Forex Growth Bot Discussion

dd - 44 % and look at balance - it is Up - Down - Up - Down . It meens that EA can loose 50% of balance very fast in 2-3 days because it has SL. What it is based on? i see history - it is uses MM lot 0.25 0.25 0.25 ...no martin. but it can be greed with lot exponent 1 + trend orders or something. Is it indicators enters?

This bot does not use indicators. It is based on pure price action. By default EA uses high risk (0.05 lot per $1000) that is why there is such big dd.

что значит прайз экшин Димон?

т.е реагирует чисто на движение цены, раньше пользовался этим роботом, потом перешел на робин вол. Робин тоже реализует стратегию пробива волатильности, имеет две стратегии. Первая аналогична фгботовской, с другими параметрами, вторая - довесок к первой, открывает позиции на откатах цены. Бэктест робина дает больший доход при меньшей просадке, сейчас только им и пользуюсь, посмотри мою статистику, по моему здорово выходит.

ну как бы да интересно идет если такие роботы и стратегии в годовых масштабах рассматривать )) А если поставить на 10 000 и потеря баланса пойдет 2 раза подряд по 50% ...понимаешь о чем я

Интересно у тебя все графики друг друга повторяют) Веер

используй дефолтовый риск робина. Про фгб молчу, дефолтовый риск фгб высокий очень. Максимальная просадка робина с 2000 года около 10% при риске 1.5%. Статистику любого робота нужно оценивать помесячно минимум, иначе на автоматической торговле можно смело ставить крест. Да и на любой другой торговле, наверное, тоже.

Все графики повторяют друг друга потому что на всех этих аккаунтах работает один и тот же робот. Вручную позиции не закрываю.

c'mon guys, dont force me to use google translate on this page as well? ;)

hehe learn Russian))

Hmmmm, nice system but those drawdowns are intense!

OohYA posted:
Hmmmm, nice system but those drawdowns are intense!

dd is normal - i do not like that this EA loose 50% balance in summer 2012

Looks impressive - but 29%-40% Drawndown is not 'low'..... Can you get this in the <10% range with settings?

HI,

The DD is high because the system is trading at high risk. (.01/250USD)

I recommend .01/1000USD for max DD around 10% on a standard account.

For equity below 10,000USD you can use medium risk, which would be .01/500USD and 20% DD

Medium risk of around 20% DD is acceptable for most to trade and still sleep at night!😄

Regards

use less risk per trade

Thanks - Didn't look at it close enough (yet) to see if there were other settings - cheers for the answer...

Is it just me or do you also wonder why the EA won't close some trades in profit? I mean, the perfect example was the last 7 trades which were opened on 7th February. I have no idea why it didn't close some of those 7 trades that day when it hit ~1.337. Previously, it closed at least 1 or 2 trades, but now, it let it 'go', thus, the last 2 trades were closed in loss, which could have been closed in profit, 2 trades were closed the next day only at higher price, so less profit, and there are still 2 trades left opened, and we approach a possible uptrend again...

Wasn't there an inside setting which closed all positions which were in profits after 18 hours? Is that gone?

Don't get me wrong, I'm using this EA since November 2011, and I'm in profit, a lot, and got some money withdrawn as well, so I'm all-in-all very happy, but sometimes I do not get the exit 'strategy' this EA uses. 😄

Also, yes, I know that it must leave the trades open which are in profit to gain more from the trend, but I don't think that it is 'ideal' to leave positions open for several days, if you know what I mean... 😉

gzs26388 posted:
Is it just me or do you also wonder why the EA won't close some trades in profit? I mean, the perfect example was the last 7 trades which were opened on 7th February. I have no idea why it didn't close some of those 7 trades that day when it hit ~1.337. Previously, it closed at least 1 or 2 trades, but now, it let it 'go', thus, the last 2 trades were closed in loss, which could have been closed in profit, 2 trades were closed the next day only at higher price, so less profit, and there are still 2 trades left opened, and we approach a possible uptrend again...

Wasn't there an inside setting which closed all positions which were in profits after 18 hours? Is that gone?

Don't get me wrong, I'm using this EA since November 2011, and I'm in profit, a lot, and got some money withdrawn as well, so I'm all-in-all very happy, but sometimes I do not get the exit 'strategy' this EA uses. 😄

Also, yes, I know that it must leave the trades open which are in profit to gain more from the trend, but I don't think that it is 'ideal' to leave positions open for several days, if you know what I mean... 😉

It's an EA, it'll always be at best, profitably inaccurate...

OohYA posted:

gzs26388 posted:
Is it just me or do you also wonder why the EA won't close some trades in profit? I mean, the perfect example was the last 7 trades which were opened on 7th February. I have no idea why it didn't close some of those 7 trades that day when it hit ~1.337. Previously, it closed at least 1 or 2 trades, but now, it let it 'go', thus, the last 2 trades were closed in loss, which could have been closed in profit, 2 trades were closed the next day only at higher price, so less profit, and there are still 2 trades left opened, and we approach a possible uptrend again...

Wasn't there an inside setting which closed all positions which were in profits after 18 hours? Is that gone?

Don't get me wrong, I'm using this EA since November 2011, and I'm in profit, a lot, and got some money withdrawn as well, so I'm all-in-all very happy, but sometimes I do not get the exit 'strategy' this EA uses. 😄

Also, yes, I know that it must leave the trades open which are in profit to gain more from the trend, but I don't think that it is 'ideal' to leave positions open for several days, if you know what I mean... 😉

It's an EA, it'll always be at best, profitably inaccurate...

Yes, I know, but what I was trying to say is that it seems to me that the closing 'strategy' might involve some manual intervention on the EA's side? As it doesn't act the same way when it is closing the open trades.

Or you haven't noticed this yet?