Show your profitable account here.

Apr 12, 2015 at 12:17
Vues 180,388
6,052 Replies
Membre depuis Oct 31, 2017   posts 7
Jan 15, 2018 at 08:01

Looks pretty good so far but holding&hoping never works in the long run. A few times you have had a floating DD and you didnt close the trades, you held them. It worked out for you but what happens when price moves against you (and it will)? These systems only work for a limited period of time and at some point they all face a big DD. Its inevidable and its guaranteed to happen.
Thanks for your input, august last year i took a loss at 3%, as i felt i was totally wrong with the basket, my hard stop is at 6% and is coded into the EA,

Also holding&hoping is not the core strategy, its more based on risk management and leverage, the reason im able to endure wide swings boils down to the fact I use small lot sizes, and never usually anything over 1:5 leverage, all my MAM investors have a minimum of 10k and the MAMs run at 1.5 x Max Risk, yes a few times I held the trades and was reaching 4-5% dd, for me 4-5% dd is acceptable, it really depends on peoples risk appetites

Yes price will eventually move strongly against me, but with managing risk and closing out this is mitigated,
SatangFX . com
Membre depuis Oct 31, 2017   posts 7
Jan 15, 2018 at 08:02
ohh, the quote thing didnt work for me,, and I dont know how to edit that post, anyway, im sure most people will understand i was quoting you and not talking to myself lol
SatangFX . com
Membre depuis Nov 27, 2015   posts 107
Jan 15, 2018 at 19:08
ForexRightEasy posted:
fxinvesta posted:
RSTrading posted:
Hi there.

There are threads where you can go advertise your trading accounts, but with stricter rules.

I would like to invite traders to show off their accounts here if they pass certain criteria.

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)

That's it. Only these five things. If your account passes that, feel free to let others know. There will be those that are disgruntled they cannot participate and will try to justify their way of trading, please ignore them - if it works for you, then great - maybe start a new thread and invite others trading that style to participate. - As I said, this place is not for arguing, it is for displaying accounts that potential investors might want to follow based on the criteria above. This thread is not intended to badmouth other trader's ways.

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxinvesta/fxinvesta/2275219

Great trades with low DD. Would you mind to open up more details, such as trading history? Thanks

Hello, thanks, and no, I think the only important thing to show, are the statistics, it is the only thing that should matter to an investor, who is interested in other things, for sure it is not an investor.

Regards!
Risk comes from not knowing what you're doing.
Membre depuis Jan 03, 2018   posts 162
Jan 16, 2018 at 06:51
SatangFX posted:
seems my post was moderated,

anyway have a look at my master with 170k+ and MAMs,

Feel free to let me know if you have any question,

Kind Regards,

Satang FX

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/SatangFX/satang-fx-master/2310608

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/SatangFX/mam-account-15-x-risk/2310656

nice trading
nick123427@
Membre depuis Feb 22, 2011   posts 4862
Jan 16, 2018 at 10:54
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed
forex_trader_159862
Membre depuis Nov 01, 2013   posts 41
Jan 16, 2018 at 13:39
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed

Look at the close time. It's obvious a dangerous grid system:

