Broker black list讨论

Looking at recent scams that show some sort of broker support. To prevent future scams to use MFB I´d like to suggest creating a broker black list. If an account uses a blacklisted broker, but it doesn't show up because of user settings, a warning message should warn the user and MFB members of potential scam and faked results.

So, what do you think?

Aimak

I agree.

I had a similar proposal https://www.myfxbook.com/community/suggestion-box/combating-fake-results/69829,1

In the very least we should be aware where these results are coming from. Why hide the IP address. We should be able to check them and keep a list of doubtful brokers.

In recent months there seems to have been a spate of these dubious accounts. I think MyFxBook should act now before it all becomes a joke.

Agreed! This make all traders and investors more comfortable and to avoid loss 'by running other people money'.

Can you list 1 or 2 brokers that should be Black Listed as an example?

One broker that jumps in my head is GRAND CAPITAL - https://www.forexpeacearmy.com/forex-forum/scam-alerts-folder/3400-how-grand-capital-steals-money.html



I think this is a great idea. You have my vote =)

It must be controlled properly, i have looked at some reviews and i think most reviews and ratings are based on RAGE, especially when a trade did'nt go too well. Have 3 or 4 of these ragers voting and you have a losing broker that was actually good in the first place. It's also not fair if a rating is applied as bad when there is only 1 post under it. For this to work, some sort of proof must be presented why the broker failed and maybe a balance scale where the negative and positive balances out properly with the amount of votes. Idieally you want a rating to be dominent after a certain amount of votes, not just 1.