Advertisement
FxPapa Expert Advisor (Theo FxPapa)
Người dùng đã xóa hệ thống này.
FxPapa Expert AdvisorThảo luận
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 12:32
Dear Brijesh
There is no problem with the EA.
As you can see in the manual of the first version of the EA(1.0) the Max DD was 20% while the input risk was 10%.
We have fixed it. If you want to have the same lot size as the past you should double the risk.
Please use the version 3.
Best Regards
There is no problem with the EA.
As you can see in the manual of the first version of the EA(1.0) the Max DD was 20% while the input risk was 10%.
We have fixed it. If you want to have the same lot size as the past you should double the risk.
Please use the version 3.
Best Regards
Tham gia từ Nov 20, 2010
87bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 13:51
FxPapa, there's still a problem with this EA. The GBPUSD sell trade 1.58339 is still open on your account, currently down about -40 pips, while the same trade closed on both my demo and live accounts for a +8 pip gain. So the trades are still not in sync with each other. Why is this continuing to happen? I thought everything was fixed? 😕 I'm losing confindence in this trading system...
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 13:58
rgmann posted:
FxPapa, there's still a problem with this EA. The GBPUSD sell trade 1.58339 is still open on your account, currently down about -40 pips, while the same trade closed on both my demo and live accounts for a +8 pip gain. So the trades are still not in sync with each other. Why is this continuing to happen? I thought everything was fixed? 😕 I'm losing confindence in this trading system...
Dear Roger
There is no problem. Our broker (IBFX) rejected the close order. It may happens to every broker.
Regards
Tham gia từ Nov 20, 2010
87bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 14:04
That's strange, because I'm using IBFX for both of my accounts, and they closed the trade for +8.1 pips on the live account and +7.8 pips on my demo account. But thank you for the quick response anyway. Hopefully your trade will turn around and close positive for you... 😄
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 14:19
rgmann posted:
That's strange, because I'm using IBFX for both of my accounts, and they closed the trade for +8.1 pips on the live account and +7.8 pips on my demo account. But thank you for the quick response anyway. Hopefully your trade will turn around and close positive for you... 😄
Dear Roger
You are right. We have good experience with IBFX.
Best Regards
Tham gia từ Nov 20, 2010
87bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 20:15
FxPapa, now you have a second GBPUSD sell trade opened at 1.58944 that I don't have on either of my accounts. Something is still not right...
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 20:21
rgmann posted:
FxPapa, now you have a second GBPUSD sell trade opened at 1.58944 that I don't have on either of my accounts. Something is still not right...
Dear Roger
Everything is right.
You don't have the second trade because your first trade has been closed in profit.
As you may know the second and third trades are done when the first position be in loss.
Regards
Tham gia từ Nov 20, 2010
87bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 21:59
Ok, I wasn't aware of that. Thanks for the information. So I take it that we won't have any other trades opened on our accounts until your positions close out for either a profit or a loss. Is that correct?
Cheers,
Roger
Cheers,
Roger
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 22:04
rgmann posted:
Ok, I wasn't aware of that. Thanks for the information. So I take it that we won't have any other trades opened on our accounts until your positions close out for either a profit or a loss. Is that correct?
Cheers,
Roger
Hi
Yes.
Regards
Tham gia từ Feb 04, 2011
32bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 23:10
FxPapa posted:
Dear Roger
Everything is right.
You don't have the second trade because your first trade has been closed in profit.
As you may know the second and third trades are done when the first position be in loss.
Regards
FxPapa,
Why isn't such information included in the EA's user manual?? Don't you think we clients have a right to know this?
Not only does it seem as though you have been using us as beta testers without our knowledge or consent, but the manual you provided is less than "bare bones". Most of the useful information I've acquired about your EA has been found in these discussion pages.
Does that seem right (especially for a $400 price tag)??
Tham gia từ Jan 18, 2012
69bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 23:15
(đã sửa Mar 19, 2012 at 23:17)
i dont like fxpapa and fxpapa is not looking reliable.
400$ for a silly trade copier ea, which is not able to copy trades properly. its a bullshit.
400$ for a silly trade copier ea, which is not able to copy trades properly. its a bullshit.
Tham gia từ Sep 21, 2011
39bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 23:26
I wish people would really relax and stop being greedy.
If you don't want this system don't use it.
Systems sometimes loose, and have flat periods, let the guy do his work and be patient.
If you don't want this system don't use it.
Systems sometimes loose, and have flat periods, let the guy do his work and be patient.
Brains always tell it how it is, while balls get it done.
Tham gia từ Nov 26, 2011
136bài viết
Mar 19, 2012 at 23:30
Dear Traders
It's so simple.
The EA opened a short position.
All of our clients had about +8 pips profit for that but our broker rejected the close order of our own account so our position is still open.
The EA has opened another short position because our first position was on loss and you don't have it because your position has been closed already with profit.
As I said several times the EA receives the signals from our server but it manage them independently.
It's not a pure trade copier.
I've explained all these things several times to every one who asked me.
I really want you to be honest. Be sure if there is any mistake from us I apologize from all clients but now there is no problem at all. Everything is working fine.
Regards
It's so simple.
The EA opened a short position.
All of our clients had about +8 pips profit for that but our broker rejected the close order of our own account so our position is still open.
The EA has opened another short position because our first position was on loss and you don't have it because your position has been closed already with profit.
As I said several times the EA receives the signals from our server but it manage them independently.
It's not a pure trade copier.
I've explained all these things several times to every one who asked me.
I really want you to be honest. Be sure if there is any mistake from us I apologize from all clients but now there is no problem at all. Everything is working fine.
Regards
Tham gia từ Feb 18, 2010
50bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 11:24
FxPapa,
Whys do not use the Guardian system? This will keep a strict control over the management of licenses, while allowing the EA to be independent.
Whys do not use the Guardian system? This will keep a strict control over the management of licenses, while allowing the EA to be independent.
Tham gia từ Nov 06, 2009
44bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 12:54
dont wish for guardian, worst piece of software everrrrrrrrrrrrrr. crashes your vps in no time...............
fidelitasllc@
Tham gia từ Jul 24, 2011
91bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 12:57
FxPapa account closed their trades, with bigger profit than ours.
It's time to trade again! ;)
It's time to trade again! ;)
Tham gia từ Nov 20, 2010
87bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 14:20
Yeah, FxPapa's strategy for dealing with losing trades seems to work out quite well most of the time. Sooner or later it will hit a full SL on all three positions that it opens, but it will hardly damage the account too bad. Overall it's making very nice gains... 😎
Tham gia từ Feb 04, 2011
32bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 15:20
FxPapa,
I see that there are two trades which occurred today on your account which were not duplicated on my account
(https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ragency/fxpapa-demo/256142)
or on another account that uses your EA which I've been monitoring.
I thought that Version 3 was supposed to have cured such problems ...
I see that there are two trades which occurred today on your account which were not duplicated on my account
(https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ragency/fxpapa-demo/256142)
or on another account that uses your EA which I've been monitoring.
I thought that Version 3 was supposed to have cured such problems ...
Tham gia từ Nov 06, 2009
44bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 15:26
ragency, read above, thats been explained by fx papa..............................
fidelitasllc@
Tham gia từ Feb 04, 2011
32bài viết
Mar 20, 2012 at 19:02
reinerh posted:
ragency, read above, thats been explained by fx papa..............................
Sorry, you're right. I read the wrong column for the opening dates.
