- Trang chủ
- Cộng đồng
- Nhà giao dịch mới
- Manual or EA? I have done well with EA but most are scared, ...
Edit Your Comment
Manual or EA? I have done well with EA but most are scared, why?
Tham gia từ Dec 12, 2014
18bài viết
May 19, 2020 at 19:05
Tham gia từ Dec 12, 2014
18bài viết
I was wondering why people don't use an EA to trade, instead of doing the trades manually.
Is anyone here using an EA to carry out their trades?
If so, do you use your own EA?
Is anyone here using an EA to carry out their trades?
If so, do you use your own EA?
Investors always comes first.
Tham gia từ Feb 22, 2011
4573bài viết
May 25, 2020 at 11:09
Tham gia từ Feb 22, 2011
4573bài viết
serk1 posted:
I was wondering why people don't use an EA to trade, instead of doing the trades manually.
Is anyone here using an EA to carry out their trades?
If so, do you use your own EA?
I would say people are lazy.
Lazy people just buy some EA created by someone else without understanding how it works.
As result they lose money twice
- when they pay for EA
- when they got loses on their account
That's why I never sell EAs. I do mirror trades from my account to theirs and get paid only where there is profit
Tham gia từ Jul 23, 2020
816bài viết
Oct 07, 2021 at 14:50
Tham gia từ Jul 23, 2020
816bài viết
I prefer manual trading. It’s fun.
Tham gia từ Jul 23, 2020
696bài viết
Oct 07, 2021 at 20:58
Tham gia từ Jul 23, 2020
696bài viết
EA is good for those who cannot control their emotion.
Tham gia từ Dec 26, 2019
21bài viết
Oct 15, 2021 at 19:16
Tham gia từ Dec 26, 2019
21bài viết
I guess there is nothing better than manual trading, mainly because such types of trading activity can possibly bring you much more experience and skills rather than auto-trading. Of course, we shouldn't underestimate the work of EAs and it's quite spread across all the market, nevertheless if you haven't got enough experience, you would better stay off the idea of using EAs mainly because the main task for you is to learn how to trade professionally an earn money. The process of searching for EAs is quite long and you will just waste of your time I guess, nevertheless if you want, then you can try.
Centrillador
Tham gia từ Oct 18, 2021
60bài viết
Oct 19, 2021 at 12:49
Tham gia từ Oct 18, 2021
60bài viết
I can use both manual and ea tradiing. everything depends my time. If I had a lot of free time I prefer manual trading. If I am going sleep or go out then I can use ea.
Tham gia từ Mar 03, 2019
57bài viết
Oct 21, 2021 at 11:57
Tham gia từ Mar 03, 2019
57bài viết
I am a manual trader. I have often thought about going down the EA route but haven't as yet.
Tham gia từ Oct 21, 2021
3bài viết
Tham gia từ Mar 15, 2019
76bài viết
Oct 24, 2021 at 23:49
Tham gia từ Mar 15, 2019
76bài viết
It's better to do both IMO.... I run an EA which is predominantly for scalping... But if I see an opportunity, I use a separate manual account for throwing down swing trades.
All or nothing
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
Oct 27, 2021 at 17:15
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
I think both are good. EA can trade more hours but manual trading gives your quality trades. Whichever works for you, then do that.
Trading is a marathon, not a sprint.
Tham gia từ Jul 19, 2020
749bài viết
Oct 28, 2021 at 09:21
Tham gia từ Jul 19, 2020
749bài viết
I like manual trading. I don't like to use EA to trade. It's like I am trusting someone else strategy without knowing anything about it. I don't know based on which strategy is made.
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
Oct 28, 2021 at 10:20
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
UweMoench posted:
I like manual trading. I don't like to use EA to trade. It's like I am trusting someone else strategy without knowing anything about it. I don't know based on which strategy is made.
Of course, you will like manual trading because that's what you know. What if you are the one who made the EA out of the strategy that you're using to trade manually? Would you feel the same way? It's obviously useless to use an EA or a strategy without having any confidence on it.
Trading is a marathon, not a sprint.
Tham gia từ Aug 28, 2020
29bài viết
Oct 28, 2021 at 12:19
Tham gia từ Aug 28, 2020
29bài viết
Since I'm still a beginner with only six months of live trading experience, I prefer a trading manual to learn more about forex markets to develop new skills and strategies.
Tham gia từ Oct 21, 2021
3bài viết
Tham gia từ Oct 17, 2018
99bài viết
Oct 30, 2021 at 17:07
Tham gia từ Oct 17, 2018
99bài viết
I currently work on manual trading, I think it's good practice to have understanding of how to trade in order to use an EA. I am starting to work on EA's but it takes time to do the back testing to get the settings right to make any good money. I feel more in control when I trade manually so I think it is how I will trade going forward. Not against having an EA working in the background making a little more money though.
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
Oct 31, 2021 at 18:59
Tham gia từ Aug 27, 2017
84bài viết
There's no difference really. Not all strategy can be converted to a trading bot anyway so you can only trade manually. If some or all of the parts of the trading system can be converted to an automated process, then of course, it's way better because it will lessen the stress and effort on your end. I don't see the point of choosing one over the other.
People who strictly choose manual trading only thinks that they have the control but unfortunately, there's too much uncertain parts with the financial markets. If some things will help you control some parts of the trading process, that will always be the best path.
People who strictly choose manual trading only thinks that they have the control but unfortunately, there's too much uncertain parts with the financial markets. If some things will help you control some parts of the trading process, that will always be the best path.
Trading is a marathon, not a sprint.
Tham gia từ Mar 17, 2021
494bài viết
Dec 11, 2021 at 06:11
Tham gia từ Mar 17, 2021
494bài viết
croisssan posted:
I am an advocate of manual trading. I have nothing against robots, but I trust manual trading more.
I also think that manual trading will be the best option for a trader.
Tham gia từ Oct 19, 2020
8bài viết
Feb 03, 2022 at 14:58
Tham gia từ Oct 19, 2020
8bài viết
Of course, I heard about algrotrading. Maybe someday I will try it too, but there’s one thing that is more important for me. It’s manual trading. I haven’t started trading on a real account yet, so I think that it’s too early for me to think about robots. I hope soon I will open a real account and get down to real trading. I think I have tried everything on a demo account and I feel a strong need to test myself on a real account.
I heard a lot about great difference between trading on a demo account and trading real money. Of course, I expect a huge stress. I don’t think that there’s something wrong with my nerves, but I do expect that it will not be very easy. So, manual trading on a real account is the thing I try to prepare myself for now.
I think I will try trading robots once I gain enough experience on a real account trading manually. I don’t want to try robots earlier.
I heard a lot about great difference between trading on a demo account and trading real money. Of course, I expect a huge stress. I don’t think that there’s something wrong with my nerves, but I do expect that it will not be very easy. So, manual trading on a real account is the thing I try to prepare myself for now.
I think I will try trading robots once I gain enough experience on a real account trading manually. I don’t want to try robots earlier.

*Nghiêm cấm sử dụng cho mục đích thương mại và spam, nếu vi phạm có thể dẫn đến việc chấm dứt tài khoản.
Mẹo: Đăng ảnh/url youtube sẽ tự động được nhúng vào bài viết của bạn!
Mẹo: Dùng @ để tự động điền tên người dùng tham gia vào cuộc thảo luận này.