Pour utiliser le chat, veuillez vous connecter.
Retour aux contacts

Is Myfxbook New Impact Forecast more dependable than Forex factory ?

Aug 03, 2012 at 07:21
Vues 1,621
16 Replies
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 03, 2012 at 07:21 (édité Aug 03, 2012 at 07:21)
From experience, Whose News impact forecast is more dependable/accurate. Myfxbook or Forex Factory

Share your views and experience..
My recommended Broker
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 03, 2012 at 21:03
MFB
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 04, 2012 at 21:45

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?
My recommended Broker
Membre depuis Jan 14, 2010   posts 556
Aug 05, 2012 at 06:21

MetaCoder posted:
From experience, Whose News impact forecast is more dependable/accurate. Myfxbook or Forex Factory

Share your views and experience..

I would go with myFxBook, not to mention there are much more events which help me fill in the gap when markets start moving for no reason.
Membre depuis Jan 14, 2010   posts 556
Aug 05, 2012 at 06:22

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?

I don't think it's possible, but you can suggest it in the suggestion-box so they can add it https://www.myfxbook.com/community/suggestion-box/8,1
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 10:47

James_Bond posted:

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?

I don't think it's possible, but you can suggest it in the suggestion-box so they can add it https://www.myfxbook.com/community/suggestion-box/8,1


Thanks for the suggestion. I just added this request to the suggestion box.
My recommended Broker
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 05, 2012 at 11:09
why you need it in CSV format?
are you BACKUP fan😀


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 11:50

stevewalker posted:
why you need it in CSV format?
are you BACKUP fan😀


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?

I'm developing a News EA. CSV format is very useful for EA backtesting..
My recommended Broker
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 05, 2012 at 12:05
good luck!

So why asking for csv format while you konw it?


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
why you need it in CSV format?
are you BACKUP fan😀


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?

I'm developing a News EA. CSV format is very useful for EA backtesting..
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 12:21

stevewalker posted:
good luck!

So why asking for csv format while you konw it?


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
why you need it in CSV format?
are you BACKUP fan😀


MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
MFB

Thanks Steve. Are you aware of how to obtain a CSV file containing fxbook News release Archive?

I'm developing a News EA. CSV format is very useful for EA backtesting..

Am asking if there's a downloadable News Archive in CSV format. I have forex factory News Archive from 2007 till 2012. I'm trynna get something similar for fxbook calender
My recommended Broker
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 05, 2012 at 12:44
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 13:01 (édité Aug 05, 2012 at 13:02)

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves
My recommended Broker
Membre depuis Jan 14, 2010   posts 556
Aug 05, 2012 at 14:22

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves

I agree. Obviously it's not simply knowing how much a market will move with a specific impact, however you do get a good estimation on the coming volatility and possible effect on the market.
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 05, 2012 at 16:10
yes you can forecast the volatility. you dont need a crystal ball for that. when rate desecion is done most prob there will be a volatility.
but which direction the price move?



James_Bond posted:

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves

I agree. Obviously it's not simply knowing how much a market will move with a specific impact, however you do get a good estimation on the coming volatility and possible effect on the market.
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 16:13 (édité Aug 05, 2012 at 16:14)

stevewalker posted:
yes you can forecast the volatility. you dont need a crystal ball for that. when rate desecion is done most prob there will be a volatility.
but which direction the price move?



James_Bond posted:

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves

I agree. Obviously it's not simply knowing how much a market will move with a specific impact, however you do get a good estimation on the coming volatility and possible effect on the market.

Knowing the directional price move is an issue I've pretty much worked on and Now need the history data to see how the idea would have fared in the past..
My recommended Broker
stevewalker
forex_trader_79941
Membre depuis Jun 06, 2012   posts 1439
Aug 05, 2012 at 16:27
had worked on that. no prediction from news result.
it is your turn

good luck!

walker

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
yes you can forecast the volatility. you dont need a crystal ball for that. when rate desecion is done most prob there will be a volatility.
but which direction the price move?



James_Bond posted:

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves

I agree. Obviously it's not simply knowing how much a market will move with a specific impact, however you do get a good estimation on the coming volatility and possible effect on the market.

Knowing the directional price move is an issue I've pretty much worked on and Now need the history data to see how the idea would have fared in the past..
Membre depuis Nov 26, 2011   posts 126
Aug 05, 2012 at 16:57

stevewalker posted:
had worked on that. no prediction from news result.
it is your turn

good luck!

walker

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
yes you can forecast the volatility. you dont need a crystal ball for that. when rate desecion is done most prob there will be a volatility.
but which direction the price move?



James_Bond posted:

MetaCoder posted:

stevewalker posted:
there is no corolation between news and the price direction.
only retail sales in US at months 11-12.
trade it reverse becouse everyone knows that retail sales make top ın last 2 months.

walker


 Contrary to your statement, there actually is a relationship b/w High/Medium impact news releases and Market spikes+short term directional moves

I agree. Obviously it's not simply knowing how much a market will move with a specific impact, however you do get a good estimation on the coming volatility and possible effect on the market.

Knowing the directional price move is an issue I've pretty much worked on and Now need the history data to see how the idea would have fared in the past..

There's actually no prediction involved. Its a combination of well calculated Buy and Sell requests
My recommended Broker
Se connecter / S’inscrire to comment
You must be connected to Myfxbook in order to leave a comment
*Lutilisation commerciale et le spam ne seront pas tolérés et peuvent entraîner la fermeture du compte.
Conseil : Poster une image/une url YouTube sera automatiquement intégrée dans votre message!
Conseil : Tapez le signe @ pour compléter automatiquement un nom dutilisateur participant à cette discussion.