Discussion BlueMonkey Real Money Live Test == Started Oct 2014

fxtrader10 posted:

hokie posted:

askew8 posted:
Wow we are gEttinger hammered out here!!!

I found something interesting...

In my account at the moment all buy positions have been closed with a profit, and now in fact the EA is in the new positions on EURUSD, and it is a SELL! While the master account is still showing BUY positions and is suffering a big loss at the moment.

So this reveals that the EA is not a trade copier, and the position (BUY or SELL) is not governed by the position in the server (either manually or automatically). In other words, it's possible to have entirely different positions and trades between master account and our individual account!

Funny because I have many buy positions still open - perhaps you got the 1pip extra from your broker to push all your trades to close - lucky you!

fxtrader10 posted:

hokie posted:

askew8 posted:
Wow we are gEttinger hammered out here!!!

I found something interesting...

In my account at the moment all buy positions have been closed with a profit, and now in fact the EA is in the new positions on EURUSD, and it is a SELL! While the master account is still showing BUY positions and is suffering a big loss at the moment.

So this reveals that the EA is not a trade copier, and the position (BUY or SELL) is not governed by the position in the server (either manually or automatically). In other words, it's possible to have entirely different positions and trades between master account and our individual account!

Funny because I have many buy positions still open - perhaps you got the 1pip extra from your broker to push all your trades to close - lucky you!

hokie posted:
Funny I have even more trades than the master EA, so far 7 most recent GBPUSD positions were closed with profit, and now I still have one open position on GBPUSD while master account has none at the moment. Not complaining, not worrying... just saying :-)

fxtrader10 posted:

hokie posted:

askew8 posted:
Wow we are gEttinger hammered out here!!!

I found something interesting...

In my account at the moment all buy positions have been closed with a profit, and now in fact the EA is in the new positions on EURUSD, and it is a SELL! While the master account is still showing BUY positions and is suffering a big loss at the moment.

So this reveals that the EA is not a trade copier, and the position (BUY or SELL) is not governed by the position in the server (either manually or automatically). In other words, it's possible to have entirely different positions and trades between master account and our individual account!

Funny because I have many buy positions still open - perhaps you got the 1pip extra from your broker to push all your trades to close - lucky you!

bluemonkey posted:

fx5473br posted:
Guys, I had some big differences on my account like the others... Alex from bluemonkey has my vps details and he's investigating... beside of that he gave me few more instances and I'm enabled in some other brokers to compare...
Right now We're testing ironfx real, demo and i'm installing in a demo account at FXCM (bluemonkey real account)

thanks

if you guys need any brokers to be tested, please let @fx5473br know.

thanks.

A

whiteboy posted:
leave your emotions out of the trade. let the ea do its thing . If we loose then we loose. Big deal who hasn't lost before. You shouldn't be trading with money you can't afford to loose.

FinalElement21 posted:

hokie posted:
Funny I have even more trades than the master EA, so far 7 most recent GBPUSD positions were closed with profit, and now I still have one open position on GBPUSD while master account has none at the moment. Not complaining, not worrying... just saying :-)

What broker are you using?

Banana123 posted:
I also had all my buy trades closed in profit. But just after they closed, the Euro plunged and reversed in a matter of seconds. Very Lucky indeed. I was surprised to see the buy trades in master account in myfxbook were not not closed leaving in huge DD.

This actually happened three times were my trades closed in profit but master account didn't after the currency reversed. I think this issue has something to do with the broker. By the way my account is up 31% since I started on December 2. So far I'm happy with the performance of the monkey and I look forward to having 30% of my account ruined in the near future..

Go Monkey Go, give 'em more banana LOL

Banana123 posted:
To add more, after all the buy trades have been closed with profit, the monkey has since opened four more sell trades which also closed in profit. Now there are currently three more open sell trades with very small DD.

hokie posted:

Banana123 posted:
To add more, after all the buy trades have been closed with profit, the monkey has since opened four more sell trades which also closed in profit. Now there are currently three more open sell trades with very small DD.

Banana, your trades exactly matched mine ! Just closed 4 sell trades and currently 3 open sell trades with very small floating loss.
I thought EA like BM was not pips sensitive, 'cause it is not a scalper, but I guess I was wrong, it would still help if our broker has very low spread and fast execution even for BM. On top of that, I am a US resident, so there was not too many brokers that I could pick, really glad I found one...

Banana123 posted:
I also had all my buy trades closed in profit. But just after they closed, the Euro plunged and reversed in a matter of seconds. Very Lucky indeed. I was surprised to see the buy trades in master account in myfxbook were not not closed leaving in huge DD.

This actually happened three times were my trades closed in profit but master account didn't after the currency reversed. I think this issue has something to do with the broker. By the way my account is up 31% since I started on December 2. So far I'm happy with the performance of the monkey and I look forward to having 30% of my account ruined in the near future..

Go Monkey Go, give 'em more banana LOL