Forex Growth Bot

Gain : +2644.71%
Drawdown 94.46%
Pips: 8075.5
Trades 2881
Won:
Lost:
Type: Real
Leverage: 1:200
Trading: Automated

Forex Growth Bot Discussion

Dec 20, 2010 at 23:46
254,497 Views
3,525 Replies
Member Since Mar 31, 2010   79 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:20
v1.3 worked well
v1.4 didn't close the trades... they were closed by stop loss :(
i go back to v1.3

it is strange that the vendor has a good trading strategy and they can't find a programmer who makes a working ea
Member Since Mar 20, 2011   22 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:23
i have version 1.3 and it closed on stop loss too!
Member Since Apr 15, 2011   97 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:34
I'm still running 1.3 and having the same problem
Member Since Mar 31, 2010   79 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:35
thx
i don't understand why is it so hard to close trades in profit
the vendor should ask for help
there are a lot of good programmers in the community
Member Since Mar 05, 2011   13 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:42
The same happened to me, Im convinced that they closed the trades manually. So pitty, I really trusted them, and it really looked good till now.
:(
Member Since May 01, 2011   20 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:47
Hey guys im using the trade copier so as to get over all the problems that you are discussing, so far so good, the last three trades made nearly 200 pips and then one tiny loss, worth considering for a small monthly fee.
Member Since Jul 21, 2010   119 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:49
yes, but I bought 2 licenses of FGB, I can subscribe the signal service, but I want the money of the 2 license back
Member Since Apr 15, 2011   97 posts
May 12, 2011 at 20:53

stevek11 posted:
Hey guys im using the trade copier so as to get over all the problems that you are discussing, so far so good, the last three trades made nearly 200 pips and then one tiny loss, worth considering for a small monthly fee.


can you post your results so that we may be able to see any deviation compared to the FGB chart so that we can weigh everything. I'm up for getting the trade copier but until I see the results otherwise I'm not inclined to get it.

Is anyone willing to show the results of the trade copier before the rest of us get it. I'll even take something that's not verified.
Member Since May 01, 2011   20 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:06
Ok with the trade copier here are the last four trades:

2011.05.12 12:15 sell 1.41372 closed at 1.41611 -23.9 pips
2011.05.11 19:00 sell 1.42159 closed at 1.41548 +61.1 pips
2011.05.11 18:45 sell 1.42177 closed at 1.41322 +85.5 pips
2011.05.11 18:30 sell 1.42058 closed at 1.41454 +60.4 pips

Hope this proves helpful guys
Member Since May 08, 2011   1 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:21
I too ended up with the trades closed at a loss :( Great strategy - poor programming😕
Member Since May 01, 2011   20 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:25
I think maybe a break even solution could work , say 40 - 50 pips would maybe be helpful
Member Since May 09, 2011   2 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:26
What is trade copier pls?
Member Since Apr 15, 2011   97 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:28

chobbes posted:
What is trade copier pls?


Is the $50 a month thing.
Member Since Apr 18, 2011   33 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:28
;)) the same happend with me. all started in profit.. ended in big losses.. somebody its using the trail target and trail stop function? with or without the wave trailing function????? can i use it together? if you check theese settings, it seems, that allmost all the trades can be closed like they did....... then this means, that they are using this functions???? i just activated. the both of the functions...

It recommanded to use this function separate or together? i was thinking, that trail target 100pips its nice with trail pips 20...
i lost a lot of pips... i need to recover somehow... i dont realy want to pay for that service. we payed once the price for the EA.. for this we need good service as well...

From the FGB MANUAL:"Trail Target & Trail Pips (Advanced and Power Versions) – Trail target is the number of pips in
profit at which time the trail pips, similar to trailing stop activates. This means that is trail
target is 100, and profit is at 100 pips, then trail pip will activate. If trail pips is 20, then the
robot will close if the profit goes down to 80 pips. If pip profit increases then stop loss will
move up so there is always a 20 stop loss (or whatever number you choose). This is checked
every tick. Will NOT work with Assign SL and TP set TRUE.

Use Wave Trailing (Default is false) (Power Version) – Wave trailing is an advanced system that
trails the profit take and stop loss. Helps improve profits. Wave Trailing (Default is "40-80;40-
80;40-80;40") this string defines the Wave Trailing rule. This is semicolon separated string with
Wave ranges. Default Wave Trailing rule defines three 40-80% wave and last 40% trailing."
Member Since May 01, 2011   20 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:29

chobbes posted:
What is trade copier pls?

The trade copier is software for the growthbot team to copy their exact trades to your account and they also manage the trades for you, it is quite good.
Member Since Apr 15, 2011   97 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:31

stevek11 posted:
Ok with the trade copier here are the last four trades:

2011.05.12 12:15 sell 1.41372 closed at 1.41611 -23.9 pips
2011.05.11 19:00 sell 1.42159 closed at 1.41548 +61.1 pips
2011.05.11 18:45 sell 1.42177 closed at 1.41322 +85.5 pips
2011.05.11 18:30 sell 1.42058 closed at 1.41454 +60.4 pips

Hope this proves helpful guys


My apologies if I seemed rude concerning the proof thing. I just like confirmation.
Member Since May 01, 2011   20 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:33

cunod posted:

stevek11 posted:
Ok with the trade copier here are the last four trades:

2011.05.12 12:15 sell 1.41372 closed at 1.41611 -23.9 pips
2011.05.11 19:00 sell 1.42159 closed at 1.41548 +61.1 pips
2011.05.11 18:45 sell 1.42177 closed at 1.41322 +85.5 pips
2011.05.11 18:30 sell 1.42058 closed at 1.41454 +60.4 pips

Hope this proves helpful guys


My apologies if I seemed rude concerning the proof thing. I just like confirmation.

im working on connecting my account to myfxbook so you guys can see the real verified trades of the copier,
no need for apologies we all like proof..... lol
Member Since Apr 15, 2011   97 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:54

stevek11 posted:



2011.05.12 12:15 sell 1.41372 closed at 1.41611 -23.9 pips
2011.05.11 19:00 sell 1.42159 closed at 1.41548 +61.1 pips
2011.05.11 18:45 sell 1.42177 closed at 1.41322 +85.5 pips
2011.05.11 18:30 sell 1.42058 closed at 1.41454 +60.4 pips

Hope this proves helpful guys





I did the math comparing those trades and there is about a 7 pip difference on average compared in the 4 trades. and you took the highest one was that one in loss. FGB lost about 8 pips and you lost about 15 more pips.
Member Since Apr 18, 2011   33 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:55
FGB just opened now 2 positions with 0.15 lot size.. what is happening? my fixed lot size in the settings was 0.05?????
HiPwrD64
forex_trader_32468
Member Since Mar 23, 2011   14 posts
May 12, 2011 at 21:59
I think it's the 'internal controls' BS at play. I just turn it off and restart MT4 frequently in between trades.
Sign In / Sign Up to comment
You must be connected to Myfxbook in order to leave a comment
*Commercial use and spam will not be tolerated, and may result in account termination.
Tip: Posting an image/youtube url will automatically embed it in your post!
Tip: Type the @ sign to auto complete a username participating in this discussion.