Advertisement
FX Open - FX Solution EA (bei fxsolution )
| Gewinn : | +5.32% |
| Drawdown | 23.88% |
| Pips: | 133.0 |
| Trades | 74 |
| Gewonnen: |
|
| Verloren: |
|
| Typ: | Demo |
| Hebel: | - |
| Trading: | Automatisiert |
FX Open - FX Solution EA Diskussion
Jan 07, 2011 at 16:58
536 Angesehen
3 Replies
Mar 01, 2011 at 19:44
Your EA is not tracking Correctly. I have tried to contact you via email but can't get a response. I will be posting my trades so everyone can see the difference and would hope you can explain why the discrepancies.
Slow and steady wins the race.
Mar 02, 2011 at 03:13
I have been following your FX EA you have posted here: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/fxsolution/fx-open-fx-solution-ea/75464
I also have it running on a separate account at FXOPEN. I have noticed that your version seems to close trades manually? Like yesterday and today several trades were not allowed to run their course but were terminated early.
Are you posting your logic anywhere so I may follow along?
I also have it running on a separate account at FXOPEN. I have noticed that your version seems to close trades manually? Like yesterday and today several trades were not allowed to run their course but were terminated early.
Are you posting your logic anywhere so I may follow along?
Slow and steady wins the race.
Mar 02, 2011 at 03:17
I have been trading this EA on the same broker with the same account size. The not so funny thing is my results are totally not the same as FX Solution's. I have emailed and wrote detailed questions but never get an answer; very disappointed. Below is the Good Bad and downright Ugly results. I love how he removes loosing trades and then manually kills other trades.
Keep in mind, this is just February's results only. Total performance to date on this EA: -2,579.40
FX's Posted Trades:
03.01.11 02:01 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.65300 1.62000 1.62800 1.62620 18.0 18.00
02.23.11 01:10 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.64030 1.60730 1.61530 1.61240 29.0 29.00
02.24.11 10:05 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61120 1.61920 1.61620 1.61920 30.0 30.00
02.23.11 20:25 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61440 1.62240 1.61940 1.62140 20.0 20.00
02.22.11 02:50 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61400 1.62200 1.61900 1.62200 30.0 30.00
02.22.11 02:36 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.59460 1.62760 1.61960 1.61530 -43.0 -43.00
02.21.11 06:55 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61140 1.62640 1.62340 1.61140 -120.0 -120.00
02.21.11 02:45 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61190 1.62690 1.62390 1.61190 -120.0 -120.00
02.16.11 21:35 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.63360 1.60060 1.60860 1.62460 -160.0 -160.00
Total: -316.00
==============================================================================================
My Real Money Account:
02.28.11 15:27 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.60349 1.62300 1.62619 1.61619 -31.9 -133.38
02.28.11 06:43 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.63603 1.60303 1.61103 1.62596 -149.3 -150.77
02.23.11 01:10 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.64031 1.60731 1.61525 1.61402 12.3 9.82
02.24.11 02:06 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.61789 1.60700 1.62268 1.61790 47.8 46.66
02.24.11 10:05 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.60415 1.61915 1.61615 1.61915 30.0 28.87
02.23.11 20:25 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61421 1.62221 1.61921 1.62121 20.0 18.83
02.22.11 02:55 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61391 1.62191 1.61881 1.62191 31.0 -129.82
02.22.11 03:35 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61348 1.62148 1.61847 1.62148 30.1 28.92
02.22.11 02:36 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.59455 1.62755 1.61955 1.61531 -42.4 -43.58
02.21.11 06:45 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61099 1.62599 1.62299 1.61098 -120.1 -121.29
02.21.11 03:22 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61190 1.62695 1.62417 1.61187 -123.0 -124.19
02.03.11 05:23 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 - 1.55000 1.61958 1.62480 -52.2 -58.31
Total: -588.24
Keep in mind, this is just February's results only. Total performance to date on this EA: -2,579.40
