to a particular broker, much more a broker with Scam Warning.

If ever I'm wrong and if Vladimir is a legitimately great trader, the GREATEST I've ever seen actually after so many years on Forex Trading, then I mean no disrespect, but you really have to change broker dude! Then replicate your results on a Legit Broker.

I really hope my suspicions are unfounded for your sake @aslan9.

raeldc posted:
@aslan9

I don't usually comment on stuff here but I really felt compelled to comment out of dire concern. If you really did put money, a staggering $30,000 on Gainsy because you were convinced that this PAMM account of Vladimir can give you the returns you dream of, then I hope I'm wrong. But this 'Live' PAMM account is very very FISHY.

First there is already a SCAM warning about Gainsy - guess what's it about? They don't issue withdrawals. The complaints are coming from people who invested on certain PAMM accounts with an 'almost Perfect' track record. If this is true then it seems that Gainsy can fake account history so they can Scam people into opening live accounts and investing huge amounts. Then when it's time to trade, it doesn't really perform, and when it's time to withdraw, they don't issue withdrawals.

Don't you find it fishy that though everyone is saying that Vladimir should change broker, all he says that he's got good experience with Gainsy? A really serious professional trader wouldn't want to get too attached to a particular broker, much more a broker with Scam Warning.

If ever I'm wrong and if Vladimir is a legitimately great trader, the GREATEST I've ever seen actually after so many years on Forex Trading, then I mean no disrespect, but you really have to change broker dude! Then replicate your results on a Legit Broker.

I really hope my suspicions are unfounded for your sake @aslan9.

My dear friend!
Thank you for your words - I am really glad to read such reviews from another traders! Really, thanks a lot. Have to say, that the reason of my trading results are years of work and developments.
I do not want to tell you about broker - everyone has his own opinion about every broker, as for me the best review is the review that you can make by yourself using your own experience of trading with broker. That's what I did and that is why I still trading with them.
I think that all in our hands and I hope I will not disappoint any of my investor.
And believe me, I am not the greatest trader, I think if someone will spend so much time for learning of market then he will be able to show better results. Unfortunately, during this learning I've lost a lot of things and people in my life. My first wife thought that I am loosing my time and she leaves me alone. On weekends I have a right to see my young son. He is the best I have ever created. Sorry for mistakes, I am crying while I am typing this text and I am not using translators now because they cannot show my feelings in this text. Usually I am controlling my emotions (and you can check it by looking to my trades) but when I am thinking about my son I cannot hold back the tears, because I have no rights to spend much time than on weekends only. Children are everything for me! And I am trying to trade well because I wish a good life to my children (now I have a little daughter and I love her so much!)
Once again, thanks for your words!

And aslan9, thanks for your trust! I will make an everything to make us richer!

Vladimir, you could solve the last issue easily, just open second pamm at the broker they wish and trust more and copy your trades there too. You will have a second account what will gives you more safety, if something will happen to the broker of your first pamm, what easy can happen. And guys here will happy too. God bless you with issue of your wife and kids. I love kids also :)

Hi, dear andyb777!
Thank you for your advise, I also thought about it but in order to start trading with another broker I have to create an account with that broker and deposit my own funds firstly (minimum 10K), but I don't want to fund it while I haven't tested it, because there will be the opportunity to lose my funds. Some of guys that asks me to create an account with another brokers can be representatives of that brokers (I think, you will understand me).

Vladimir, I recommend FXCM and FOREX.com, both are listed companies in New York stock exchange.
It can guarantee that your funds are very safe. To be a PAMM manger, it's quite easy and quick, you just provide 6 months recods from Gainsy! After, I believe there will be a lot of investors who have more confidence to join your PAMM!

I understand you totaly. I also do not believe everyone who writes me something, but think money management is very important. Even brokers like Alpari come into trouble. Imagine all what you was working for since years, is destroyed not by your mistake, but by the broker. I do not know your strategy, does it need 10k $ , or not, but with your sharp ratio mayby 500 $ enough? + investors money, but its yours, you have to decide.

