KangarooEA_CFX讨论

Why do you need to hide the name of the broker?

Why do you need to hide the open trades? We would like to know the draw down.

Just another EA seller with useless DEMO. If it really makes money why don't you put it on a real account?

forexma posted:
    Just another EA seller with useless DEMO. If it really makes money why don't you put it on a real account?

Hi SOLAR,

We have been using KangarooEA on our live accounts for about a year, along with many other EAs in our library. This demo is set up to demonstrate KangarooEA's individual performance. It is not a scalper nor does it trade the quiet Asian session and since starting the demo we have seen an exact match between the demo trades and our live trades.

Your comment is a common one though. Which is fair enough, because many less reputable EA systems do use questionable brokers on demo to show unrealistic results.

Because of this, we have transferred a small amount from our trading portfolio over to a new account to show that the live and demo trades match. We will have it up on MyFxBook and on our website within the next couple of days.

Thank you for your comment.

Green Pips

Ozzie @ TulipFX.

kobebeef posted:
    Why do you need to hide the name of the broker?

Why do you need to hide the open trades? We would like to know the draw down.

Hi Kobebeef

We trade with The Collective, so use The Collective demo as we have found it identical to our live feeds.

We had live trades private while we were building up to our launch. They are now unlocked.

For any system with private open trades you can always observe their drawdown via the equity balance to the left of the main graph.


Positive equity curves


Ozzie @ TulipFX.

When does the formal holiday period end ? I know its doesn't necessarily trade every day but i wuld like to know when to look out for it

Thx

Hi ianj,

The KangarooEA is now back trading :) Just have to be patient and wait for the market to present the opportunities to trade now.

BTW, check out www.tulipfx.com if you have not recently - we will be adding a new pair to the KangarooEA soon!

look interesting,
what is the average pips per trade in back testing since 2007 in EURUSD and AUDUSD?

Hi lolik,

If you go to our website at www.tulipfx.com and download our KangarooEA whitepaper, full backtests are provided there for you to analyse.

TulipFX posted:
    Hi lolik,

If you go to our website at www.tulipfx.com and download our KangarooEA whitepaper, full backtests are provided there for you to analyse.

well, i have already done that...
it mention only profit in $$$$$$
the whitepaper does not mention average pips per trade in backtesting...

Feel free to download the backtests and do your own full analysis if there are any additional statistics you wish to obtain.

i will ask again...
i feel that you hide average pips per trade.
why?
it is not in your reports
and you keep saying that it is in the report.
it is not in the report!

We hide nothing.

Here you can see the average pips per trade on our forward test: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/TulipFX/kangarooea/56195

Here is the whitepaper: https://tulipfx.com/downloads/KangarooEAv5_Whitepaper_Feb1.pdf

Here are full backtests which you can run through an analysis program to dig out whatever information you wish: https://tulipfx.com/downloads/Kangaroo_v5_backtests.zip

There is nothing to hide. If you want any details not specifically mentioned please feel free to do your own analysis to discover them.

i will say it again
average pips per trade is not shown in your back testing report.
if you send me a backtesting report with fixed 0.1 lot
then the averege pips per trade will be the expected payoff value!

right now
average pips per trade is not shown in your back testing report!

Lolik: not that I've got anything to do with TulipFX (other than having bought Kangaroo), but as I'm getting exhausted by the Vaudeville cross-talk act:

Average Win: 18.31 pips / $534.98
Average Loss: -13.27 pips / -$392.62

based on 32 seconds' analysis having uploaded the AUDUSD backtest TulipFX posted above into the myfxbook strategy analysis applet. You can see it at https://www.myfxbook.com/strategies/kangaroo-audusd/2754 - I'll leave you to do the EURUSD yourself.

If you're trying to work out the 'pip expectancy' then of course you'll need to factor the above data into the strike rate - which is also in the strategy analyser at the link above.

Before you accuse others of lying/hiding/cheating always best, in my experience, to check you're not being dense yourself... although I do understand it's easy to make that assumption in the autotrader marketplace. For what it's worth, I've found TulipFX extremely open and responsive, and a far cry from the breathless marketing approach taken by most EA vendors.

lolik posted:
    i will say it again
average pips per trade is not shown in your back testing report.
if you send me a backtesting report with fixed 0.1 lot
then the averege pips per trade will be the expected payoff value!

right now
average pips per trade is not shown in your back testing report!

Hi lolik,

Backtest reports do not show these statistics, that is why you cannot find them , not because we are hiding or have deleted them.

If you wish please add the backtests statistics to excel or look to use an analysis program which has all kinds of extra data presented for you to make your decision on.

ok
i have done this reports to check avg pips per trade :
https://www.myfxbook.com/strategies/kangaroo-eurusd-m5/2771
https://www.myfxbook.com/strategies/kangaroo-audusd/2754

for EURUSD average pips per trade is 8.06 pips per trade
for AUDUSD average pips per trade is 9.64 pips per trade

but it says in Advanced statistics that Commission is 0$ !
how come? no commission?
so, is 8.06 pips per trade is after broker took the spread(2 pips average) or before?

lolik,

There is never any commission on backtests. The results are always after the spread is taken into account.

TulipFX,

Just wondering why in myfxbook your track record is verfied, but your trading privileges are not verified?

Hi DennisL,

Sorry for the late reply, but I didn't notice you had commented.

This demo we have done the small trades to verify trading privileges but simply have not done the small verification trades on the live account because we'd rather not corrupt its results with these trades.