ロード中...
Myfxbook.comを続ける
Myfxbook.comを続ける
Čeština
Deutsch
English
Español
Français
Indonesia
Latviešu
Melayu
Polski
Português(Brasil)
Português(Portugal)
Slovenčina
Svenska
Türkçe
Vietnamese
Русский
हिंदी
ไทย
日本語
简体字
繁體中文
한국어
サインイン
登録
Open an account with FOREX.com
政経カレンダー
Interest Rates
FX Calculators
ニュース
スプレッド
センチメント
外国為替ヒートマップ
相関
Market Hours
ホーム
VPTrader
投稿
共有
このページを共有！
Advertisement
VPTrader
による投稿
1
2
1
2
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 13:43
@FxMasterGuru Yes, I agree. That would be great. Otherwise if they could provide Mt4 access during a longer period.The broker is LMAX UK. Any opinions? I also belive you can chose other brokers aswell, but will check that up.I see. No worries. Just curious.Regarding http://forexmanager.co.za/ do you have any thoughts in general? Here I actually know a guy who have been with those traders for quite some time and you have verified past performance on MFB. You also have the choice to chose between brokers. The strategy is somewhat not as clear (news trading with low frequency) and there seem to b...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 12:56
@FxMasterGuru Was not this same answer posted by @Paracelsus66 for a few minutes ago? Now it is edited. Are you managing these two different profiles or is there a bug on MFB? 😕
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 12:55
@Paracelsus66 Thanks for you reply.1. I see. I am also only familiar with MFB. When calculating DD, all open positions are included, are they not? And all withdraws and deposits are calculated so they not interfere with the actual performance?2. Ok, great. Then I know that they could not refuse this simply becuse it takes to much time. It should be an easy fix if they are serious enought.3. I agree. I get a serious impression, but of course it needs to be verified through MFB and preferably Mt4 access aswell. I will ask for this during my meetings.Anything more of use to add? :)Thanks
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 10:44
@FxMasterGuru Here is from Foyle:http://foylecapital.com/factsheet.pdf
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 09:59
@FxMasterGuru Here is some accounts from Swiss direkt. Of course, they still need to be verified, and not 5 % each month, but still looks good to me. One is only 10 k minimum initial deposit:http://topsheets.net/TopSheet.aspx?crmCustRep=1&topSheetId=107&id=3010&pdf=1&view=1http://topsheets.net/TopSheet.aspx?crmCustRep=1&topSheetId=107&id=3008&pdf=1&view=1http://topsheets.net/TopSheet.aspx?crmCustRep=1&topSheetId=107&id=3006&pdf=1&view=1http://topsheets.net/TopSheet.aspx?crmCustRep=1&topSheet...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 20, 2015 at 09:56
Thanks.1-2. Yes, that´s basically what I meant. The important part is whether you approach them, asking for comfirmation rather than they approaching you "selling" the solutions. For Anmaric, Perfecto etc. you can read about them all over, and there is also a lot of "rubberband ads" all over the internet.Question: a) Would you prefer MFB next to ie. FXBlue or other third partys? And why? b) I guess live access to Mt4, seeking trades in real time is better than seeing the solutions through a third party? Especially if the trades are not lagging...3. Agree, but they sho...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 19, 2015 at 14:52
@FxMasterGuru Thanks.1. I see. So even real time mt4 access is not sufficient enought since it has some lagging involved (in those specific cases)? But if it would not be laggning, would you trust it?2. Yes, agree....3. Of course. I understand.4. Makes sense.5. Absolutely. You need to work with greater amounts and still diversify, so in funds, the risk i higher.Sorry, seems like the other strategies did not show in my other comments. Here is what I wrote:http://forexmanager.co.za/http://www.myfxbook.com/members/ForexManagerDBAhttp://www.foylecapital.com/http://www.swissdirekt.ch/en/home-en/Wha...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 19, 2015 at 06:23
@FxMasterGuru *The last to above don´t show their results on MFB though, but making it easy to manipulate the results, perhaps those larger firms don´t even bother to use those third party solutions, simply because they don´t have to. Both Swiss Direkt and Foyle looks good. I will take meeting, but all input would be appreciated.Thanks,
