Forex Growth Bot讨论

fineguywhosnice posted:
    Anyone else have the Trade Copier? I'd like to see some published results on here...I just signed up for it...I heard from people online it was better...I would love to see some proof!

Im working on setting up my account with myfxbook, its pending at the mo

Hailtrader is absolutely correct: I am using copy tools for years on several different brokers and it never happen that trades be closed because of broker. Delays at open/close are possible, disconnected or frozen platform can cause small differences too but never premature closing.

At the end of the day this is the best ea i have ever used, and ive used them all, I get quick responses back from the support team and they are always working hard on updating and solving problems. The only true way to make it big in forex is to devise your own stratergies and manual trade but this takes time and experience, something none of us on here have or we wouldnt be here relying on software to do it for us. the best thing for everyone to do is to all change to the same broker, be it alpari which is what i use and get nearly exactly the same results with the ea as they do or switch to think forex. good luck hope you all have a good trading day today

stevek11 posted:
    At the end of the day this is the best ea i have ever used, and ive used them all, I get quick responses back from the support team and they are always working hard on updating and solving problems. The only true way to make it big in forex is to devise your own stratergies and manual trade but this takes time and experience, something none of us on here have or we wouldnt be here relying on software to do it for us. the best thing for everyone to do is to all change to the same broker, be it alpari which is what i use and get nearly exactly the same results with the ea as they do or switch to think forex. good luck hope you all have a good trading day today

I'm also on Alpari UK real and demo account. And you are right, the entrys are nearly the same and also the exits, but for my opinion FGB did a big mistake in regard to confidence, beause they closed the trades manually yesterday with a big profit, but the EA closed by itself 4 trades with a total loss of -173.8 pips.
And I'm still waiting for a explanation from the FGB-Team here !

Hi Guys,

As mentioned when we moved from the previous update.. we have smart exit = true. Smart exit caused our trades to close. After 18 hours.

Haitrader posted:
    

stevek11 posted:
    At the end of the day this is the best ea i have ever used, and ive used them all, I get quick responses back from the support team and they are always working hard on updating and solving problems. The only true way to make it big in forex is to devise your own stratergies and manual trade but this takes time and experience, something none of us on here have or we wouldnt be here relying on software to do it for us. the best thing for everyone to do is to all change to the same broker, be it alpari which is what i use and get nearly exactly the same results with the ea as they do or switch to think forex. good luck hope you all have a good trading day today

I'm also on Alpari UK real and demo account. And you are right, the entrys are nearly the same and also the exits, but for my opinion FGB did a big mistake in regard to confidence, beause they closed the trades manually yesterday with a big profit, but the EA closed by itself 4 trades with a total loss of -173.8 pips.
And I'm still waiting for a explanation from the FGB-Team here !

FGB support always said they dont close their trade manually, to get their answer they are active on their forum.
In my broker some time it close order in profit and fgb broker close their trade in loss. then what is the meaning of it they close their order in loss manually ?
thats not happen, still its leading it depends on brokers. there are some changes that they are working on it, and hope they will fix those issues very soon.
rite now i just withdraw all my funds as soon as i get them on i will share my real account statement. Im using instaforex. exness also give good results.

any way those who are facing verification prob, they have to uninstall the mt4 and delete the folder from their program files. also uninstall the FGB. then restart the system then install fresh one. then try to verify their license, I also face the same prob but my mt4 get hanged and doesnt verify and all the time when it restart it need verification, so i go with the fresh installation and every thing is back to normal.

<b>the support said they are using smart exit = true.</b>

hmm. so, they are not use default setting. since the version 1.4, smart exit = false.

aryaforex posted:
    hmm. so, they are not use default setting. since the version 1.4, smart exit = false.

they already mention it, if not then we have their statement now 😄

Pakfx posted:
    

aryaforex posted:
    hmm. so, they are not use default setting. since the version 1.4, smart exit = false.

they already mention it, if not then we have their statement now 😄

ok. lets start over next weeks. plan is change, smart exit = true, internal control = true.

Hope other guys also see our reply & we make some good profit next week.

I think the FGB Team should invest more time in the EA, not in the signal service...

