Calculating percentage gain/loss投票结果
Calculating percentage gain/loss讨论
Dec 10, 2010 at 11:19
1,067浏览
1 Replies
Dec 10, 2010 at 11:19
The way the percentage is calculated on this site greatly differs from how portfolio managers calculate gains. On this site, percentage is calculated based on your initial investment (adjusted for deposits and withdrawals). If you have gained or losed a lot since your initial deposit, these percentages does not make sense.
An example. If you deposited $100, and by luck or good trading😎 you are up to an equity of $1000. If this is you start capital one month, and you loose (or gain) $100 that month, your statement will tell you that you have lost/won 100%.... while actually you have only lost/won 10% of you start capital that month. If you are to have monthly statistics, they should be based on monthly amounts... It is kind of funny to read some of the statements in here, where accounts loose or gain thousands of percent each month... How can you loose a thousand percent and still have money to trade?
This calculation also regards the custom start date. If you are to have statistics of your trading since your custom start date, then these statistics should be based on the start capital of that start date, and not some start date far back in the past.
Just a thought!
An example. If you deposited $100, and by luck or good trading😎 you are up to an equity of $1000. If this is you start capital one month, and you loose (or gain) $100 that month, your statement will tell you that you have lost/won 100%.... while actually you have only lost/won 10% of you start capital that month. If you are to have monthly statistics, they should be based on monthly amounts... It is kind of funny to read some of the statements in here, where accounts loose or gain thousands of percent each month... How can you loose a thousand percent and still have money to trade?
This calculation also regards the custom start date. If you are to have statistics of your trading since your custom start date, then these statistics should be based on the start capital of that start date, and not some start date far back in the past.
Just a thought!
Consistent profits through thurall analysis
会员从Oct 28, 2009开始
1424帖子
Dec 10, 2010 at 11:24
I'm in agreement with this. Especially the second point. I appreciate it's difficult to carry out accurate percentage gain figures and please everyone given that people are depositing and withdrawing all the time. Maybe it would be possible to add two different percentage gain figures to the headline box calculated differently.
11:15, restate my assumptions: 1. Mathematics is the language of nature. 2. Everything around us can be represented and understood through numbers. 3. If you graph these numbers, patterns emerge. Therefore: There are patterns everywhere in nature.
*商业用途和垃圾邮件将不被容忍，并可能导致账户终止。
提示：发布图片/YouTube网址会自动嵌入到您的帖子中！
提示：键入@符号，自动完成参与此讨论的用户名。