FX's Posted Trades:
03.01.11 02:01 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.65300 1.62000 1.62800 1.62620 18.0 18.00
02.23.11 01:10 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.64030 1.60730 1.61530 1.61240 29.0 29.00
02.24.11 10:05 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61120 1.61920 1.61620 1.61920 30.0 30.00
02.23.11 20:25 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61440 1.62240 1.61940 1.62140 20.0 20.00
02.22.11 02:50 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61400 1.62200 1.61900 1.62200 30.0 30.00
02.22.11 02:36 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.59460 1.62760 1.61960 1.61530 -43.0 -43.00
02.21.11 06:55 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61140 1.62640 1.62340 1.61140 -120.0 -120.00
02.21.11 02:45 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61190 1.62690 1.62390 1.61190 -120.0 -120.00
02.16.11 21:35 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.63360 1.60060 1.60860 1.62460 -160.0 -160.00
Total: -316.00
==============================================================================================
My Real Money Account:
02.28.11 15:27 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.60349 1.62300 1.62619 1.61619 -31.9 -133.38
02.28.11 06:43 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.63603 1.60303 1.61103 1.62596 -149.3 -150.77
02.23.11 01:10 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.64031 1.60731 1.61525 1.61402 12.3 9.82
02.24.11 02:06 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 1.61789 1.60700 1.62268 1.61790 47.8 46.66
02.24.11 10:05 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.60415 1.61915 1.61615 1.61915 30.0 28.87
02.23.11 20:25 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61421 1.62221 1.61921 1.62121 20.0 18.83
02.22.11 02:55 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61391 1.62191 1.61881 1.62191 31.0 -129.82
02.22.11 03:35 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61348 1.62148 1.61847 1.62148 30.1 28.92
02.22.11 02:36 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.59455 1.62755 1.61955 1.61531 -42.4 -43.58
02.21.11 06:45 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61099 1.62599 1.62299 1.61098 -120.1 -121.29
02.21.11 03:22 GBPUSD Buy 0.10 1.61190 1.62695 1.62417 1.61187 -123.0 -124.19
02.03.11 05:23 GBPUSD Sell 0.10 - 1.55000 1.61958 1.62480 -52.2 -58.31
Total: -588.24
Slow and steady wins the race.
Mitglied seit Nov 20, 2010
1 Posts
Mar 02, 2011 at 14:56
Hello,
These allegations are absolutely ludicrous. There has been NO removing of trades and or closing trades manually. If that was the case, I would of removed all of the losing trades from February. Each broker has different price feeds/data which means that the trades will vary slightly from broker to broker. In addition, FX Open changed their GMT midweek which had an impact on the EA and some positions were handled differently by the EA due to this. The change in GMT by FXOpen is well documented. I noticed you posted only trades from February. Why didn't you post trades from earlier? February has been our only losing month since the EA was released in November. We send out notifications on when to stop trading the EA and when to turn it back on.
Kind Regards,
FX Solution EA Team
These allegations are absolutely ludicrous. There has been NO removing of trades and or closing trades manually. If that was the case, I would of removed all of the losing trades from February. Each broker has different price feeds/data which means that the trades will vary slightly from broker to broker. In addition, FX Open changed their GMT midweek which had an impact on the EA and some positions were handled differently by the EA due to this. The change in GMT by FXOpen is well documented. I noticed you posted only trades from February. Why didn't you post trades from earlier? February has been our only losing month since the EA was released in November. We send out notifications on when to stop trading the EA and when to turn it back on.
Kind Regards,
FX Solution EA Team
*Kommerzielle Nutzung und Spam werden nicht toleriert und können zur Kündigung des Kontos führen.
Tipp: Wenn Sie ein Bild/eine Youtube-Url posten, wird diese automatisch in Ihren Beitrag eingebettet!
Tipp: Tippen Sie das @-Zeichen ein, um einen an dieser Diskussion teilnehmenden Benutzernamen automatisch zu vervollständigen.