What I've read in this forum about the EA the last 24 hours, is a horror scenario...
Closing the trades per hand, etc. Thats not support, thats squeezing money out..
The FGB worked really good at the end of last year, beginning of this year; but now with the verification shit, they made more problems than they solved...

Forget the signal service and put more time in the EA; I've used Kennys EA now for a while, but as some of the people said here, the FGB don't like other EAs or manual trading. Don't understand why, but ok. So i'm now running the FGB alone on an VPS with standard settings.
You could invent something, that our FGB closes the trades, if you'll close it per hand on your Thinkforex Account... :)

So please add an trailing stop, etc in the basic version and spend more time in the EA, than in the signal service. For the customer support...

Regards

i think, that they realised, that they can make more money with this trade copier service and now they showing some issues with the ea....===> all the costumers ar joining the trade c service..>>> if the plan sounds like this, then its a shame! if no, my bad. i request a money back for the power ea and i'm joining as well. what can i say........😡

Haitrader posted:
    

RTSE posted:
    

stevek11 posted:
    Hey guys im using the trade copier so as to get over all the problems that you are discussing, so far so good, the last three trades made nearly 200 pips and then one tiny loss, worth considering for a small monthly fee.

I started using the trade copier when it first came out on my ATC account. It seemed to work well at first and then one day it closed 3 trades much earlier than the trades in the demo account closed.....and I lost a lot of profit because of the early close. I wrote support and ask then what was going on and they ask me about the EA status on the chart and about my trade logs. I answered the status question, sent them my trade logs and they replied that it must be a problem with my broker and ask if I could switch to a different one. That's when I gave up on the trade copier and went back to the EA. Bottom line is that the trade copier is no more reliable than the EA.....its performance is extremely dependent on the broker you use.

The explanation of FGB is definitely wrong. The slave of a signalcopy master EA can never close earlier than the master. Why? Because it got no signal from the master. The slave read continously the list of the trades of the master and adapt his own trades. Your account has nothing to do, when your trades were closed earlier. It is always the action on the master account.
Only a later closing could be possible, in some cases, like ' trade context is busy', requotes etc.

Yep, that's what I think as well, that they just closed the trades manually from the master. If they had told me that, I wouldn't have had a problem staying with the copier service but their explanation 'that it was a problem with my broker', just didn't make sense, so I quit using it.

With regard to the EA, as much as I hate seeing trades that were in profit by as much as those ones yesterday were, turn around and become losing trades, backtesting the EA shows the exact same performance for yesterday. Since I do like the way this EA backtests overall, and its performance yesterday seems to be right in line with its backtests, I still have faith in that the EA was working correctly and that it's a very good EA in the long run. Yesterday, it just gave back a portion of the huge wins from two weeks ago but my profits are still very positive overall for the past 2 weeks.

fxgrowthbot posted:
    Hi Guys,

As mentioned when we moved from the previous update.. we have smart exit = true. Smart exit caused our trades to close. After 18 hours.

Cool, thank you for that explaination FGB. Is that the only parameter that you have set differently than the defaults for this demo account?

Hallo,

hoffe dass jemand hier ist und deutsch versteht.
Ich habe den groth bot erworben und runtergeladen.
Jetzt möchte ich aber die Lot Größe ändern. Eingestellt
sind 0.1 Lot ich möchte aber z.B. 0.01 Lot. Sobald ich dies
bei den Einstellungen (Input) geändert und gespeichert
habe und ich die Einstellungen Input wieder öffne ist die
Lotgröße wieder auf Standard also 0.1 Lot. Was mache ich falsch
bzw. was muss ich tun?

Danke

Drücken Sie f7 uder mt4 und Suche nach den Parameter LotSize

es sollte nicht geändert sein wenn du die parameter fenster wider öffnest (press F7)
warscheinlich du ziehst den robot wider auf den chart >> mache das nicht
aufpassen!!! >> dieses robot wird nur an thinkforex terminal vollstandig funkzionieren!!!

Well FGB just got taken off the my chart till things calm down, it just pulled a stupid. Opened up a .40 lot and nearly blew my margin level in about a 10 pip loss . I have tried a restart all that suff. Dont know what to do now.

I will try the FGB copier for one month, if that doesnt work than all of this is a scam!! Pitty!
:(