Diskusija

Hi Vincent, thanks for your post and analysis,

please consider that Keltner is not trading with a constant Trades/week so your graph conclusion can be slightly different.
Anyway I think the market condition can justify that decad perf, we all perfectly know that with a volatility increase perf can be compromised in particular for trend trading system. Your analysis is challenging yes, but please consider that parameeters correlation are a bit misleading and in my opinion smells of analysis optimization in the sense that probably we can also find parameeter (for example winrate/XT) that show how Keltner performance increase are correlated and that Keltner will continue to overperforms.
Cheers and thanks again for the challege analysis !
Could you please pm the formula used for parameeters calculation ? want to check your analysis in few system in my portfolio that in a couple of years had a very fast decline in performance.
Xam

vocasla posted:
This post may be challenged but there appears circumstantial evidence that this system may be decaying at a predictably constant rate:

vgasper posted:
If I calculate all from today(24.6.2016) there is 178.9 pips minus?!?! How is possible that there is 94,2 pips of profit?

Any idea 'Jared'?

Bump

Your not considering different lot sizes of trades. 1 pip at 5 lots is a lot different than 10 pips at .5 lot

everyone facing loss at the month of July. Why only the owner do not have any trades at all???

can anybody confirm, by purchasing the keltner pro e.a. from the owner of the site, and trades are done not daily basis, sometimes per day 5 trades, sometimes no trade for 1 month.. how the e.a. is set for the same

when continuous losses comes, e.a. stopped, and restarted after a gap of 1 month, same day 4 trades

and there is no continuous trades, since it is e.a. how it can apply a gap for trading like this ? looks like human e.a.

they predict the losses and shut down until profit trades appearing ?! WOW, I suggest they( vendors) invest in stocks and become another Buffett. LOLOLOL😂😂😂

vsreeram77 posted:
can anybody confirm, by purchasing the keltner pro e.a. from the owner of the site, and trades are done not daily basis, sometimes per day 5 trades, sometimes no trade for 1 month.. how the e.a. is set for the same

when continuous losses comes, e.a. stopped, and restarted after a gap of 1 month, same day 4 trades

and there is no continuous trades, since it is e.a. how it can apply a gap for trading like this ? looks like human e.a.

I wish that were the case. It's more a result of me not realizing a new version of MT4 was released, and the broker no longer allowing my current version. Once I allowed MT4 to update, trades resumed. The wins and losses just happen to be coincidental.

keltnerpro posted:
Your not considering different lot sizes of trades. 1 pip at 5 lots is a lot different than 10 pips at .5 lot

I was just talikng about pips not profits... So any idea?? 😉

For 1 month you couldn't get the new version running ? :)

This EA still the best EA ever, BUT, as mentioned some post ago...you/we NEED manual corrections, and the owner does it (believe or not) !!!

And can works very good on every PAIR.

But SHIT will happened (CHF), so you/we need to study support/resistence every days or at least, weeks.

And for sure, owner does it (2).

This is not a EA set and forget for sure (+7k% with 6k of start it's impossible).

LLuk posted:
For 1 month you couldn't get the new version running ? :)

Haha, I would ask the same question in your position.

Truth is, I rarely log onto my VPS to check.

I monitor the trades through myfxbook just like the rest of you.

Just figured it was a period of inactivity.

Believe or not, that terminal has not been updated in about 6 months.

Kind of catches you off guard when the broker forces you to update to continue trading.

Because I have plenty of other accounts not shown, this is my re-investment account used for proof and used to build up a nest egg
for the future.

true true... marketing at its finest lol

Hi all

I am planning to start with 5K usd. I do understand forex is risky etc..

Just want to get an idea if I invest under keltnerpro what will be the monthly profit?

Just a ball park profit % will do. Pls help me out.

Thanks.

prasansg29 posted:
Hi all

I am planning to start with 5K usd. I do understand forex is risky etc..

Just want to get an idea if I invest under keltnerpro what will be the monthly profit?

Just a ball park profit % will do. Pls help me out.

Thanks.

5k real? 1-2% - every year H24, (NO CHF PAIR it's only a FAKE mirror).

So think about VPS cost, BROKER SCAMMER cost, PANIC ATTACK everydays with sl taken health...and put your 5k into farm biz...

NOBODY CAN GIVE YOU MONTHLY PROFIT WITH %!!!

IF YOU REALLY UNDERSTAND FOREX IS RISKY ETC... DON'T PUT YOU MONEY INTO FOREX :-)

Sureincome posted:

5k real? 1-2% - every year H24, (NO CHF PAIR it's only a FAKE mirror).

So think about VPS cost, BROKER SCAMMER cost, PANIC ATTACK everydays with sl taken health...and put your 5k into farm biz...

NOBODY CAN GIVE YOU MONTHLY PROFIT WITH %!!!

IF YOU REALLY UNDERSTAND FOREX IS RISKY ETC... DON'T PUT YOU MONEY INTO FOREX :-)

you right 5k wont really get you far in the begining but it can grow. Forex is one the best things in the world, forget real estate or mutual funds, forex has been the best thing I have ever invested in. allowed me to buy lots of nice things and help a lot of people :)

FXtrader2010 posted:

Sureincome posted:

5k real? 1-2% - every year H24, (NO CHF PAIR it's only a FAKE mirror).

So think about VPS cost, BROKER SCAMMER cost, PANIC ATTACK everydays with sl taken health...and put your 5k into farm biz...

NOBODY CAN GIVE YOU MONTHLY PROFIT WITH %!!!

IF YOU REALLY UNDERSTAND FOREX IS RISKY ETC... DON'T PUT YOU MONEY INTO FOREX :-)

you right 5k wont really get you far in the begining but it can grow. Forex is one the best things in the world, forget real estate or mutual funds, forex has been the best thing I have ever invested in. allowed me to buy lots of nice things and help a lot of people :)

And your primary source of this success has been this EA?

saaedb posted:

FXtrader2010 posted:

Sureincome posted:

5k real? 1-2% - every year H24, (NO CHF PAIR it's only a FAKE mirror).

So think about VPS cost, BROKER SCAMMER cost, PANIC ATTACK everydays with sl taken health...and put your 5k into farm biz...

NOBODY CAN GIVE YOU MONTHLY PROFIT WITH %!!!

IF YOU REALLY UNDERSTAND FOREX IS RISKY ETC... DON'T PUT YOU MONEY INTO FOREX :-)

you right 5k wont really get you far in the begining but it can grow. Forex is one the best things in the world, forget real estate or mutual funds, forex has been the best thing I have ever invested in. allowed me to buy lots of nice things and help a lot of people :)

And your primary source of this success has been this EA?

heck no!

Thanks for all the honest reply. Thus any reliable EA for signal start? Thanks.