BlueMonkey Real Money Live Test == Started Oct 2014討論

fx5473br posted:
Guys, I had some big differences on my account like the others... Alex from bluemonkey has my vps details and he's investigating... beside of that he gave me few more instances and I'm enabled in some other brokers to compare...
Right now We're testing ironfx real, demo and i'm installing in a demo account at FXCM (bluemonkey real account)

thanks

if you guys need any brokers to be tested, please let @fx5473br know.

thanks.

A

Does this ea only trade 1 pair at a time?

whiteboy, according to my poor experiencie I saw it trading in my account at the same time EURUSD and EURGPB...

whiteboy posted:
Does this ea only trade 1 pair at a time?

It has the ability to trade multiple pairs at the same time.

fx5473br posted:
whiteboy, according to my poor experiencie I saw it trading in my account at the same time EURUSD and EURGPB...

yet this will happen very very rarely. almost 5% of times it can happen.

A

bluemonkey posted:

fx5473br posted:
Guys, I had some big differences on my account like the others... Alex from bluemonkey has my vps details and he's investigating... beside of that he gave me few more instances and I'm enabled in some other brokers to compare...
Right now We're testing ironfx real, demo and i'm installing in a demo account at FXCM (bluemonkey real account)

thanks

if you guys need any brokers to be tested, please let @fx5473br know.

thanks.

A

If you need my help..please let me know. I'm with FBS and here is the link for the ECN account ( its running V1.1 with default settings)

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bundesrepublik/ecn-robot/1096891

bundesrepublik posted:

bluemonkey posted:

fx5473br posted:
Guys, I had some big differences on my account like the others... Alex from bluemonkey has my vps details and he's investigating... beside of that he gave me few more instances and I'm enabled in some other brokers to compare...
Right now We're testing ironfx real, demo and i'm installing in a demo account at FXCM (bluemonkey real account)

thanks

if you guys need any brokers to be tested, please let @fx5473br know.

thanks.

A

If you need my help..please let me know. I'm with FBS and here is the link for the ECN account ( its running V1.1 with default settings)

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bundesrepublik/ecn-robot/1096891

your account's drawdown is exactly as much as ours and not any different.

please let us know if you have any questions.

A

wmoody posted:
Hi Everyone,

I just received the EA over the past weekend and have got ver. 1.1. Not sure if there is a difference in the later versions, but I know he is still handing out v.1.1 so it can't be that big a difference. My question is for everyone inquiring about orphaned trades. Why do you believe these trades have been orphaned? Is the only proof you have because of the 'master account,' which we now know is not a master account or do you have other evidence? Are you looking at the details on chart? Just wondering because orphaned trades can be very dangerous and will definitely influence whether I continue to use this EA. Thanks.

Hi,
My advise is that do not use this EA on live account as it had wiped out my two accounts. Every time Alex visited my VPS and told me that 'This is Strange!!!' and that strange had no solution till date. It had taken many trades and left orphaned till the accounts were wiped out despite the help was sought many times and Alex remained helpless. Also, it takes very high lots with many trades after some time and causes huge floating loss and wipe out the account. I had tested on Tallinex, IC Markets and Pepperstone and it had same failure on all brokers where I had used it.
Regards,

raviluke posted:
I understand that people are worried that trades are NOT EXACTLY matching with the master account displayed here and extra trades are being called as 'Orphaned Trades'.
Honestly, they are NOT orphaned trades. Orphaned trades are those that the EA doesn't know about and won't control or manage it.
Right now, I have 6 SELL EUR/USD trades open and the master account here only has 5. Which according to people here, is ONE ORPHANED TRADE. This isn't an orphaned trade because the EA knows about it and is managing it.
Check my screenshot, and the BlueMonkey EA does display 6 trades. If it displayed 5 trades, and 6 were open, then yes, one of them is indeed an orphan and I would be worried. The differences are due to different brokers, latency and slippage.
Hope I explained it well.

Hi,
Your definition is right. I had many trades in past were not tracked by EA and left open till account was wiped out in two accounts. So I testify that this EA has built in deficiency of not tracking the trade. Every time Alex visited my VPS said 'This is Strange!!!' and could not help any more except stating this is strange!!!
Regards,

bluemonkey posted:

fx5473br posted:
whiteboy, according to my poor experiencie I saw it trading in my account at the same time EURUSD and EURGPB...

yet this will happen very very rarely. almost 5% of times it can happen.

