Advertisement
Forex Growth Bot
| Gain : | +2644.71% |
| Drawdown | 94.46% |
| Pips: | 8075.5 |
| Trades | 2881 |
| Won: |
|
| Lost: |
|
| Type: | Real |
| Leverage: | 1:200 |
| Trading: | Automated |
Forex Growth Bot Discussion
May 12, 2011 at 22:03
(edited May 12, 2011 at 22:05)
nzsolt85 posted:
FGB just opened now 2 positions with 0.15 lot size.. what is happening? my fixed lot size in the settings was 0.05?????
thats the 3rd instance of this that I have heard of. It is tripling the lot size for some reason. I'm thinking more and more that this is all a programming glitch brought on by 1.4. I dont think these problems were occurring until the release of that.
And it didn't open anything for me.
forex_trader_12567
Member Since May 29, 2010
258 posts
May 12, 2011 at 22:08
nzsolt85 posted:
i'm stil using the 1.3 version... somebody has open trades???
no bro. now, my seeting assign TP & SL TRUE. Smart Exit True. internal control still on.
forex_trader_32468
Member Since Mar 23, 2011
14 posts
May 12, 2011 at 22:10
cunod posted:
nzsolt85 posted:
FGB just opened now 2 positions with 0.15 lot size.. what is happening? my fixed lot size in the settings was 0.05?????
thats the 3rd instance of this that I have heard of. It is tripling the lot size for some reason. I'm thinking more and more that this is all a programming glitch brought on by 1.4. I dont think these problems were occurring until the release of that.
This happened to me a couple days ago. Closed a trade manually with internal controls on. I forgot to reset the EA by restarting MT4, and when FGB decided it was time to close the already-closed position, it basically issued a new order in the opposite direction.
I turned off the internal controls and had no problems since then.
May 12, 2011 at 22:12
nzsolt85 posted:
i'm stil using the 1.3 version... somebody has open trades???
Even through were using 1.3 the fgb team is probably using a 1.4 version on their side, if it be to trigger something or not. Im not up on how this ea operates in the background wise. keep in mind Im speculating on this and giving them the benefit of the doubt.
May 12, 2011 at 22:15
HiPwrD64 posted:
This happened to me a couple days ago. Closed a trade manually with internal controls on. I forgot to reset the EA by restarting MT4, and when FGB decided it was time to close the already-closed position, it basically issued a new order in the opposite direction.
I turned off the internal controls and had no problems since then.
so a restart of mt4 will fix this
Member Since Jun 14, 2010
28 posts
May 12, 2011 at 22:45
Anyone else have the Trade Copier? I'd like to see some published results on here...I just signed up for it...I heard from people online it was better...I would love to see some proof!
May 12, 2011 at 22:58
oh and folks for those that are unaware the trade copier is at
http://www.forexgrowthbot.com/signals/
http://www.forexgrowthbot.com/signals/
May 12, 2011 at 23:37
08071965 posted:
it´s a Big Scam ; SCAMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
Same robot
http://www.forexshuffle.com/
Same Broker
Big SCAMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
Alert, Alert
Hello!😲 Big statement. What part are you saying is a scam? I looked at the forex shuffle account and from what I am seeing they are nothing alike in their trade history.