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 19, 2015 at 06:22
Thanks for your replay.I believe no brokers can be trusted in this industry, not even the "mainstream" or big ones. Just look at Alpari and FXCM UK earlier this year (have the people who helds funds at Alpari still been compensated?) Being able to really trust the brokers you need to move over to more regulated markets, like futures, and for example trade the FX futures listed on CME. But of course, some FX brokers might be better that others, and having an UK registered broker might be better than a small from NZ.So PAMM is more safe the MAM? Could you explain further.What else woul...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 19, 2015 at 06:21
@FxMasterGuru I agree with you on all parts. But to sum up: can you then ever trust the results from a third party (i.e MFB or FXBlue) what so ever? And in that case, what would you like to see? If then watching the trades in real time on Mt4 an comparing with the prices from other brokers would that be sufficient or could it still be fabricated?Do you agree with @ScalpingRus that PAMM is a lot safer than MAM? Making it harder to manipulate.Also, do you need to "own" the broker to fabricate the results or could it be done in other ways to aswell (not co-operating with the broker)?I ...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 17, 2015 at 06:40
@FxMasterGuru Also, do you belive that FPA:s live test on Anmaric RHO counts for nothing? http://www.forexpeacearmy.com/managed_forex_performance/anmaric_rho_programm/realI mean, the reason for FPA doing this is to detect scams, bot of course, if the data is maniuplated through the broker, perhaps it will "pass" the FPA test aswell?It sure gives some credability though...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 17, 2015 at 06:33
@FxMasterGuru Thanks for your quick respons.I agree that parts are quite suspicious. Let´s say it is a sophisticated scheme, is there any way for us, to actually know and find proof? I mean, is it even possible to get more information than what we have as for now? It sounds like you know a lot about the fx industry, would it be possible to verify their live trades and compare those to other brokers in real time, making sure that those are actually real trades being taken, creating these results?I have also asked the question about providing another broker, for transparency reasons, and s...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 16, 2015 at 14:40
@FxMasterGuru What about this manager: http://www.myfxbook.com/members/ForexManagerDBAResults looks good on all accounts, no big DDs. I know a guy who has one of those accounts and can verify, through broker statements that this i legit. Funds have been deposited and withdrawed without issues through FXCM. According to him, the FXCM has also shut several accounts down on several occasions (basically kicked the clients out), probably because the performance have been "to good" which have led them to losses (not being able to hedge short and quite big positions). All input and feedback...
5% average monthly profit for at least 2 years (with less than 25% max. DD)
経験豊富なトレーダー
の中
Apr 16, 2015 at 12:30
@FxMasterGuru I have been reading through the "over two year long discussion" and also been reading on some other forums etc regarding those specific strategies/companies: Anmaric, PerfectoFX and also 5Gulden who are all using the same NZ broker, 3TG Brokers. I also have my suspicions, but as for now, is there any hard proofs that this is a "scam" in any sort of way? I have read a lof of suspicious thoughts, and agree that some parts are at least "odd" but would like to know if anyone on this forum actually can prove anything?On the contrary, does anyone have any ...
You have an Ad Blocker!
Myfxbook is a site supported by advertisements. Here are two ways for you to continue browsing:
Ad Free Subscription
および
Disable your Ad Blocker
Already subscribed?
サインイン
ログインしていません
この機能は登録メンバーのみが利用できます。
登録は無料で1分もかかりません。
登録ボタンをクリックして続行します。
あなたがすでにメンバーで私たちのサービスを楽しんでいるなら、後はサインインするのみです。
Keep up to date with the markets
Enable notifications to receive real-time important market updates:
政経カレンダー
外国為替ニュース
You can disable notifications at any time from your browser.
Unblock Notifications
You've blocked browser notifications for Myfxbook.com. Please enable it:
You can disable notifications at any time from your browser.
過去
コンセンサス
実際