Golden_Midas posted:
Hi, dear andyb777!
Thank you for your advise, I also thought about it but in order to start trading with another broker I have to create an account with that broker and deposit my own funds firstly (minimum 10K), but I don't want to fund it while I haven't tested it, because there will be the opportunity to lose my funds. Some of guys that asks me to create an account with another brokers can be representatives of that brokers (I think, you will understand me).

Hi golden Midas,

I would have no problem investing 30 000 pounds into your Pamm however as I stated before I dont care who the broker is as long as they fall into a solid monetary jurisdiction ie Europe, America, uk. All the major players who have big funds do this.
Segregated funds and insurance to a certain level , usually 50 000 dollars.

Now I am not from a broker but trying to help as I believe you could manage a substantial account with your skills but can never do so with your current broker. It is like saying you have the skills of a top Formula 1 driver but are competing in the go karts.
You need to step up to the top levels to match your skills. I cannot understand why you dont, unless you are a different sort of Lewis Hamilton who is happier in the go karts. Odd but possible!

andyb777 posted:
I understand you totaly. I also do not believe everyone who writes me something, but think money management is very important. Even brokers like Alpari come into trouble. Imagine all what you was working for since years, is destroyed not by your mistake, but by the broker. I do not know your strategy, does it need 10k $ , or not, but with your sharp ratio mayby 500 $ enough? + investors money, but its yours, you have to decide.

Hope you will understand me also in next: after CHF shock a lot of companies shown their 'instability' (including Alpari). That was also the reason why I stayed with gainsy. At that moment I was surprised that I am able to withdraw not only my initial deposit but also my profit from this broker. As I understand there are still some problems with alpari, someone withdrew their money, someone not yet.

Hope you will understand me also in next: after CHF shock a lot of companies shown their 'instability' (including Alpari). That was also the reason why I stayed with gainsy. At that moment I was surprised that I am able to withdraw not only my initial deposit but also my profit from this broker. As I understand there are still some problems with alpari, someone withdrew their money, someone not yet.

No, I don't understand this, what happen to Alpari, can happen to Gainsy too.

It can happens with any broker but it happened with alpari and not with gainsy.
Anyway, as I see, some of investors made requests for withdrawals and hope they already got their funds. as I know, one of them exactly already got his funds)

Hi Golden Midas,

Can you explain a little about your 'perfect results'? How is it possible to keep ratio of Equity Growth/Balance Growth at almost perfect ONE?

I find that almost impossible to be believe.

The reasons why many here found it 'Too Good to be True':

1. Your near perfect Equity Growth/Balance Growth ratio .... to get that kind of perfect result, you need your prediction of every trade to be move in the direction of your prediction right from the start i.e. once you open trade, it must go in the right direction you had predicted. NOT even a little dip in the opposite direction.

2. Gainsy's reputation problem in many forums and they are blacklisted by Forex Peace Army and Forex Fraud. With your near perfect ONE ratio, it is inevitable that others suspect you as part of the fraud.

Thanks for your review (If you're really think that my results are perfect)!!!
I am really glad to read it! (By the way, I don't think that it's really 'PERFECT')
Well, this is a little about my trading story: I've really spent a lot of time while I ended to develope my system. You can read about it in this thread, as I already told, I've lost too much while I made it. But as you can see, it really brings me a lot of money. It's a pity that something cannot be bought, for example, lost time, lost moments of life, lost family...
And about ' it must go in the right direction you had predicted. ' - yes, it has to be, my system works exactly with such rules, and I will not understand anyone who wants to predict a movement in a opposite side!

About the reputation of gainsy... And what can you tell me about reputation of forex peace army? Personally I do not believe them - I have read a lot of another resources while choosing broker, including Myfxbook, earnforex etc. And also I read a lot about forex peace army (including Dmitriy Chavkerov - an owner of forexpeacearmy) - that is why I am not believe in their reviews.

I offer you to contact investors that already got some profit with my trading. there are a lot of investors that found my account right here on myfxbook.

its not about this trader's word against Forex Peace Army, It is the traders who actually tried Gainsy and reported to Forex Peace Army.

FPA is just a review site of retail traders posting their experience.