May 12, 2011 at 23:46
Orders
Forex Growth Bot
105355037 2011.05.11 19:30 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42060 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42686 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -125.20
456976 Forex Growth Bot
105355587 2011.05.11 19:45 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42184 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42679 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -99.00
456976 Forex Growth Bot
Orders
Shufle
105356103 2011.05.11 20:00 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42187 1.44701 0.00000 2011.05.12 18:45 1.42570 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -7.66
99006 {723009} Shufle
105355141 2011.05.11 19:30 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42086 1.44582 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42684 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -11.96
99006 {721907} Shufle
105355607 2011.05.11 19:45 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42177 1.44681 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42683 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -10.12
99006 {722505} Shufle
Orders
Forex Growth Bot
105355990 2011.05.11 20:00 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42163 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 18:45 1.42567 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -80.80
456976 Forex Growth Bot
105370102 2011.05.12 13:15 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.41371 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 14:15 1.41607 0.00 0.00 0.00 -47.20
456976 Forex Growth Bot
Forex Growth Bot
105355037 2011.05.11 19:30 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42060 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42686 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -125.20
456976 Forex Growth Bot
105355587 2011.05.11 19:45 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42184 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42679 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -99.00
456976 Forex Growth Bot
Orders
Shufle
105356103 2011.05.11 20:00 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42187 1.44701 0.00000 2011.05.12 18:45 1.42570 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -7.66
99006 {723009} Shufle
105355141 2011.05.11 19:30 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42086 1.44582 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42684 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -11.96
99006 {721907} Shufle
105355607 2011.05.11 19:45 sell 0.02 eurusd 1.42177 1.44681 0.00000 2011.05.12 20:30 1.42683 0.00 0.00 -0.36 -10.12
99006 {722505} Shufle
Orders
Forex Growth Bot
105355990 2011.05.11 20:00 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.42163 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 18:45 1.42567 0.00 0.00 -3.60 -80.80
456976 Forex Growth Bot
105370102 2011.05.12 13:15 sell 0.20 eurusd 1.41371 0.00000 0.00000 2011.05.12 14:15 1.41607 0.00 0.00 0.00 -47.20
456976 Forex Growth Bot
May 13, 2011 at 00:29
ok what you are showing does have merit, but 714 trades (shuffle) vs 220 trades (fgb) still a bit of a deviation. Even if this is the same system, this happens constantly, people getting EAs, retweeking them and rebranding them as their own. What the bottom line is ultimately is the determining factor is; does it work? Will it produce profits? Will it kill our accounts? Which so far FGB its got a good track record. Were just having a hic up in things right now. Were trying to figure it out. That's what we care about.
forex_trader_12567
Member Since May 29, 2010
258 posts
May 13, 2011 at 00:29
should we refund Guys?
May 13, 2011 at 00:32
cunod posted:
ok what you are showing does have merit, but 714 trades (shuffle) vs 220 trades (fgb) still a bit of a deviation. Even if this is the same system, this happens constantly, people getting EAs, retweeking them and rebranding them as their own. What the bottom line is ultimately is the determining factor is; does it work? Will it produce profits? Will it kill our accounts? Which so far FGB its got a good track record. Were just having a hic up in things right now. Were trying to figure it out. That's what we care about.
Good Luck for you e and FGB, Ok
forex_trader_32776
Member Since Mar 28, 2011
942 posts
May 13, 2011 at 00:38
(edited May 13, 2011 at 00:46)
Forex Shuttle:
thinkforex broker with 1.1 spreads with zero comm on EURUSD. Two trading styles. (1)-Arbitrage .1lots for 1-2 pips and (2)Scalp 10TP and 400SL 0.01 lot LOGIN:1151301 PW:shuf92__Thinkforex:Live-server
https://www.myfxbook.com/memembers/forexscam/perry-martin-forex-shuffle-scam/98602
- I haven't updated the forex shuttle for about a month, but the last time I checked, FGB is not Forex Shuttle, Its probably the other way around. I haven't checked the login credentials for forex shuttle, but they are above, if you want to dig deeper into this matter.
forex shuttle is also a monthly signal service, which FGB is an actual Bot for you to keep. Forex shuttle probably started to send signals that were generated from FGB as its clearly the most stable EA on the market. Whats your opinion on this matter?
Yeah you guys are right - http://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxshuffle/forex-shuffle/93497
the EURUSD were opened at the same time as FGB- however the trades were closed at a loss, while FGB made gains.The trades below were taken from the (Link above) to Forex Shuttle system page.
05.11.2011 16:30 05.12.2011 17:30 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44582 - 1.42082 1.42698 -61.6 -12.42 1d -0.61%
05.11.2011 16:45 05.12.2011 17:30 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44681 - 1.42178 1.42692 -51.4 -10.38 1d -0.51%
05.11.2011 17:00 05.12.2011 15:45 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44701 - 1.42191 1.42578 -38.7 -7.84 22h 45m -0.39%
thinkforex broker with 1.1 spreads with zero comm on EURUSD. Two trading styles. (1)-Arbitrage .1lots for 1-2 pips and (2)Scalp 10TP and 400SL 0.01 lot LOGIN:1151301 PW:shuf92__Thinkforex:Live-server
https://www.myfxbook.com/memembers/forexscam/perry-martin-forex-shuffle-scam/98602
- I haven't updated the forex shuttle for about a month, but the last time I checked, FGB is not Forex Shuttle, Its probably the other way around. I haven't checked the login credentials for forex shuttle, but they are above, if you want to dig deeper into this matter.
forex shuttle is also a monthly signal service, which FGB is an actual Bot for you to keep. Forex shuttle probably started to send signals that were generated from FGB as its clearly the most stable EA on the market. Whats your opinion on this matter?
