Advertisement
KeltnerPRO - Jared (Od keltnerpro)
| Zisk : | +5645.75% |
| Čerpání | 58.74% |
| Pipy: | 4744.8 |
| Obchodníci | 1003 |
| Vyhraná : |
|
| Prohraná : |
|
| Typ : | Reálný |
| Páka: | 1:100 |
| Obchodování : | Neznámé |
KeltnerPRO - Jared diskuse
forex_trader_205742
Členem od Aug 31, 2014
62 příspěvků
Oct 05, 2015 at 18:19
Thanks Vlad. We are all in the same boat.
Členem od Mar 02, 2013
229 příspěvků
Oct 05, 2015 at 20:59
vladrac posted:
Do you know if someone is running this on a DEMO these days? If yes we could just look...
maybe Ricky is still reading these and can turn his EA into a demo account so we can compare...
Do you mean me?
Sometimes i read here, but i am done with keltner. Turned off the EA early enough and withdraw the profit.
Shall i run it on demo?
I think the repport of the vendor tells enough about the performance. He does not fake the results.
The differenece between who your are and who you would like to be be is what you do
Členem od Jan 28, 2011
51 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 06:08
TradeNew posted:HedgeEdge posted:
Check this out - and tell me if you would trade such an equity curve:
http://www.forexgermany.de/ressources/metatrader-strategy-tester/backtesting-keltner-pro-GBPUSD-2009-2014-2pips.htm
As a bt multi millionaire i didnt rely on any bts anymore. Only use them to get a feeling of how the ea trade. bts are worthless.
why do you need a bt if a system is making money NOW? Only real forward test is what counts and any system will faill sooner or later without adapting to changing market conditions.
And no i wouldnt trade keltner relating on that bt but i bought it months ago and so i trade it on the only pair which is profitable now.
Also i wouldnt buy keltner again. for sure.
You're right, it works right now but that's just a fluke, for sure.
Everybody knows that GBPUSD is one of the most erratic fx pairs, prone to all types of false breakouts, etc. The cable is historically very volatile but not always in a 'friendly' way. This is also reflected in the BT: over the long haul it's a break-even thing, at best. Withdraw your profits asap before the market changes behavior again, or else you will flush all gains down the toilet... trust me, the BT doesn't lie here.
Členem od Jul 31, 2012
210 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 21:07
ricki72 posted:vladrac posted:
Do you know if someone is running this on a DEMO these days? If yes we could just look...
maybe Ricky is still reading these and can turn his EA into a demo account so we can compare...
Do you mean me?
Sometimes i read here, but i am done with keltner. Turned off the EA early enough and withdraw the profit.
Shall i run it on demo?
I think the repport of the vendor tells enough about the performance. He does not fake the results.
I see too many commments about DEMO vs REAL I'd love to see whats what with this one.
I do believe DEMO and Real will be the same for this EA.
Could you help us check ;)
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
Členem od Mar 02, 2013
229 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 21:34
ok i will
just for you! 😉
just for you! 😉
The differenece between who your are and who you would like to be be is what you do
Členem od Mar 02, 2013
229 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 21:36
But before I wanted to announce that this one is the only EA which gave me more than 100% profit!
The differenece between who your are and who you would like to be be is what you do
Členem od Jul 31, 2012
210 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 21:38
ricki72 posted:
ok i will
just for you! 😉
Well, I mean, if you still have the EA....and you are not incurring in expenses by doing so...it would be a good info to have!
And yep I can see the results were great for you and it did pay for the costs of the EA itself.
But again over 100% it would have meant higher risks...and maybe one of the DD would have taken you out.
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
forex_trader_29148
Členem od Feb 11, 2011
1768 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 22:14
(Upravené Oct 06, 2015 at 22:15)
i'v seen so many treads looking like that at the end...what a desperation
one thing in commun ,they hav all been scammed
one thing in commun ,they hav all been scammed
Členem od Jul 31, 2012
210 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 22:15
rob559 posted:
i'v seen so many treads looking like that at the end...what a desperation
Like what ?
vladrac@
forex_trader_29148
Členem od Feb 11, 2011
1768 příspěvků
Oct 06, 2015 at 22:16
(Upravené Oct 06, 2015 at 22:31)
there is too many do a litle search and you find out
unlike you i have been around fro more than 3 years so may i speak ,unbelievable how some people have a short memory
unlike you i have been around fro more than 3 years so may i speak ,unbelievable how some people have a short memory
Členem od Feb 09, 2011
313 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 11:43
ricki72 posted:
But before I wanted to announce that this one is the only EA which gave me more than 100% profit!
Yeah and now You gave back more than 50% of it.
