stephanusRの投稿 - 3ページ

Winsor's Five Trading EAs in Real Time 経験豊富なトレーダーの中 Sep 26, 2010 at 20:04

That was a demo account one of many I have blown in testing my methods. Click on general and you will see it is marked demo for broker fxpro. Do you want me to upload all 30 of my demo accounts from FxOpen, Alpari and Fxpro, that I have blown? What counts is an audited tax return of all real accounts. You avoided the question, which is noted. On myfxbook we can create a Harry Potter make believe world , but in the real world the IRS or Canadian tax authority wants to know about all those real accounts from Belize, Switzerland , even those hiding in fronting companies at Mauritius . They want...

Access Control For Public Profile 提案ボックスの中 Sep 26, 2010 at 17:11

Before one invests in a PAMM one would want to see all the trades to figure out what was the draw-down on each to see if the risk was excessive . One should not invest in a system that hides this information.

Winsor's Five Trading EAs in Real Time 経験豊富なトレーダーの中 Sep 26, 2010 at 16:12

Your three listed real systems haven't been updated for days now, then there are those 9 systems on http://app.currensee.com/forexpert/external/profile/WIHFG.A , Are they all registered in your name or is it other people's money you are taking risks with?

Winsor's Five Trading EAs in Real Time 経験豊富なトレーダーの中 Sep 26, 2010 at 16:01

From which of the 123 real accounts held in the names of your clients that you are trading with no risk to yourself? Stephanus Rensburg (stephanusR) a moment agohttp://www.myfxbook.com/community/trading-systems/wwwctsforexcom-jasmine-real--account/53272,1At http://www.ctsforex.com/FOREX-TRADING-SOFTWARE-SELECTION.html you claim a track record for Jasmine back to March 2009, but myfxbook.com has only verified this account as having operated for two months. Your last update was 21 Sept, where is 22,23 and 24 Sept?Please explain.At http://app.currensee.com/forexpert/external/profile/WIHFG.A you ...

CTSForex.com Jasmine Real $$$ Account Aggressive 取引システムの中 Sep 26, 2010 at 15:49

At http://www.ctsforex.com/FOREX-TRADING-SOFTWARE-SELECTION.html you claim a track record for Jasmine back to March 2009, but myfxbook.com has only verified this account as having operated for two months. Your last update was 21 Sept, where is 22,23 and 24 Sept? Please explain. At http://app.currensee.com/forexpert/external/profile/WIHFG.A you list nine real accounts but on myfxbook.com you are only showing us three real accounts. How many real accounts do you have . What is the total return across all your accounts. These accounts are not your own personal money but those of investors, thus y...

MA-six 取引システムの中 Sep 25, 2010 at 14:58

How many Oanda sub accounts do you have and are you running an automated system using the oanda API? You have a good return on equity for the period employed, but need to have month on month of positive returns for at least 12 months to fully reflect the trends, counter trends and break-outs the market will experience. Just one month of negative equity would be red flag. Best of luck in your trading. 41 winners out of 42 is very good, but myfxbook needs to display the draw-downs of each individual trade weighted as % of equity as discussed in the suggestion box. This is your http://thesixthru...

Alpari-Real-Risk10 取引システムの中 Sep 23, 2010 at 06:22

-

Looking for Good Forex Traders To Trade My Capital 経験豊富なトレーダーの中 Sep 21, 2010 at 17:22

It does take $5000 to open an offshore account which for a firm like http://www.myfxbook.com/members/WhyLose is no problem because he does it with other peoples money. He lists three winning accounts, the other 134 losing he doesn't tell us about. On http://www.whylose.com/ he writes "...Our blog posts some of the trades we make automatically via our Trade Copier...."We want to know about all the trades from all the accounts with the net gain or loss as % of equity employed. He lists three winning accounts each with a deposit of $3000, $3000 and $10000 for a total of $16000. Th...

Manage Account 取引システムの中 Sep 21, 2010 at 10:09

Did you really deposit $100 000 with a bucketshop in Panama or Hong Kong? Why did you not place such a large amount with mbtrading.com rather. Who in Hong Kong gave you a fx trading license or is everything just excel entries on spread sheet linked to a cracked copy of mt4 servers edition. You have uploaded two winning accounts , where are your other 53 losing accounts, when will they be uploaded? http://sparenfx.com/content/aboutus/contact.htmlPhysical AddressSPAREN DATA SERVICES(Customer technical support only)Global Bank Tower, Floor 12th, Office 1214Calle 50, Panama city, PanamaSPARENFX1...

Looking for Good Forex Traders To Trade My Capital 経験豊富なトレーダーの中 Sep 21, 2010 at 09:35

Main problem with money managers are that they can setup hundreds of off-shore companies and hedge funds and only show you the funds that make money leaving out the losing accounts. They setup 100 EA's and let it trade these 100 funds automatically. You would need to get this fund managers audited tax return, what is he trading for himself. He must be able to show his 50 losing and 3 winning accounts in his personal name, the same losing accounts he shows the tax man. If he can't do this then the only way to quantify his trading skill would be a single http://www.stocktwits.com account...