Yeah you guys are right - http://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxshuffle/forex-shuffle/93497
the EURUSD were opened at the same time as FGB- however the trades were closed at a loss, while FGB made gains.The trades below were taken from the (Link above) to Forex Shuttle system page.
05.11.2011 16:30 05.12.2011 17:30 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44582 - 1.42082 1.42698 -61.6 -12.42 1d -0.61%
05.11.2011 16:45 05.12.2011 17:30 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44681 - 1.42178 1.42692 -51.4 -10.38 1d -0.51%
05.11.2011 17:00 05.12.2011 15:45 EURUSD Sell 0.02 1.44701 - 1.42191 1.42578 -38.7 -7.84 22h 45m -0.39%
forex_trader_18284
Member Since Sep 13, 2010
37 posts
May 13, 2011 at 00:40
(edited May 13, 2011 at 00:41)
stevek11 posted:
Hey guys im using the trade copier so as to get over all the problems that you are discussing, so far so good, the last three trades made nearly 200 pips and then one tiny loss, worth considering for a small monthly fee.
I started using the trade copier when it first came out on my ATC account. It seemed to work well at first and then one day it closed 3 trades much earlier than the trades in the demo account closed.....and I lost a lot of profit because of the early close. I wrote support and ask then what was going on and they ask me about the EA status on the chart and about my trade logs. I answered the status question, sent them my trade logs and they replied that it must be a problem with my broker and ask if I could switch to a different one. That's when I gave up on the trade copier and went back to the EA. Bottom line is that the trade copier is no more reliable than the EA.....its performance is extremely dependent on the broker you use.
forex_trader_32468
Member Since Mar 23, 2011
14 posts
May 13, 2011 at 02:08
bah, all this talk about copier service... went to check it out and was pleasantly surprised that the price is only $35/mo, rather than the $50 before. that's less than half of ONE losing trade, or a fraction of ONE potential winning trade. OK i'll bite. signing up.
May 13, 2011 at 04:50
RTSE posted:
stevek11 posted:
Hey guys im using the trade copier so as to get over all the problems that you are discussing, so far so good, the last three trades made nearly 200 pips and then one tiny loss, worth considering for a small monthly fee.
I started using the trade copier when it first came out on my ATC account. It seemed to work well at first and then one day it closed 3 trades much earlier than the trades in the demo account closed.....and I lost a lot of profit because of the early close. I wrote support and ask then what was going on and they ask me about the EA status on the chart and about my trade logs. I answered the status question, sent them my trade logs and they replied that it must be a problem with my broker and ask if I could switch to a different one. That's when I gave up on the trade copier and went back to the EA. Bottom line is that the trade copier is no more reliable than the EA.....its performance is extremely dependent on the broker you use.
The explanation of FGB is definitely wrong. The slave of a signalcopy master EA can never close earlier than the master. Why? Because it got no signal from the master. The slave read continously the list of the trades of the master and adapt his own trades. Your account has nothing to do, when your trades were closed earlier. It is always the action on the master account.
Only a later closing could be possible, in some cases, like " trade context is busy", requotes etc.
May 13, 2011 at 04:57
cunod posted:
stevek11 posted:
2011.05.12 12:15 sell 1.41372 closed at 1.41611 -23.9 pips
2011.05.11 19:00 sell 1.42159 closed at 1.41548 +61.1 pips
2011.05.11 18:45 sell 1.42177 closed at 1.41322 +85.5 pips
2011.05.11 18:30 sell 1.42058 closed at 1.41454 +60.4 pips
Hope this proves helpful guys
I did the math comparing those trades and there is about a 7 pip difference on average compared in the 4 trades. and you took the highest one was that one in loss. FGB lost about 8 pips and you lost about 15 more pips.
the account they are showing on here is for the ea, their trade copier account is a different account.