Better to lose an oportunity than a money
Členem od Jan 28, 2011
51 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 12:55
This is not a scam, it's just an EA with a poor trading logic. It enters on breakouts right at the top on exhaustions, when other people take their profits and the trend fades, this thing enters - when the party is over.
It stays in profit for 5 min. and deceives you that you will walk away with a gain, then the spike is over and you got your butt handed to you in the form of a SL.
It stays in profit for 5 min. and deceives you that you will walk away with a gain, then the spike is over and you got your butt handed to you in the form of a SL.
Členem od Jul 31, 2012
210 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 13:04
HedgeEdge posted:
This is not a scam, it's just an EA with a poor trading logic. It enters on breakouts right at the top on exhaustions, when other people take their profits and the trend fades, this thing enters - when the party is over.
It stays in profit for 5 min. and deceives you that you will walk away with a gain, then the spike is over and you got your butt handed to you in the form of a SL.
The main idea is not bad, is just the execution of this EA with predefined conditions which dont reflect current behavior.
You can trade NEWS - which is what this EA does - successfully if you better understand the fundamentals behind it and if you have a better understanding of what is a valid BO.
And yes, most of the time this EA was too late when entering the market specially this year.
Anyway, if you want to have an EA/indicator for high volatillity beyond a ATR channel , which 90% of the time will coincide with a news...you can use this EA.
Or the indicator version of this EA which i shared long ago.
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
forex_trader_29148
Členem od Feb 11, 2011
1768 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 14:39
HedgeEdge posted:
This is not a scam, it's just an EA with a poor trading logic. It enters on breakouts right at the top on exhaustions, when other people take their profits and the trend fades, this thing enters - when the party is over.
It stays in profit for 5 min. and deceives you that you will walk away with a gain, then the spike is over and you got your butt handed to you in the form of a SL.
yes i agree ,but the same pattern of ea selling comes back every couple of months with uncredible results ,at the same broker ,and selling for 800.$ ,comon guys you know better than that,rather than wait for 6 months before jumping into the wagon,
the only one of those 800.$ having success is from the same seller is vortex pro that i got from a pirated site for 25$ ,i'm making money with that one at a different broker,but i'v been waiting for a few months before and i had some traders telling me that the results was very good at another broker before i jump in
forex_trader_29148
Členem od Feb 11, 2011
1768 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 14:41
next time you need advice don't hesitate to ask me before getting trapped
Členem od Mar 02, 2013
229 příspěvků
Oct 07, 2015 at 16:33
rob559 posted:
next time you need advice don't hesitate to ask me before getting trapped
So which is the best EA to buy?
I used Vortex pro too, I got it even for free. But after 2 or 3 days I had 20% loss, so I switched it off...
The differenece between who your are and who you would like to be be is what you do
Členem od Oct 23, 2014
77 příspěvků
Oct 11, 2015 at 07:30
just saw this on forex peacy army.2015-09-29 KeltnerPRO Real Test stopped. Note from FPA: Due to unethical threats made by broker synergy's emplyees, the FPA is no longer accepting test accounts from Synergy. The tested company was informed as early as on 2015-08-13 to submit a substitued account but failed to respond at all.
Členem od Jul 31, 2012
210 příspěvků
Oct 11, 2015 at 09:26
ricki72 posted:rob559 posted:
next time you need advice don't hesitate to ask me before getting trapped
So which is the best EA to buy?
I used Vortex pro too, I got it even for free. But after 2 or 3 days I had 20% loss, so I switched it off...
Well, that's a nice one! Mister Jared and Doug will have hard time explaining this.
Again, if he can make 200K, 500K with his own EAs why bother selling.
Well a 700-800 a piece...if he can convince enough ppl to buy it...that can also add up to a good profit.
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
Členem od Aug 28, 2015
47 příspěvků
Oct 14, 2015 at 06:39
Again, if he can make 200K, 500K with his own EAs why bother selling.
Because it's just a dreams..
They are earning just from selling copies of EA which is loosing almost for half a year..
Let's get down Forex Black Market, expose fake Expert Advisors!
Členem od Jul 09, 2014
47 příspěvků
Oct 14, 2015 at 11:31
I suggest you Jared you put option to change BUY and SELL for those clients who doesnt believe in this product ;). So if there are BUY conditions EA goes SELL and opposite :D. And than we can see the difference...
For now I trust EA and I think there are just bad conditions on the market...
I suggest to all who are disapointed to show your accounts here...
For now I trust EA and I think there are just bad conditions on the market...
I suggest to all who are disapointed to show your accounts here...
Im writing about my experiences, so yours can be different ;)
