BlueMonkey Real Money Live Test == Ended Oct 2014 (bluemonkey) Thảo luận

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

Sep 20, 2014 at 11:57

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

here the formulas used by MT4 for the back test results...
https://articles.mql4.com/127
as you can see nowhere the floating DD is used! only the balance is used calculated against closed trades only.
so you can have a move of 1 000pips against you, the trade is closed at +10pips... no DD, you are positive.

conclusion... set the risk to the minimum possible and target a small 5% per month.
wait and see how the DD is using the hourly DD calculated by fxblue (instead of myfxbook).

bluemonkey

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

Sep 21, 2014 at 03:07

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

============= ANNOUNCEMENT
============= ANNOUNCEMENT
============= ANNOUNCEMENT

All IBFX users please send your new FXCM account numbers so we can register it for you.

A

kobebeef

Tham gia từ Jun 24, 2010 124bài viết

Sep 21, 2014 at 06:26

Tham gia từ Jun 24, 2010 124bài viết

willgart posted:
here the formulas used by MT4 for the back test results...
https://articles.mql4.com/127
as you can see nowhere the floating DD is used! only the balance is used calculated against closed trades only.
so you can have a move of 1 000pips against you, the trade is closed at +10pips... no DD, you are positive.

conclusion... set the risk to the minimum possible and target a small 5% per month.
wait and see how the DD is using the hourly DD calculated by fxblue (instead of myfxbook).

Agree. When I back test an EA, it reported Max DD of USD 500, but when forward testing, it hit a Max DD (Margin + Floating loss of open positions) up to USD 3000.

Grid and/or Martingale is very aggressive and need a lot of capital to sustain the huge draw down. I would use these EA on cents accounts only...heee

bro25

Tham gia từ Aug 14, 2014 6bài viết

Sep 21, 2014 at 06:39

Tham gia từ Aug 14, 2014 6bài viết

yes , account crashed

forex_trader_113355

Tham gia từ Feb 22, 2013 116bài viết

Sep 21, 2014 at 06:51

Tham gia từ Feb 22, 2013 116bài viết

willgart posted:
here the formulas used by MT4 for the back test results...
https://articles.mql4.com/127
as you can see nowhere the floating DD is used! only the balance is used calculated against closed trades only.
so you can have a move of 1 000pips against you, the trade is closed at +10pips... no DD, you are positive.

conclusion... set the risk to the minimum possible and target a small 5% per month.
wait and see how the DD is using the hourly DD calculated by fxblue (instead of myfxbook).

Hi,
So can you guide the group to set exactly what should be risk level means % loss at at that level it will close all trades in loss. Please share the test result if you have optimised the input data to the EA. This is very tight control Copier and not EA so you can not properly back test as per my understanding. Any way I stopped using it.

Regards,
Dhiraj

forex_trader_169857

Tham gia từ Dec 31, 2013 170bài viết

Sep 22, 2014 at 05:04

Tham gia từ Dec 31, 2013 170bài viết

bro25 posted:
yes , account crashed

Crashed? Aww, those poor poor souls who bought this EA. Must have caused quite a bit of damage to their accounts.

willgart

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

Sep 22, 2014 at 10:54

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

when we'll you see some updates on the account?
an hourly update is a minimum...

bluemonkey

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

Sep 22, 2014 at 16:25

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

willgart posted:
when we'll you see some updates on the account?
an hourly update is a minimum...

We are preparing the new account. we will start monitoring the new account shortly.

A

GooSe79

Tham gia từ Feb 28, 2013 4bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 06:52

Tham gia từ Feb 28, 2013 4bài viết

bluemonkey posted:
willgart posted:
when we'll you see some updates on the account?
an hourly update is a minimum...

We are preparing the new account. we will start monitoring the new account shortly.

A

Sure! You have to move to a new account after mergin call.
The old account is gone.....

sirius1fx

Tham gia từ Oct 23, 2012 349bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 06:56

Tham gia từ Oct 23, 2012 349bài viết

willgart posted:
when we'll you see some updates on the account?
an hourly update is a minimum...

he is not going to update this account , it crashed its bad for his EA business to show it fully crashed..