Gainsy has 3 Guilty cases against them and they(Gainsy) has not met the requirements to remove that status ( the same goes for SynergyFX). The bad reviews go on and on at this Broker.




They even have a Virtual Fund Account as PAMM, so you can trade to promote your skills to ATTRACT INVESTORS at ZERO RISK TO THE TRADER.

Beware potential investors!!

It is very easy for a broker that is not monitored or falls under a jurisdiction as dubious as the Grenadines to have results show up in my fx book that look walk on water perfect. It is also the modus operandi to allow the initial investors to withdraw their profits. They will build up a trust relationship with the intention that the GULLIBLE will soon be lured by the prospect of easy money and start flocking.
This my friends is when things get nasty as when the pool is big enough then your all led quietly off like lambs to the slaughter.

The reason I am posting is it has happened to me and as embarrassing as it is to admit it , I am damned if I will sit by and make it easy for anyone to pull off on others. You lose your money faster than your first trading account.

Midas I challenge you to open a demo account with a reputable broker , one that is under EU jurisdction and link it with your trading acc and lets see the results then.

I hope you prove me wrong and I wish you all the best but you cannot blame people for being sceptical can you?

Hi Midas,

As Netrader suggest, all looking at you would like a demo account from a trustworthy broker. If you are so confident, please show the world that you are up to this challenge. If possible, do it in a real account from a trustworthy broker.

We are all looking forwarding to your results in another account from another account apart from Gainsy.

Regards
Dennis Lye

Well, I am agree to trade with another brokers but as I am fulli satisfied with this broker and I don't want to create account with the broker that is still not tested by myself personally I am ready to agree with one man from this resource and to manage an account that will be deposited by you. For example: You are opening an account with the broker, that is trusted by you, provide me the trading password of MT4 platform and I am trading. We will share the profit that I will earn. In case if you will scam me then I will stop to trade.
Also I am trying to renew my trading statement from some another brokers, when I will make it I will publish it right here as a proof that I am a real trader.
In any case I have already 19 investors that earns with me in Gainsy company - thanks to them. Hope, they are satisfied by my results.
Once again, sorry for mistakes in this text - I am from UA and I don't speak English well.

Hi Midas,

In a few days ago, I told I hope to join your trades. Right now, most people don't trust Gainsy.
I hope you can trade with my account and share the profit. I can wiretransfer the profit to you monthly. You can public my records that prove you are a real trader! My broker is FOREX.com. No one will doubt this broker anymore.


Regards,
Ryan

Beware guys, I've heard this scam before. Super trader with 'almost perfect' results on a dubious broker. People get hooked to invest, and when the time comes to withdraw and perform, boom! Trader disappears. Broker got lots of deposits, then they too disappear (or ignore the request for withdrawals). Forex is too easy to scam - lots of 'suckers'. It's easy for brokers to fake trade history. The 'trader' could be actually employed by the broker. It's also easy for the broker to ignore request for withdrawals, as long as they're not under a regulatory commission where the depositor resides. Gainsy is regulated by svgfsa.com - in a small country where money launderers hide their money. If Gainsy bails out on you, could you go chase them there at Saint Vincent and the Grenadines? Seriously, would you spend more money on a litigation case against Gainsy? Most people would just forget about it, and just warn others through sites like FPA.

You can't use the CHF debacle to show that 'even the big guys' fall. Those big brokers were public companies, and they are required to show their capital reserves. But these small brokers like Gainsy, they can hide what's happening to them. All brokers were affected by what happened to CHF, if you understand what really happened, then you know it's impossible for an ECN/STP broker to not get drastically affected. Everyone is licking their wounds even today! If a broker claims that they were not affected, then that's probably because they are a Market Maker - they are not really connected to a Liquidity Provider in the Interbank Network.

And why discredit Forex Peace Army? As far as I know, only Scam Brokers and Sharks hate it. So they have to discredit it. FPA is on your side traders.

So Golden_Midas, the solution is very simple. Change your broker. You can't stick to Gainsy. Heck, with your 'skills' why manage a PAMM account? That in itself is dubious. Think big man! Hedge funds will be begging to get you as their trader and you'll be trading in the Millions of $$$ no less.