To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts
mohasasa
Jan 20 2019 at 14:49
11 zpráv(a,y)
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?

Adribaasmet
Jan 21 2019 at 08:13
897 zpráv(a,y)
What is A-Book and B-book? Unfortunately, I’m not aware of this kind of terminology.

L3CAP
Jan 21 2019 at 11:13
264 zpráv(a,y)
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


A respectable and well regulated broker would not refuse such a request, can you clarify from which broker you had requested this?

vontogr (togr)
Jan 21 2019 at 13:39
4862 zpráv(a,y)
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


Why does it matter to you?

Adribaasmet
Jan 22 2019 at 07:45
897 zpráv(a,y)
L3CAP posted:
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


A respectable and well regulated broker would not refuse such a request, can you clarify from which broker you had requested this?


Exactly; it sounds something different. I’m also interested to know the broker’s name.

BartenderFX
Jan 22 2019 at 07:46
14 zpráv(a,y)
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


is none of your business. As long your broker processes your withdrawals correctly

mohasasa
Jan 22 2019 at 08:04
11 zpráv(a,y)
Adribaasmet posted:
What is A-Book and B-book? Unfortunately, I’m not aware of this kind of terminology.


- You can read about A-Book & B-Book broker here:-

https://www.forexsignals.com/blog/2017/08/the-difference-between-a-book-and-b-book-brokers/

mohasasa
Jan 22 2019 at 08:08
11 zpráv(a,y)
togr posted:
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


Why does it matter to you?


- They said that they updated their servers to provide us with better liquidity & execution, but I know from their mt4 that they are the market maker(because when you look at their execution it is INSTANT).

- So, why they are lying about new liquidity because they are the old & new liquidity.

vontogr (togr)
Jan 22 2019 at 09:59
4862 zpráv(a,y)
mohasasa posted:
togr posted:
mohasasa posted:
- Last week I have contacted my broker and asked him to give me a statement that shows whether my trades were on their A-book or B-book.

- They refused and told me that's confidential and we cannot share this information with our clients.

- What to do in this situation?


Why does it matter to you?


- They said that they updated their servers to provide us with better liquidity & execution, but I know from their mt4 that they are the market maker(because when you look at their execution it is INSTANT).

- So, why they are lying about new liquidity because they are the old & new liquidity.


These are actually different thing
broker: market maker vs. STP broker
execution: A book vs. B book

I would say as long as you make profits and withdraw them good for you. Especially with instant execution.
The only issue could be with very big trades that are profitable AND were not sent ot market
but I assume this is not the case.

GangYanny
Jan 22 2019 at 11:47
10 zpráv(a,y)
I do not think that a broker has to tell you that information. It might be the case that they do not know until you take a trade. If it is small trade then it may be one but if it is a larger then it may be another

Prosím, přihlašte se pro vložení komentáře.