FxPapa Expert Advisor讨论

Hi rgmann

That sucks!

I was lucky, and I think my fxpapa is working well thankfully.

Here is mine so far:

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/lxboston/fx-papa/278860

You might want to check your journal to see if there was an error with your broker.

Also I might note that on the 10th mine opened two GBPUSD trades when the flagship one only opened one, they both closed at the same time or same TP

This was beneficial however, if it was a loosing trade could have gotten messy

   rgmann posted:
   Once again I got today's losing trade, but not the second winning trade. So the problem of missing signals is still happening! Here's my account stats so you can see for yourself...

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/rgmann/rgm-real/197153

It would sure be nice if I missed the losing trade every once in a while!

FxPapa seems to have malfunctioned on me too.

It took 2 trades but, the second one, which is supposed to compensate for the first trade's loss, did not do so. I ended up losing 32.1 pips. About 1 week of profits down the drain.

FxPapa, please help us out, here.

Dear Roger & Alec

We are creating a testing tool. Kindly contact our support and provide them with the information they ask.

Regards

Hello FXpapa,

for your chart which broker you use. My broker closed the winning position 10 min later. My Account has loose yesterday.

Regards

Hi FxPapa,

The 3rd and 4th lines are missing from your message on my chart:
'Successfully connected to the FxPapa Server.
Account Number verified.'

I have restarted the MT4 platform, but those lines are still missing.

This is presently of great concern because there are two orders open.

   ragency posted:
   Hi FxPapa,

The 3rd and 4th lines are missing from your message on my chart:
'Successfully connected to the FxPapa Server.
Account Number verified.'

I have restarted the MT4 platform, but those lines are still missing.

This is presently of great concern because there are two orders open.

Hi

Don't worry. It OK. When there is any open position the EA doesn't need account number verification.

We should write this on the Manual.

Thanks for your notice.

   FxPapa posted:
   

   ragency posted:
   Hi FxPapa,

The 3rd and 4th lines are missing from your message on my chart:
'Successfully connected to the FxPapa Server.
Account Number verified.'

I have restarted the MT4 platform, but those lines are still missing.

This is presently of great concern because there are two orders open.

Hi

Don't worry. It OK. When there is any open position the EA doesn't need account number verification.

We should write this on the Manual.

Thanks for your notice.

How do I know that I won't miss future orders? This has been going on for at least 8 hours, now.

it is the bloody regular habit of fxpapa to trade always against market trend. What the hell he does always.
For only 10 pip it trades always against market trend. Oye trade always with market trend. U understood, what i said.
I dont like to pray everyday for the trades. It gives only 10 to 15% per month but the stop loss is 20%.

First learn how to trade, then take the trade. I know u trade manually.

   ajaysingh posted:
   it is the bloody regular habit of fxpapa to trade always against market trend. What the hell he does always.
For only 10 pip it trades always against market trend. Oye trade always with market trend. U understood, what i said.
I dont like to pray everyday for the trades. It gives only 10 to 15% per month but the stop loss is 20%.

First learn how to trade, then take the trade. I know u trade manually.

i feel papas strategy is sound, i watched enough trades till now. but the copier is not reliable for whatever reason, or i would have joined already.

trade copiers always seem to have certain issues, have not found one yet which has been 100%.

fxpapa.com is down?

Service Unavailable

HTTP Error 503. The service is unavailable.

try a different browser, i can get in just fine..............

It is ok now, was the same time when the error message was on the EA

ah might be hosted all on the same server then...............

   ragency posted:
   

How do I know that I won't miss future orders? This has been going on for at least 8 hours, now.

It happened to me before. It stays like that until the trades close. Then it connects again for the next trade.

   Alec posted:
   

   rgmann posted:
   Once again I got today's losing trade, but not the second winning trade. So the problem of missing signals is still happening! Here's my account stats so you can see for yourself...

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/rgmann/rgm-real/197153

It would sure be nice if I missed the losing trade every once in a while!

FxPapa seems to have malfunctioned on me too.

It took 2 trades but, the second one, which is supposed to compensate for the first trade's loss, did not do so. I ended up losing 32.1 pips. About 1 week of profits down the drain.

FxPapa, please help us out, here.

Hi FxPapa,

I've sent you several emails over the past couple of days, but haven't heard back from you yet. I'm hoping we can find a solution for the trade signals that I keep missing. I've lost over $1,000 because of this the past week. I checked my Mt4 Journal and Experts tabs, and there were not any errors present. However, on the chart that the EA is attached to it says, 'Error 721.' Do you know what that means? Please contact me as soon as possible. Thank you.

Regards,
Roger

Error 721 is a connection problem. It always be fixed shortly and automatically. Don't worry about it.

Check our website. We have 24/5 support service.

The problem is from your side. I've suggested you to let us run the EA for you on our own VPS but you refused. When you won't let us find out the problem we can't offer the solution.

FxPapa,

I think you misunderstood my last post. It wasn't meant as a complaint. I simply wasn't sure if you had received my last couple of emails yet, since I hadn't heard back from you yet (at the time I posted the above comment). I'm hoping to find a solution to the problem, and am open to any suggestions you have. I'm not sure why you think that I 'refused' your offer to run the the EA on your own VPS, since I emailed you asking how we would go about doing that. You have been very fair up to this point and made me a very generous offer. I'm posting this here so that everyone knows that you have been trying to fix this problem for me, not in order to bad mouth your product or company. So I apologize if it came across that way...

Regards,
Roger

I want to publicly thank FxPapa for finding a solution to the problem I've been experiencing on my account. He has done more than most vendors would be willing to do, and I believe that everything should work fine going forward. His support has been top notch so far! 😄

Cheers,
Roger

Hi FxPapa. Can you you explain me please what's the purpose of opening the third trade? I mean according to my calculations (lets say risk=10) the third trade will open as soon as the first open trade has reached -120 pips. But when the first open trade reaches around -125 pips (ONLY AFTER 5 PIPS) then we have already DD 10% so the basket close with lose. So the third trade is to give space to the basket only some more pips? Maybe i have miscalculated or didnt understand the risk behaviour. Please correct me if i am wrong.