This robot is only good for 3-8% a month and still might even crash with such low risk!

if you follow the flock like sheep you always end up stepping in shit!

TheFX4You

Tham gia từ Jun 09, 2013 92bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 10:06

Tham gia từ Jun 09, 2013 92bài viết

And I thought why there are so many messages from users, who recently lost money and now desperately want to recover it.
Asking for my EA to recover it.

Seems that I found answer..

Stable 20% per month without manual intervention...

willgart

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 11:11

Tham gia từ Aug 20, 2011 588bài viết

well... disappointing...
on a side the vendor recognize the risk on the over side he is not fully transparent...
the switch for the account should be transparent and should takes no time...
(and no its not because of a MC, but because the broker stop its service and the account is switch to another broker)

not sure the conclusion we have to understand here...

robotchallenge

Tham gia từ Dec 07, 2009 134bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 13:07

Tham gia từ Dec 07, 2009 134bài viết

Every time a large drawdown appears the vendor disconnects the updating so that we don't have full transparency. I am seeing this now for the second time as the DD approaches 40%.

Be afraid, very afraid?

ahmedfouad

Tham gia từ Oct 23, 2010 198bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 13:40

Tham gia từ Oct 23, 2010 198bài viết

TheFX4You posted:
And I thought why there are so many messages from users, who recently lost money and now desperately want to recover it.
Asking for my EA to recover it.

Seems that I found answer..

With my all respect to you.
I have purchased your EA and it's also so dangerous.
When your EA buys a currency pair and it reverses more than 600 pips hoping it will come back again and make profit only for 10 pips, it's still very risky.
Unfortunately NO EA is safe.

Anyway, I am happy if you will find any good solution to your EA (not based on backtest as you do) but based on forward test.
Also, you need to put a trial account on myfxbook to let us match our trades to yours.
This is the way you will gain more credibility and trust.
And you will find my encouragement as well and recommendation to others

Thanks.

parlavink

Tham gia từ Nov 18, 2013 154bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 14:07

Tham gia từ Nov 18, 2013 154bài viết

TheFX4You posted:
And I thought why there are so many messages from users, who recently lost money and now desperately want to recover it.
Asking for my EA to recover it.

Seems that I found answer..

sir,
you sell pictures live test is offline very bad EA ......
You can not live test show is so bad your EA

AutoTest71

Tham gia từ Sep 10, 2013 54bài viết

Sep 23, 2014 at 15:06

Tham gia từ Sep 10, 2013 54bài viết

parlavink posted:
TheFX4You posted:
And I thought why there are so many messages from users, who recently lost money and now desperately want to recover it.
Asking for my EA to recover it.

Seems that I found answer..

sir,
you sell pictures live test is offline very bad EA ......
You can not live test show is so bad your EA

What are you saying?!

IN ENGLISH, please!

fx5473br

Tham gia từ Aug 13, 2014 149bài viết

Sep 24, 2014 at 06:45

Tham gia từ Aug 13, 2014 149bài viết

A,

In the last 8 days my EA just registered 1 trade. You told me I should wait for the 'next basket' but still nothing...

bluemonkey

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

Sep 24, 2014 at 06:53

Tham gia từ Jun 22, 2014 423bài viết

filipesantos posted:
A,

In the last 8 days my EA just registered 1 trade. You told me I should wait for the 'next basket' but still nothing...

Please email me your VPS credentials and I will take a look. You should have buy trades on EURGBP now.

A

fx5473br

Tham gia từ Aug 13, 2014 149bài viết

Sep 24, 2014 at 06:55

Tham gia từ Aug 13, 2014 149bài viết

doing it right now! thanks

😄	😐	😡	😁	😀
😑	😈	😲	😭	😎
😝	😳	😕	🙄	😞
🙃	😱	😇	😉	😂

😄	😐	😡	😁	😀
😑	😈	😲	😭	😎
😝	😳	😕	🙄	😞
🙃	😱	😇	😉	😂

EURUSD	1.08517	GBPUSD	1.26979	AUDUSD	0.66521
USDJPY	156.477	USDCAD	1.36437	USDCHF	0.91141

BlueMonkey Real Money Live Test == Ended Oct 2014Thảo luận