Advertisement
KeltnerPRO - Jared (による keltnerpro)
| 増加 : | +5645.75% |
| ドローダウン | 58.74% |
| ピップス: | 4744.8 |
| 取引 | 1003 |
| 勝利: |
|
| 負け: |
|
| タイプ: | リアル |
| レバレッジ: | 1:100 |
| 取引: | 不明 |
KeltnerPRO - Jared 討論
Nov 02, 2014 at 07:42
thesupremeforex posted:ahmedfouad posted:Steven31 posted:
wow really $500 for EA??.
I would never waste such money.
I bought another EA for $149 i though it's much, but at least it works...
Take care ...This guy works for a man called himself here on myfxbook "TheFx4U"....His EA is called "RTREND" and it works on JPY pairs without stop loss and multiplier sizes till recovery.....he is promoting by himself or like others for an EA .......This guy here wants to tell you that it cost $ 149....and it works.....Craaappp...!!
I have bought it already......!! and I will give it for free....."Charity"....as he told me.....He told me when I bought his EA that he is NOT having the price of EA for him and he is paying it for Charity...!!!!!! :)))))))))))))))))))))))))
May be I will copy him for charity...!! I will give this EA for free for whoever want to wipe his account...!!
Check out my subject here.
http://www.myfxbook.com/community/general/thefx4you--his-ea-rtrendtake/836607,1
Hello!
I also had purchased that EA and it made huge floating loss so I removed it. When I asked for refund he refused it!!! So please be careful to buy this EA of USD 148.00. First he will give free then he will make you emotionally to pay him!!
Regards,
TSF
YES! Please becareful of TheFx4You! and his clone account 'Steven31'.
Nov 05, 2014 at 07:50
just uploaded new version k-pro;has 2 new filters.one for better entries.very impressed with wizard that did it.thought i would have to delete current model.this wizard installed everything even kept my settings.shows attention to detail by owner.hope someone keeps track of performance between versions.with k-pro you can only operate on one account live or demo at a time.!
Nov 09, 2014 at 14:20
Seems to me like you want to keep both , as they work best in different pairs ( I guess for obvious reasons, as one is BO EA the other is a Rev-BO).
Both achieved the really high % in profit , by risking quite a lot in the first month....
Which is the usual commercial EA strategy: open many accounts with max risk till you get 1 lucky month which will boost the account 2-3 or more times, and then reduce the risk...
Ppl are attacked by the large %, but never really look back and consider what was the risk taken to achieve it.
If you want a real good EA, you MUST consider how much did the guy risk to achieve this high profit!?
If you look at this KPro EA in the first month, there were times that during 1 event he open more than 5 trades with a really high risk... that is in my view a ALL-IN approach - Gamble style!
Cheers,
Vlad
Both achieved the really high % in profit , by risking quite a lot in the first month....
Which is the usual commercial EA strategy: open many accounts with max risk till you get 1 lucky month which will boost the account 2-3 or more times, and then reduce the risk...
Ppl are attacked by the large %, but never really look back and consider what was the risk taken to achieve it.
If you want a real good EA, you MUST consider how much did the guy risk to achieve this high profit!?
If you look at this KPro EA in the first month, there were times that during 1 event he open more than 5 trades with a really high risk... that is in my view a ALL-IN approach - Gamble style!
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
Nov 10, 2014 at 07:32
@vladrac , even if you average down the first month gains to what they gained later, they both are still pretty good EAs. I don't understand why you keep beating up on that point.
@jamesphuc, from what I can tell, they both are very good EAs and both are different style. Keltnerpro trades momentum and would would sell or buy new highs/lows for the day with high momentum behind the move. Rev is a trend follower and opens trades on pull backs.
About draw downs... I have no clue. my personal experience with Keltner pro is, when I bought it, it was having the worst month and my first 16 trades were negative, and my account was -15% in its first month, it picked up later and right now my account is +15% (so yeah, it made 35% last month).... For Rev it's been the opposite experience so far, it's been in the black from day one and that account too is +15% for the first 2 weeks. What happens moving forward, I have no clue.
If I had to pick one or the other, at this point, I'd pick Rev. But I like them both. I hope this helps answer your question.