A

In my account its trading only EURUSD!!!

Hi Alex,
Your 6th trade lot size (i.e. 0.48) is 12 times higher than first trade lot size (i.e. 0.04) in the same direction whereas the trend is opposite of your trade. What is logic behind this!!
Regards,

ddr555 posted:
Hi Alex,
Your 6th trade lot size (i.e. 0.48) is 12 times higher than first trade lot size (i.e. 0.04) in the same direction whereas the trend is opposite of your trade. What is logic behind this!!
Regards,

It is using the grid strategy right now.

Just shared two accounts under my portfolios (public)
1)Ironfx Demo
2)FXCM Demo (same broker as bluemonkey master account)

Since they are new there are no trades yet.

Please let me know if you can access or not the accounts

thanks

fx5473br posted:
Just shared two accounts under my portfolios (public)
1)Ironfx Demo
2)FXCM Demo (same broker as bluemonkey master account)

Since they are new there are no trades yet.

Please let me know if you can access or not the accounts

thanks

You can add this too..it has already trades ( Broker is FBS )

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/bundesrepublik/ecn-robot/1096891

thanks ;)

any help related to comparing the accounts will be very helpful

ddr555 posted:

wmoody posted:
Hi Everyone,

I just received the EA over the past weekend and have got ver. 1.1. Not sure if there is a difference in the later versions, but I know he is still handing out v.1.1 so it can't be that big a difference. My question is for everyone inquiring about orphaned trades. Why do you believe these trades have been orphaned? Is the only proof you have because of the 'master account,' which we now know is not a master account or do you have other evidence? Are you looking at the details on chart? Just wondering because orphaned trades can be very dangerous and will definitely influence whether I continue to use this EA. Thanks.

Hi,
My advise is that do not use this EA on live account as it had wiped out my two accounts. Every time Alex visited my VPS and told me that 'This is Strange!!!' and that strange had no solution till date. It had taken many trades and left orphaned till the accounts were wiped out despite the help was sought many times and Alex remained helpless. Also, it takes very high lots with many trades after some time and causes huge floating loss and wipe out the account. I had tested on Tallinex, IC Markets and Pepperstone and it had same failure on all brokers where I had used it.
Regards,

Shesh so many opinions, so little facts! I have been using on pepperstone live account for 3+ months and never hit SL once, only straight profit. are you on ECN account or standard?

FXtrader2010 posted:

ddr555 posted:

wmoody posted:
Hi Everyone,

I just received the EA over the past weekend and have got ver. 1.1. Not sure if there is a difference in the later versions, but I know he is still handing out v.1.1 so it can't be that big a difference. My question is for everyone inquiring about orphaned trades. Why do you believe these trades have been orphaned? Is the only proof you have because of the 'master account,' which we now know is not a master account or do you have other evidence? Are you looking at the details on chart? Just wondering because orphaned trades can be very dangerous and will definitely influence whether I continue to use this EA. Thanks.

Hi,
My advise is that do not use this EA on live account as it had wiped out my two accounts. Every time Alex visited my VPS and told me that 'This is Strange!!!' and that strange had no solution till date. It had taken many trades and left orphaned till the accounts were wiped out despite the help was sought many times and Alex remained helpless. Also, it takes very high lots with many trades after some time and causes huge floating loss and wipe out the account. I had tested on Tallinex, IC Markets and Pepperstone and it had same failure on all brokers where I had used it.
Regards,

Shesh so many opinions, so little facts! I have been using on pepperstone live account for 3+ months and never hit SL once, only straight profit. are you on ECN account or standard?

FXtrader2010, what do you have set for a stop loss?

ddr555 posted:
Hi Alex,
Your 6th trade lot size (i.e. 0.48) is 12 times higher than first trade lot size (i.e. 0.04) in the same direction whereas the trend is opposite of your trade. What is logic behind this!!
Regards,

@ddr555 I think you didn't understood yet the strategy behind this robot.

@bluemonkey Alex I see you are more active and put more effort for customer care. Thank you.
Cheers.