Diskusija

Please wait and see before buying

not impressive so far

here are the main problems of the EA. No stop loss. No instructions on which are the indicators on which the EA has been created.
From what I have understood, this EA is on a Moving Avarage, usually the trade opens when the price is far from the MA, waiting for the price to come back to the MA. But this is not always true. It is necessary to put a SL.
Having tried the AVATAR system with a loss of 5000 euros in 10 minutes, and FRERO who ruined, fortunately I did not lose money, and other systems like 10x strategy on signalstart, I have to say that they all use the same system. I do not know if they are the same person, but they use the same system.

In this case, I think, considering that I am testing this EA with MT4, with Tick Manager, and a demo account, that the real accounts are the old IDS Venture and IDS Venture 30K e 50K.

There the owner obtain a low percentage, but he does not ruine. The problem is that he does not want to write me anymore. He explained me something at the beginning, than when I opened 25 trades, potentially losing money he disappeared. I have not lost money, because I am waiting for the price to come back. I do not mind how long it will take.
In the mean time I am testing the EA on a demo account.

So, if the owner of the EA is reading this words, please send me the settings of gold, which are the same for 30 e 50k.
I am trying to obtain the same thing, but I do not want to waiste time, considering that I paied 750 US dollars.

ZidanFCA posted:
Pips: -2408.7 LOL

Stop loss = 0

Did you even try to load author settings? or optimize the adviser yourself?

Yes of course, but the result is the same that you can see. Be honest and write me by email.

ZidanFCA posted:
Pips: -2408.7 LOL

Stop loss = 0

Did you even try to load author settings? or optimize the adviser yourself?

Now I have the same settings of the author in all crosses used, except for XAUUSD and GBPJPY where I used my settings on the optimization of the EA, without SL.
Let we see.

If you are earning money, write here the entire setting.

Thank you for exposing this IDS EA

Author's settings:
Max 1 trade, Period 50, deviation = 80, SL=0, TP=0, trailing start= 8, use opposite trade to exit = yes,

I do not know. It does not use SL or TP. I never know when the trade will close. In the backtest I seen SL and TP values, but not in the real execution.

Today I have activated only CADCHF, EURAUD, GBPJPY, XAUUSD, NZDUSD. In this way I have only USD twice. Among these, GBPJPY and XAUUSD are optimised by myself on an exponential MA of 9. The others, NZDUSD, EURAUD and CADCHF have the author's settings, expect for the risk set to 0.3- 0.7 instead of 0.5 - 0.5.

I would like to talk to someone else who bought this EA.

evgenkozhac posted:

Shiravale posted:
I do not know. It does not use SL or TP. I never know when the trade will close. In the backtest I seen SL and TP values, but not in the real execution.

Hello, i have pack.

EA have two method SL & TP (Fixed + Hidden)

Fixed SL & TP on screen

I tried to put feed SL and TP on the tester with Tick Manager and a confidence of 99%, but it is not profitable. At least on the test. I will try on the Demo, that it is probably better than the tester of MT4.

But anyway with the settings I am using and the crossed I tested, I have only profitable trades since yesterday morning. I will continue on a test for a few days.

Hm, shouldn't be the TP always higher than the SL to have a profitable EA on long-term? 😉

you are right. If you put 0.3 and 0.7 it works like this, at least I think.
Someone suggested.

At the moment the system is working as it should be. Honestly I am using the author's setting without changing anything. The problem is that the author did not explained anything to me. And for this reason I have lost 4000 euros.

I hope know to earn money. But be careful you have to have a look to the trades all the time, if the go over a 5-6% loss open other trades in the same direction and of the same size, no more than 3. Try to close every trade before evening, disconnect the EA or MT4 during the night. Activate the EA at 8 o'clock (Estern Europe time).

I will try to optimise the EA on the 50 MA, but actually it is earning. Do not leave money in the account. Take away the money every week or every month.

Here are the problems,

no stop loss. The EA insert the SL and TP only when the next candle start, in this way you can lose a lot of money. Unless you have to put the SL and TP manually or using an EA.

Every money management starts when the 1 H finish.

There are a lot of bugs which should be fixed. If I have to put SL and TP on my own, this EA do not worth 733 US dollars.
No more than 200 US dollars.

Please do not buy it

For your help I published also a free signal on the mql5 website, accessible via MT4/5.

https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/716324


I will do my best to be successful also with this EA. I have calculated the right SL to use and add as soon as the order is opened. Fortunately the EA works with pending orders, so it is easy to put a SL. Unless the EA will start money management only one hour later.

I have opened a real account on which I have set the two EA.

very soon I will add the link to it.

my Telegram public channel

https://t.me/IDS_real_test

hello, is ids ea useful?

yes it is, but it does not worth 700 and more dollars. You need to set it very well, and anyway I use it with other EAs to obtain these data.