Myfxbook Autotrade

Jordy

會員從Jun 02, 2015開始 2帖子

Jul 14, 2015 at 06:27

會員從Jun 02, 2015開始 2帖子

I have a couple of questions relating AutoTrade.

First of all, how do I know about the exact costs charged by MyFXbook per trade? I am with Pepperstone and I pay a small commission per lot, which in turn allows me to trade against real orders without a spread made. What are the extra costs related to AutoTrade though?

Secondly, I wondered how people combat the problem of signal providers opening a ton of trades. I noticed that overall most of the best systems only win 2 or so pips on average which means if your costs are anything near 2 pips you might as well not bother?

I also wondered in what timezone the hours of successful trades are depicted in, in the signal providers profile? In the editing screen it mentions it's UTC, is this the same timezone as in the providers profile?

Lastly anyone here who has experienced success in using AutoTrade and perhaps could point me to some good providers which are not of the 'churn'em and burn'em' type?

SupportingLife

會員從Jul 07, 2015開始 1帖子

Jul 15, 2015 at 06:51

會員從Jul 07, 2015開始 1帖子

I don't understand when i click on copy a person's EA i always get at pop that says...
"Copy With Signal Start

In order to copy this system to your account with a monthly subscription fee, send an invite to the trader so it becomes available through www.signalstart.com. Once the system is available, we will notify you by email."

^^ what is that about?

I thought as long a system was available to copy i that already was in the hands on myfxbook?

how do i sort out these "un-available systems"?

"No Guts, No Glory"

bobthebuilder101

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Jul 18, 2015 at 07:59

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Request ability to save your Autotrade signal settings, otherwise have to do all 49 signals again,

Have Custom Stop,Take profit, trailing stop levels

bobthebuilder101

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Jul 18, 2015 at 08:00

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Forgot to request the Simulator be able to simulate "Your Customized Settings/Subscribed Systems" eg.Total lots, Total open trades , Symbol ignore, trading times etc...😑

bobthebuilder101

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Jul 29, 2015 at 12:05

會員從Jun 03, 2015開始 11帖子

Please request ability to Only Take Long or Short trades of signals

Surrealistik

會員從Apr 28, 2012開始 219帖子

Aug 20, 2015 at 09:18

會員從Apr 28, 2012開始 219帖子

Has anyone actually invested money in a Johnpaul77, RobinVOL and/or Lucky Pound Autotrade per the current top 3 systems?

If so, would very much like to know your results thus far.

Offering the best commission discounts for the best broker: $1.50 / RTL Global Prime:

trader757

會員從Jun 12, 2011開始 51帖子

Aug 23, 2015 at 10:11

會員從Jun 12, 2011開始 51帖子

Surrealistik posted:
Has anyone actually invested money in a Johnpaul77, RobinVOL and/or Lucky Pound Autotrade per the current top 3 systems?

If so, would very much like to know your results thus far.

I could not even find someone who have used Demo accounts with Autotrade for several months not to say real accounts.
I have just setup 3 demo accounts where each one is running a single provider.
I have adjusted the initial balance and risk to what i consider reasonable values. Let's see how it goes.

mabene70

會員從Oct 16, 2013開始 7帖子

Aug 23, 2015 at 14:03

會員從Oct 16, 2013開始 7帖子

Surrealistik posted:
Has anyone actually invested money in a Johnpaul77, RobinVOL and/or Lucky Pound Autotrade per the current top 3 systems?

If so, would very much like to know your results thus far.

😲

sursum corda

Ambush_Trader

會員從Oct 23, 2013開始 38帖子

Aug 28, 2015 at 18:12

會員從Oct 23, 2013開始 38帖子

Let me tell you guys how autotrade is as a signal provider. We make money people join. We lose money people leave. As results people join at highs and leave at lows and very few are making money while we have had a huge gain this year. We have witnessed this cycle since last October and we are considering leaving autotrade .

Jordy

會員從Jun 02, 2015開始 2帖子

Sep 04, 2015 at 10:00

會員從Jun 02, 2015開始 2帖子

I´m actually one of your followers and I plan to stick with you, since I belief you are serious traders and I have faith in your ability to generate Alpha, but part of the problem is that it´s hard to have faith in signal providers if most of what you can base your decision on is past results.

I hope you stay, since I think you are one of the better signal providers at the moment, last months have been rough on many people I feel.

AndrasioForex

會員從Aug 03, 2015開始 4帖子

Sep 10, 2015 at 06:25

會員從Aug 03, 2015開始 4帖子

I have invested both in John Paul and Lucky Pound. Currently, I am up 5% in 30 days. So far, I am pleased with the results from these two even though John Paul has these 3 open trades for the past 2 weeks. I was up 10% before Lucky Pound made some bad moves which dropped my profits but it has been good so far.

You guys should start off with a small amount and reduce the risk percentage, as you are starting to see results, increase them. You can't judge one of these traders within a few weeks of trading.

AlfiePogi

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

Sep 10, 2015 at 12:12

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

I saw that, John Paul and Lucky pound were doing great these days but who knows in the coming days. Forex are unpredictable.

meszarosg

會員從Mar 19, 2015開始 3帖子

Sep 13, 2015 at 05:53

會員從Mar 19, 2015開始 3帖子

I am following JohnPaul77 since it came back to Autotrade. It made 123usd relalized profit and -171usd unrealized profit so far.

But I have to say, that the ranking does not mean anything. I also followed Prestige trader (after a huge drawdown) which made much more profit for me before it left the Autotrade system.

I am also following SPECIAL which does a moderate profit with low drawdowns.

molyang

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

Sep 16, 2015 at 13:02

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

As of typing now, I see that Lucky Pound has no more open positions, however , when I am looking at mine, it is still running? Am I the only one who is experiencing this?

AlfiePogi

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

Sep 17, 2015 at 07:26

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

Hi Molyang, I saw that as well. i was surprised to see the same. hmmmm there must have been something wrong in the system.

molyang

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

Sep 17, 2015 at 08:41

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

Hi AlfiePogi, I decided to close all the trades manually last night. Just to be sure, I think we all should monitor it by ourselves from time to time, I'm pretty sure it was a system bug. Anyway, I am also turning off all Autotrade by tonight's US Interest Rate adjustment annoucement.

AlfiePogi

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

Sep 17, 2015 at 12:37

會員從Nov 06, 2014開始 14帖子

Hi Molyang how was your autotrade doing? are you most of the time winning or otherwise?

molyang

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

Sep 17, 2015 at 13:45

會員從Oct 17, 2014開始 13帖子

Hi. Not doing very well. But began to be more conservative and less greedy, expensive lesson. Yourself?

core9design

會員從Aug 19, 2015開始 3帖子

Sep 20, 2015 at 05:56

會員從Aug 19, 2015開始 3帖子

Hi all, i've used a demo account with minimal balance 1000, subscribed to 8 systems (top ones, ambush, robin, volatility,lucky pound etc.) with minimal balance indicator at only 4% (high risk). Just after 1 weeks, probably good weeks, the equity is now at 1,200 level.

Link:

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/core9design/bw-test/1365594

I was wondering if i open a real account, would the results be as close as this?... Would usd1000 be sufficient in real account with subscription to 8 systems and such low minimal balance?

Additionally, which brokers would have the least slippage and lowest cost per transactions? ICMarkets, Pepperstone, Tickmill or Tenko?

EURUSD	1.13037	GBPUSD	1.32767	AUDUSD	0.64436
USDJPY	144.966	USDCAD	1.38103	USDCHF	0.8268

Advertisement