Advertisement
The GOAT: Bob Volman Fanatics
Feb 17, 2020 at 13:31
4,315浏览
8 Replies
会员从Jan 14, 2019开始
6帖子
Feb 17, 2020 at 13:31
Greetings Baby Pippettes ,
I personally have found Bob Volman’s material quite comprehensive and accurate. Although a bit challenging to digest on first glance, I am a strong advocate of his vantage point and psycological forces in the market specifically the 5min charts.
I am writing this to post to see if anyone has also found a similar respect for his material and to see if anyone can offer any insight as to how it has worked out for them and adjustments (especially provided that his material is a few years old). Nevertheless the current underlying principles are there and I want to expand on it.
If anyone has any suggested read or worked on this extensively (or passively) happy to hear from you.
Thank you for your time.
I personally have found Bob Volman’s material quite comprehensive and accurate. Although a bit challenging to digest on first glance, I am a strong advocate of his vantage point and psycological forces in the market specifically the 5min charts.
I am writing this to post to see if anyone has also found a similar respect for his material and to see if anyone can offer any insight as to how it has worked out for them and adjustments (especially provided that his material is a few years old). Nevertheless the current underlying principles are there and I want to expand on it.
If anyone has any suggested read or worked on this extensively (or passively) happy to hear from you.
Thank you for your time.
Apr 12, 2020 at 16:52
Nope. Because if it worked, he wouldn’t need to sell books with advice. The only time I take advice from a book is if I know he/she makes more from the book than the skill.
I’m the case of Forex, the skill pays more than than the book, if they were any good then they wouldn’t be selling books.
I’m the case of Forex, the skill pays more than than the book, if they were any good then they wouldn’t be selling books.
会员从Jan 01, 2020开始
19帖子
Jun 21, 2020 at 14:59
It's not bad if you have certain guidelines on the market or someone whose approach you like and whose motivation is certain.
Perhaps his approach is really close to you and will help you to understand some nuances, but you should not copy things completely, still the market is unique at every moment ...
Perhaps his approach is really close to you and will help you to understand some nuances, but you should not copy things completely, still the market is unique at every moment ...
会员从Jan 14, 2019开始
6帖子
Jun 21, 2020 at 17:50
Thanks for the inputs Thorgahuginn. I agree. I dont copy his trategy completely. Its hard for any real progress in any field to not be somewhat related to what progress some else has made. (Hence in working in silos).
I've modified it to fit my own style and created a youtube page based on some of its inner workings. Check it out if you get the chacne.
&t=3s
I've modified it to fit my own style and created a youtube page based on some of its inner workings. Check it out if you get the chacne.
&t=3s
会员从Jun 19, 2020开始
2帖子
Jun 25, 2020 at 11:30
As per my opinion, forex books are quite knowledgeable and helpful to a great extent. Also, it gives motivation to keep learning in forex. Having your own skills is equally important as everyone has their own way of trading with different styles. Having an open mind here can make you learn things from everywhere possible. It’s good to explore new ways of learning.
会员从Jul 23, 2020开始
696帖子
Oct 10, 2020 at 10:16
uxStyle posted:
Nope. Because if it worked, he wouldn’t need to sell books with advice. The only time I take advice from a book is if I know he/she makes more from the book than the skill.
I’m the case of Forex, the skill pays more than than the book, if they were any good then they wouldn’t be selling books.
Book is good for learning. Trader can gain knowledge from expert trader experience. Some books are also inspiring which I think we needed most.
会员从Jun 30, 2020开始
43帖子
Oct 19, 2020 at 12:38
Thanks for sharing, been on a lookout for good resources.
会员从Jan 14, 2019开始
6帖子
Oct 30, 2020 at 00:34
Thanks for sharing, been on a lookout for good resources.
Here's something that may help. Created a study guide a while back. A bit outdated but most of the great content Bob Volman has in his book is summarized in this study guide. There are a few additional add ons but I remain true to the core of his principles.
https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/733640-understanding-price-action-by-bob-volman-notes-and?page=5
Recommend reading both books.
附件:
会员从May 31, 2024开始
1帖子
May 31, 2024 at 20:45
Thanks for sharing, been on a lookout for good resources.
*商业用途和垃圾邮件将不被容忍，并可能导致账户终止。
提示：发布图片/YouTube网址会自动嵌入到您的帖子中！
提示：键入@符号，自动完成参与此讨论的用户名。
