To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Change in monthly % calculus vote results

Do you like this suggestion?

Yes No

Change in monthly % calculus Discussion

cacus (cacus)
Jul 21 2011 at 06:03
119 posts
Hello guys,

I see that currently the monthly performance histogram (right at the bottom of the system page) is calculated in a strange way, imho.

For example some of my accounts shows that the monthly performance is calculated by (thismonth_ending_balance/initial_deposits)-previousmonth_percentage_performance.
That's why for example the first month is calculated ok: ( (ending balance / deposits ) - previous month performance )
1500/1000 - 0 = 50% performance
But the problem is from the second month and further:
2000/1000 - 50 = 50% performance

This leads to wrong monthly average performance calculus, you can see clearly it when you upload a strategy and the analysis page tells you that it has a monthly average of 1000%!!! Which is not accurate by any mean.

Since we do have the month_ending_balance (suppose we store it at a new variable called previousmonth_ending_balance) the following algorithm, relatively to the starting balance each month would yield more accurate number for the analysis:

thismonth_ending_balance/previousmonth_ending_balance = monthly performance relatively to each month's starting balance and not based on initial deposits.


1500/1000 = 50% (ok)
2000/1500 = 33% (ok)

See the difference?, to get a 50% performance on the second month the ending balance would have had to be 2250. This is what i mean to 'relative' monthly performance.

This would automatically bring a clearer and accurate monthly average calculus and also the monthly percentages would be more clear.

Hope i made it clear and hope i don't bother.
Thanks and keep up the good work!.



Mental note: do not abuse.
Please login to comment .