WHO trades forex for more than 10 years and keeps making regular profits

montero57 posted:
anybody here with a real account that has been audited for more than 3 years?

Check out my trading account with 3+ years result verified by myfxbook.com

Hello, I'm Trading since 2010, Promise to update in 2020 so far so good.

togr posted:
@Nasrul_Swing @SaltyWaters
everyone says so
but where are your 10+ years results
that is what does matter

Where are yours?

What you just said defines hypocrisy. You don't have 10 years of results to show either.

Nice

dWaverFX posted:

togr posted:
@Nasrul_Swing @SaltyWaters
everyone says so
but where are your 10+ years results
that is what does matter

Where are yours?

What you just said defines hypocrisy. You don't have 10 years of results to show either.

You did not ask regular profit for 10 years ( thats impossible even for big fund , often they have years loss and years gain ).
 I trade FX for 10years, I have regular Profit (for last 3 years). I trade on Interactive Brokers that cannot link to my FXbook. Before criticize someone let look yourself first, I have no benefit to lie, I just replied your question politely.

10 years a very long time I doubt there are many traders that have 10 years of data good or bad. 5 years is more likely.

vudong posted:

dWaverFX posted:

togr posted:
@Nasrul_Swing @SaltyWaters
everyone says so
but where are your 10+ years results
that is what does matter

Where are yours?

What you just said defines hypocrisy. You don't have 10 years of results to show either.

You did not ask regular profit for 10 years ( thats impossible even for big fund , often they have years loss and years gain ).
 I trade FX for 10years, I have regular Profit (for last 3 years). I trade on Interactive Brokers that cannot link to my FXbook. Before criticize someone let look yourself first, I have no benefit to lie, I just replied your question politely.

I assume you are not referring to me, because I was not the one criticizing, you are referring to togr right?

sorry, I misunderstood.

I believe Individual traders who still compete on Currency trading by using traditional trading systems based on rules or technical indicators and implemented as single decision trees are increasingly ineffective. Algorithms is the way to go.

Gowaletasia posted:
I would like to ask if there is a forex trader more than 10 years old and still generate regular profit here ?
I'm sorry to ask this
because I see the portfolio of several forex winners here on other contests they lose a lot, inconsistent
my opinion for long term 100% forex traders must have lost
therefore many brokers give a lot of bonuses
please let me know if my opinion is wrong
😐

MbFriday posted:
I believe Individual traders who still compete on Currency trading by using traditional trading systems based on rules or technical indicators and implemented as single decision trees are increasingly ineffective. Algorithms is the way to go.

What are you suggesting here a simple trading system with few rules or a complex trading system with many rules?

Dear all ...

With respect to yr point of view abt technical traders .... and yr view abt automated systems ....
U are deadly wrong ... but u can always try it .

 

MbFriday posted:
I believe Individual traders who still compete on Currency trading by using traditional trading systems based on rules or technical indicators and implemented as single decision trees are increasingly ineffective. Algorithms is the way to go.

Gowaletasia posted:
I would like to ask if there is a forex trader more than 10 years old and still generate regular profit here ?
I'm sorry to ask this
because I see the portfolio of several forex winners here on other contests they lose a lot, inconsistent
my opinion for long term 100% forex traders must have lost
therefore many brokers give a lot of bonuses
please let me know if my opinion is wrong
😐

With all due respect to the fans of automated trading systems... I worked as forex trading systems programmer for 7 years. Had a lot of meetings with my colleagues from different parts of the world. I should confess, it's impossible to create a system that would compete with experienced trader, at least for the time being. Too many things to consider! It's impossible to trade successfully based only on technical indicators, and not consider at all the economic and political situation. Could you imagine how difficult to trade GBP with all this Brexit mess for automate systems? I better believe you do. The only good thing I got from my programmer experience, it helped me to become a good manual trader.

I agree .....100%

I have been trading since 2007. I have lost so many accounts. But in the last 3 to 4 years I started making a profit. But, this year I have now improved my system and consistent profit also guaranteed.
The secret to consistent winning is don't allow loses to make you quit, learn from your mistakes, and depend on God for insightful direction.

Baileyhart posted:
I think it is not easy to make profits in Forex for 10 years. I started a few weeks ago.

The thing is that nobody here can prove such a history.
But it is not easy to keep 10 years old accounts as brokers are diminishing and sometime man change broker as well.
Not talking about trading issues.

Wongkito posted:
Nice

😎

togr posted:

Baileyhart posted:
I think it is not easy to make profits in Forex for 10 years. I started a few weeks ago.

The thing is that nobody here can prove such a history.
But it is not easy to keep 10 years old accounts as brokers are diminishing and sometime man change broker as well.
Not talking about trading issues.

this is true, and also people do not like to show their losses... so it is a difficult one to monitor and have data on

Indeed no one here can demonstrate such a history.

In any case, it is difficult to keep 10 years of age accounts as representatives are reducing and at some point man change specialist too.

Not looking at exchanging issues.

I have been trading consistently for five years now, in that time i have been forced to move brokers twice. Once because a broker shut me down and refunded me my money without any reasoning, the second was the recent esma changes which effected my trading style. A lot of retail brokers that was around 10 years ago, are sadly no longer with us.