@jamesphuc, from what I can tell, they both are very good EAs and both are different style. Keltnerpro trades momentum and would would sell or buy new highs/lows for the day with high momentum behind the move. Rev is a trend follower and opens trades on pull backs.
About draw downs... I have no clue. my personal experience with Keltner pro is, when I bought it, it was having the worst month and my first 16 trades were negative, and my account was -15% in its first month, it picked up later and right now my account is +15% (so yeah, it made 35% last month).... For Rev it's been the opposite experience so far, it's been in the black from day one and that account too is +15% for the first 2 weeks. What happens moving forward, I have no clue.
If I had to pick one or the other, at this point, I'd pick Rev. But I like them both. I hope this helps answer your question.
Nov 10, 2014 at 10:15
saaedb posted:
@vladrac , even if you average down the first month gains to what they gained later, they both are still pretty good EAs. I don't understand why you keep beating up on that point.
@jamesphuc, from what I can tell, they both are very good EAs and both are different style. Keltnerpro trades momentum and would would sell or buy new highs/lows for the day with high momentum behind the move. Rev is a trend follower and opens trades on pull backs.
About draw downs... I have no clue. my personal experience with Keltner pro is, when I bought it, it was having the worst month and my first 16 trades were negative, and my account was -15% in its first month, it picked up later and right now my account is +15% (so yeah, it made 35% last month).... For Rev it's been the opposite experience so far, it's been in the black from day one and that account too is +15% for the first 2 weeks. What happens moving forward, I have no clue.
If I had to pick one or the other, at this point, I'd pick Rev. But I like them both. I hope this helps answer your question.
Keep beating up on that point? Do you care to explain how was I doing that?
Also, did I say anything that was NOT true?
Please tell me how much did this EA risked "per event" in the month of March!?
vladrac@
Nov 10, 2014 at 12:22
Hi Bullish,
Thanks for your very frank, honest comments and advice.
Congratulations to you for getting back to GAIN + MARK from the negative at beginning month.
Well, for Rev Trader Pro ea, how much % risk (MM%) did you set up per pair? Or you only set up FIXED LOTS like the vendor?
If you set up fixed lot size, then, for 1k, what is your fixed lot size?
What broker are you using for Rev Trader Pro ea? DOES THIS EA produce different results at different brokers? Anybody has got this practical experience, please share it here for all of us to study.
++ About Keltner Pro EA, I noticed that the creator just released the new version that has Break-even point added in order to move stop loss to Break-even point as soon as the trades are in +++ Pips gain. So, how do you think about this new feature of Keltner Pro EA? Have you tried this new version?
Waiting for your reply and further explanations soon.
Thanks and regards,
James
Thanks for your very frank, honest comments and advice.
Congratulations to you for getting back to GAIN + MARK from the negative at beginning month.
Well, for Rev Trader Pro ea, how much % risk (MM%) did you set up per pair? Or you only set up FIXED LOTS like the vendor?
If you set up fixed lot size, then, for 1k, what is your fixed lot size?
What broker are you using for Rev Trader Pro ea? DOES THIS EA produce different results at different brokers? Anybody has got this practical experience, please share it here for all of us to study.
++ About Keltner Pro EA, I noticed that the creator just released the new version that has Break-even point added in order to move stop loss to Break-even point as soon as the trades are in +++ Pips gain. So, how do you think about this new feature of Keltner Pro EA? Have you tried this new version?
Waiting for your reply and further explanations soon.
Thanks and regards,
James
Nov 10, 2014 at 12:30
i want to say 2 things:
1.
the support is great
2.
ea trades on my ic markets live account same trades like jareds myfxbookaccount.
i can recomment this ea. i bought the first time in 3 times because i want to look if i can make a refund without problems. and all was correct i get my refund and jared was with all things correct.
after my refund was on my account i bought the ea in one time and i am very happy with it and i can recomment this ea and the great work and support what developper makes.
1.
the support is great
2.
ea trades on my ic markets live account same trades like jareds myfxbookaccount.
i can recomment this ea. i bought the first time in 3 times because i want to look if i can make a refund without problems. and all was correct i get my refund and jared was with all things correct.
after my refund was on my account i bought the ea in one time and i am very happy with it and i can recomment this ea and the great work and support what developper makes.