New EA 'Euphoria' started on Fx book プログラミングの中 Sep 20, 2010 at 06:41

technical analysis go haywire with major news releases such as NFP. How do you adjust your indicators for NFP?

length of position holding vs. pips profit 提案ボックスの中 Sep 18, 2010 at 18:52

It is up to the evaluator of the system. Myfxbook.com won't implement it though because the site is driven by ads. One would have to have an automation script that automatically downloads all the top 100 CSV files and then run an excel, python script to generate this number. Same problem with collective2.com, they don't present the trading stats in such a way that the true risk: reward ratio is clear. Risk:reward quantifies the long term sustainability of a trading method, its statistical edge. If we can reduce a jumbled mass of numbers to a single ratio we would make significant strid...

length of position holding vs. pips profit 提案ボックスの中 Sep 18, 2010 at 12:07

Another idea is to merge the length of time held factor with the pips gain : draw-down factor , if a position remains in draw down for to long and subsequently rallies, any such rally would be more due to random luck then market insight. See http://www.myfxbook.com/community/suggestion-box/add-column-for-draw-down/52604,11) The length a losing position was held must be factored. If a losing position takes to long to rally then the "random luck" factor increases. Each trade is assigned a "random luck" factor weighted for equity used, meaning a standard lot will have more im...

Add a column for draw down on each trade 提案ボックスの中 Sep 18, 2010 at 11:27

http://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?p=4011537#post4011537Let's focus on this point a bit here. Can you disclose here how you have audited for each of your "managers" the following: 1. Operational risk 2. Investment risk 3. Liquidity riskAnd can you disclose the full audit protocol and audit trail for each of your managers?Furthermore can you disclose the individual investment and risk processes of each of your managers?Poster cloggie from FF has some additional insights we could incorporate. We need to have a database of every winning system from collective2.com, tr...

Amalgamate Oanda sub accounts 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 21:50

Lets rather not, we nearly had the world economy collapse because of systemic misrepresentation fraud form the lowest Russian hacker peddling EA's the hotshot traders at AIG writing naked put options. We need to dispel the myths and insist on evidence, facts that can be falsified as I explained in this google group thread: http://groups.google.com/group/futures-trading/browse_frm/thread/2ecad27b1e1aa13bA series of 22 posts that will enable an investor to critically evaluate claims and conclude that virtually nobody is making money in forex. If you think you can, then provide a means for ...

Add a column for draw down on each trade 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 11:39

It doesn't make your system look "bad", it just accurately quantifies the fact that your system involves large equity draw-downs and states this as a factor. The system might be profitable but then such profits must be large to compensate for the draw down which the pip-gain-factor will do. If your draw-down is 200 pips and your profit is 200 pips, then your weighted pips gain: weighted draw down factor would still be the same as 10 pip gain : 10 pip drawdown. Making 10 pips on 200 draw down would be unacceptable risk. In some cases 200:200 might not be acceptable, one should s...

Amalgamate Oanda sub accounts 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 09:43

Richard Dawkins chided people for their 'fallacy of incredulity' . David Berlinski replied " .... In appealing to the animidversions of others, he appeals to his own ability to believe almost anything ...." The investing public like Dawkins also do believe anything they are told which is why the Nasdaq hit 5000 points. Enron, Leahman , scams , hoaxes, UFO's etc. This inability to question things is why we have thousands of people trading forex, wasting their money and time ignoring the fact that 99% will eventually lose, only a few individuals manage to time the markets...

Add a column for draw down on each trade 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 09:34

Thus one doesn't have to manually read through pages of trades to find a winning system, the (pip-gain-factor) allows a single number to quantify whether random luck or true trading skill was demonstrated, and it can easily be implemented in a spread sheet or script.

Add a column for draw down on each trade 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 08:55

yes, one could do also do it graphically , it quantifies the risk/reward ratio. As a general rule if you make 10pips profit your drawdown should be no more than 10pips for a 1:1 profit ratio. Each trade's pip:drawdown ratio is then weighted as a % of deposit or equity. Every single weighted trade is then combined and then averaged for a single parameter which we shall callWeighted pips gain : weighted draw down (pip-gain-factor). Thus a standard lot trade that employed 10% of equity for a gain of 10pips for a draw down of 10 pips will have a higher positive pip-gain-factor than a micr...

Add a column for trade duration 提案ボックスの中 Sep 17, 2010 at 05:32

I made another suggestion for having a draw-down column. EAch trade's pip gain and duration must be expressed as a function of draw down in order to quantify the risk the trade was exposed to. If the trade was to long in draw-down mode before turning a profit it would mean the trader was lucky. We don't want to trade on luck but on insight.

全引用
AUDUSD	0.653	USDCHF	0.9147
EURJPY	169.15	EURCHF	0.9785
EURGBP	0.8563	GBPJPY	197.36
EURUSD	1.0699	GBPUSD	1.2487
USDJPY	158.04	USDCAD	1.3679

EURUSD	1.0699	GBPUSD	1.2487
USDJPY	158.04	USDCAD	1.3679

stephanusRによる投稿