Who is a better trader in this scenario?
Project73
Membre depuis Jun 29, 2018
27 messages
Jul 02 2018 at 13:55
Of course ultimately, it is about preference and what you value, but just for discussion/fun's sake, let's do this.
Who is a better in this scenario, assuming they both have the same ROI, drawdown, win rate and whatever statistics (lot size) you deem to be important-Trader A: the trader that trades the same few pairs over and over or Trader B: the trader that is able to trade many different pairs?
Trader A is obviously skilled in the sense that he is able to capture the trend moves, counter-trend moves, all the small and big moves in that same few pairs. On the other hand, Trader B is able to understand and execute across different pairs.
Who, in your opinion, is the better trader, assuming you got to pick one.
Who is a better in this scenario, assuming they both have the same ROI, drawdown, win rate and whatever statistics (lot size) you deem to be important-Trader A: the trader that trades the same few pairs over and over or Trader B: the trader that is able to trade many different pairs?
Trader A is obviously skilled in the sense that he is able to capture the trend moves, counter-trend moves, all the small and big moves in that same few pairs. On the other hand, Trader B is able to understand and execute across different pairs.
Who, in your opinion, is the better trader, assuming you got to pick one.
ComebackKing
Membre depuis Apr 09, 2018
37 messages
Jul 03 2018 at 06:07
In general I would say trader B. I say this because there are times when pairs will go dead; there will be very low volatility (or maybe the reverse - volatility is too high to trade). In that sense, trader A would be sitting on their hands while trader B would still be able to trade.
I would also say that if a trading strategy or system is truly robust then it will work across many assets and markets. So if trader A is successfully trading, say, the USD majors, they could likely apply that same strategy or system in other pairs.
I would also say that if a trading strategy or system is truly robust then it will work across many assets and markets. So if trader A is successfully trading, say, the USD majors, they could likely apply that same strategy or system in other pairs.
francisco
(franciscololo)
Membre depuis Jul 03, 2018
1 messages
Jul 03 2018 at 06:10
I would go with b cause he could understand the markets and how pairs correlate
vag lavi
Professional4X
Membre depuis Jan 05, 2016
1189 messages
Jul 03 2018 at 08:49
Trader A is the better trader.
If it looks too good to be true, it's probably a scam! Let the buyer beware.
CrazyTraderfx
(CrazyTrader)
Membre depuis Nov 21, 2011
1717 messages
Jul 03 2018 at 11:47
Trader C is much stronger
Enjoy trading!
Project73
Membre depuis Jun 29, 2018
27 messages
Jul 03 2018 at 14:27
CrazyTrader posted:
Trader C is much stronger
Trader C being you? ;)
kacper5
Membre depuis Aug 18, 2018
10 messages
Aug 20 2018 at 13:38
CrazyTrader posted:
Trader C is much stronger
so you are the trader C?
nick3232
Membre depuis Jan 03, 2018
156 messages
Aug 20 2018 at 14:35
trader A is better long term
nick123427@
Adribaasmet
Membre depuis Aug 27, 2017
897 messages
Aug 21 2018 at 06:49
According to my opinion: trader A is much better than the trader B.