Nov 10, 2014 at 12:55
@jamesphuc 3% risk for REV and 5% risk for Keltnerpro. I'm going to bump up the risk for REV to 5% too.
@vladrac I'm not trying to be rude, I've just read about you saying the first month insane risk many times, and my point is, and I could be wrong, that even if you take out the first month's gains out of the equation, they both are still pretty good EAs. And I also didn't say you're not telling the truth, all I'm saying is ignoring thay one month doesn't make either of the EA any less attractive.
@vladrac I'm not trying to be rude, I've just read about you saying the first month insane risk many times, and my point is, and I could be wrong, that even if you take out the first month's gains out of the equation, they both are still pretty good EAs. And I also didn't say you're not telling the truth, all I'm saying is ignoring thay one month doesn't make either of the EA any less attractive.
Nov 10, 2014 at 14:07
saaedb posted:
@vladrac I'm not trying to be rude, I've just read about you saying the first month insane risk many times, and my point is, and I could be wrong, that even if you take out the first month's gains out of the equation, they both are still pretty good EAs. And I also didn't say you're not telling the truth, all I'm saying is ignoring thay one month doesn't make either of the EA any less attractive.
Understood...
But if you read my previous post you will see that I still think this EA has a good performance.
But, many ppl will blindly read the 2000% and think that can achieve that risk "free".
Thats why my comment.
I believe in interpreting and sharing things clearly so anyone can make a judgement on these EAs... even though many ppl dont have the fundamentals to do so...
Another failure is to analyze Pips gained... I can generate 100 pips , by entering 10 trades at the same time and only winning 10 pips in each trade!
In the end of the day you will read 100 pips win... but was it really?
Cheers,
Vlad
vladrac@
Nov 12, 2014 at 07:36
talking about rev trader pro verses keltner pro;did some research and found pdf instructions on bestearobots.com.could they both be by same person.?they both have same 2 brokers to choose from; same vps; same company for help to install.for me is no problem.i have keltner pro and intend to buy rev trader pro in future.they both seem to be top of a lot of lists on internet.they also are 2 ea;s with over well over $200;000 profit on live accounts.both simply the best performance of any ea;s available right now.i dont look at lot size;but amount of pips won;stop loss; take profit; and most important to me average pips per trade.many commercial ea;s on lists and websites have good results till you see average 1-2 pips per trade;meaning close to spread for profit.
Nov 08, 2014からメンバー
11 投稿
Nov 12, 2014 at 07:54
I bought the several days ago, but I could not install it on the vps, when I add the EA, the system noted that"dear user, our licensing server seems to be no available or you have no internet,Please recover internet or try later agin. 'Ask_price_label' will not work. Please restart metatrader to try again".
First the internet is normal ,because MT4 can run well.
And then, I am sure that VPS has not install any antivirus or firewall software.
And, I try install Microsoft .net framework 3.5 and visual C++ 2010 on the VPS, but the EA cann't work yet.
Anybody has suggestion?
Tks.
First the internet is normal ,because MT4 can run well.
And then, I am sure that VPS has not install any antivirus or firewall software.
And, I try install Microsoft .net framework 3.5 and visual C++ 2010 on the VPS, but the EA cann't work yet.
Anybody has suggestion?
Tks.
付属品:
Nov 12, 2014 at 11:10
i think something went wrong with install;i have no keltner band lines on mine you can see.i could not installl manually on vps ;because firefox could not read source code.and would not open .never had that issue before.so install with wizard.make sure you un zip installer first.delete current intall and start again.thats all i can think of.then e-mail seller if not work.
Nov 08, 2014からメンバー
11 投稿
Nov 12, 2014 at 19:33
... Next time you ask yourself, stop hunters? market manipulation... nah, there's no such thing...
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/11/12/us-banks-forex-settlement-cftc-idUSKCN0IW0E520141112
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/11/12/us-banks-forex-settlement-cftc-idUSKCN0IW0E520141112
vladrac@
forex_trader_123180
Apr 18, 2013からメンバー
20 投稿
Nov 13, 2014 at 07:45
vladrac posted:
... Next time you ask yourself, stop hunters? market manipulation... nah, there's no such thing...
http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/11/12/us-banks-forex-settlement-cftc-idUSKCN0IW0E520141112
can you recommend so good eas i can buy?