01.10.2018 19:13 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19552 1.19659 10.7 3.02 9h 25m 0.10%
01.10.2018 19:20 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19614 1.19660 4.6 1.19 9h 18m 0.04%
01.10.2018 18:54 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19617 1.19659 4.2 1.07 9h 44m 0.03%
01.10.2018 18:22 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19685 1.19659 -2.6 -0.97 10h 16m -0.03%
01.10.2018 17:36 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19837 1.19660 -17.7 -5.50 11h 2m -0.18%
01.10.2018 16:52 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19852 1.19659 -19.3 -5.98 11h 46m -0.19%
01.10.2018 17:24 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19898 1.19660 -23.8 -7.33 11h 14m -0.24%
01.10.2018 17:13 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19957 1.19660 -29.7 -9.10 11h 25m -0.29%
01.10.2018 18:03 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19781 1.19659 -12.2 -3.85 10h 35m -0.12%
01.10.2018 21:15 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19463 1.19658 19.5 5.66 7h 23m 0.18%
01.10.2018 21:32 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19521 1.19659 13.8 3.95 7h 6m 0.13%
01.10.2018 21:11 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19535 1.19658 12.3 3.50 7h 27m 0.11%
01.10.2018 20:40 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19598 1.19659 6.1 1.64 7h 58m 0.05%
01.10.2018 20:06 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19668 1.19658 -1.0 -0.49 8h 32m -0.02%
01.11.2018 02:29 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19505 1.19659 15.4 4.62 2h 9m 0.15%
01.10.2018 23:28 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19506 1.19659 15.3 4.40 5h 10m 0.14%
01.11.2018 01:32 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19567 1.19659 9.2 2.76 3h 6m 0.09%
01.11.2018 02:56 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19571 1.19659 8.8 2.64 1h 42m 0.09%
01.10.2018 21:56 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19580 1.19659 7.9 2.18 6h 42m 0.07%
01.10.2018 22:09 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19581 1.19659 7.8 2.15 6h 29m 0.07%
01.10.2018 22:03 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19640 1.19659 1.9 0.38 6h 35m 0.01%
01.11.2018 04:17 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19641 1.19659 1.8 0.54 21m 0.02%
Membre depuis Aug 27, 2017   posts 994
Jan 16, 2018 at 15:47
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed

Nice filtering! Just want to add 6 months duration on your four number points!
Membre depuis Feb 14, 2017   posts 8
Jan 16, 2018 at 15:48
I welcome everyone on this portal
Real account of My ManhaTTan Club system - https://www.myfxbook.com/members/Diamond777/manhattan-club/2040939



Profit more >350% (64 week)
Verified
Low DD
No martingale. No grid.


Regards



Fichiers joints:

One step back? Three steps forward! I can consider the possibility of managing an accounts. anvar777-77@
Membre depuis Feb 22, 2011   posts 4862
Jan 16, 2018 at 15:49
yangsail posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed


I would say your system
https://www.myfxbook.com/community/trading-systems/astable/1362401,2#postRow241351
was dangerous

That is why you had deleted it.
forex_trader_159862
Membre depuis Nov 01, 2013   posts 41
Jan 16, 2018 at 16:03 (édité Jan 16, 2018 at 16:06)
togr posted:
yangsail posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed


I would say your system
https://www.myfxbook.com/community/trading-systems/astable/1362401,2#postRow241351
was dangerous

That is why you had deleted it.

So what? I tried some martingale systems and realized they're dangerous so I stopped them. Now you are accusing my like one-year-ago system to defend another dangerous grid system? Your reply is so nonsense.
Membre depuis Jan 03, 2018   posts 162
Jan 17, 2018 at 06:26
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed
excellent criterias torg
nick123427@
Membre depuis Jul 12, 2013   posts 3
Jan 17, 2018 at 06:42
togr posted:
yangsail posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed


I would say your system
https://www.myfxbook.com/community/trading-systems/astable/1362401,2#postRow241351
was dangerous

That is why you had deleted it.

I think strategies like Martingale or Grid are profitable, if trader has good experience and has a real plan to manage the orders.
So, in my opinion, if he has a good plan for controlling orders and account balance and equity in his trading strategy, it will be a really good system.
Please note that, for more than 1 year, his system is profitable and it continuously growth with a really good DD.
  
Diamond
Membre depuis Jul 12, 2013   posts 3
Jan 17, 2018 at 06:42
Sorry, I Quote last message mistakenly,
I mean vontogr's system is really good !!
Diamond
Membre depuis Jul 12, 2013   posts 3
Jan 17, 2018 at 06:43
yangsail posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed

Look at the close time. It's obvious a dangerous grid system:

01.10.2018 19:13 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19552 1.19659 10.7 3.02 9h 25m 0.10%
01.10.2018 19:20 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19614 1.19660 4.6 1.19 9h 18m 0.04%
01.10.2018 18:54 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19617 1.19659 4.2 1.07 9h 44m 0.03%
01.10.2018 18:22 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19685 1.19659 -2.6 -0.97 10h 16m -0.03%
01.10.2018 17:36 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19837 1.19660 -17.7 -5.50 11h 2m -0.18%
01.10.2018 16:52 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19852 1.19659 -19.3 -5.98 11h 46m -0.19%
01.10.2018 17:24 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19898 1.19660 -23.8 -7.33 11h 14m -0.24%
01.10.2018 17:13 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19957 1.19660 -29.7 -9.10 11h 25m -0.29%
01.10.2018 18:03 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19781 1.19659 -12.2 -3.85 10h 35m -0.12%
01.10.2018 21:15 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19463 1.19658 19.5 5.66 7h 23m 0.18%
01.10.2018 21:32 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19521 1.19659 13.8 3.95 7h 6m 0.13%
01.10.2018 21:11 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19535 1.19658 12.3 3.50 7h 27m 0.11%
01.10.2018 20:40 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19598 1.19659 6.1 1.64 7h 58m 0.05%
01.10.2018 20:06 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19668 1.19658 -1.0 -0.49 8h 32m -0.02%
01.11.2018 02:29 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19505 1.19659 15.4 4.62 2h 9m 0.15%
01.10.2018 23:28 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19506 1.19659 15.3 4.40 5h 10m 0.14%
01.11.2018 01:32 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19567 1.19659 9.2 2.76 3h 6m 0.09%
01.11.2018 02:56 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19571 1.19659 8.8 2.64 1h 42m 0.09%
01.10.2018 21:56 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19580 1.19659 7.9 2.18 6h 42m 0.07%
01.10.2018 22:09 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19581 1.19659 7.8 2.15 6h 29m 0.07%
01.10.2018 22:03 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19640 1.19659 1.9 0.38 6h 35m 0.01%
01.11.2018 04:17 01.11.2018 04:38 EURUSD Buy 0.03 1.19641 1.19659 1.8 0.54 21m 0.02%

I think strategies like Martingale or Grid are profitable, if trader has good experience and has a real plan to manage the orders.
So, in my opinion, if he has a good plan for controlling orders and account balance and equity in his trading strategy, it will be a really good system.
Please note that, for more than 1 year, his system is profitable and it continuously growth with a really good DD.
Diamond
Membre depuis Feb 22, 2011   posts 4862
Jan 17, 2018 at 12:53
Adribaasmet posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed

Nice filtering! Just want to add 6 months duration on your four number points!

What filtering?
Membre depuis Feb 22, 2011   posts 4862
Jan 17, 2018 at 12:53
nick3232 posted:
togr posted:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/togr/advanced/2044496

The criteria :

1) The account must be real - no demo's. (please do not argue here that it is the same as a live acc. etc - the idea is not to engage in any arguments)
- Passed

2) The account must be verified (please do not come and defend your unverified-but-want-to-participate account - there will simply be no interest)
- Passed

3)DD must not be higher than 40% - (please. Once again. No justification for your above 40% dd, if it is higher - don't participate)
- Passed

4)The account must be older than 3 months, maybe this is even still too young.
- Passed

5)No martingales! (it might work for you, and I do not want to engage in an argument - just please keep to yourself and don't participate)
- Passed
excellent criterias torg

Thanks a lot:)
Membre depuis Feb 22, 2011   posts 4862
Jan 17, 2018 at 12:53
fxtrader01 posted:
Sorry, I Quote last message mistakenly,
I mean vontogr's system is really good !!

@fxtrader01 Thank you
Membre depuis Feb 16, 2011   posts 222
Jan 31, 2018 at 15:55
Is it a new version?
Membre depuis Nov 17, 2017   posts 10
Jan 31, 2018 at 15:55
La rubrique est fermée
*Lutilisation commerciale et le spam ne seront pas tolérés et peuvent entraîner la fermeture du compte.
Conseil : Poster une image/une url YouTube sera automatiquement intégrée dans votre message!
Conseil : Tapez le signe @ pour compléter automatiquement un nom dutilisateur participant à cette discussion.