Inner Circle Trader Discussion

OohYA posted:
Thankfully, my life (and my trading) doesn't revolve around horribly unjustified faith in this Inner Circle Trader. Let's see whether a 'hyper-inflationary' ego is a trait worthy of success. We'll reconvene at the end of February, agreed?

Up to you.

WW on fiber 15?

I've noticed all trades are now private. Not sure what this would teach anyone! I could understand the open trades being private to prevent copiers but to not be able to view the history pretty much negates the whole exercise!

jenx posted:
I've noticed all trades are now private. Not sure what this would teach anyone! I could understand the open trades being private to prevent copiers but to not be able to view the history pretty much negates the whole exercise!

pp_Forex forgive me for breaking my silence, but here is an example of another blind trader who was endlessly praising, but now cries when the signals are gone. Hilarious I tell you!

I won't gratify you with the reply you deserve apart from to say hadn't you better go back to your sewing machine before your boss catches you using your phone.

jpblack1fx posted:
WW on fiber 15?

Did anyone else take this? It had a nice conflo with the 4/1hr OTE... locked in the first 20 and SL at BE

lol

That didn't take long to go private...wow...I thought it was going last a little longer but not this quick...now let's wait for the fake excuse...I'm sure it for ' educational' purposes....this should be a good lesson...

Well at least he didn't charge anyone for this great trading 'education'...

pp_forex posted:
He has taught his methods to hundreds of people through forums, with a very large number of us trading very successfully.

Really? And where might those results be?
Why not link to myfxbook and show these very successful results.

Well, pp_forex, we're still waiting for you to inform us where all the verifiable evidence is of yours & all the other 'large number' of very successful traders following this persons content.

Stop the usual avoiding tactics & answer Swing Traders question.

 

The guy's only done less than 30 trades, for crying out loud give him a break! Having said that, claiming bad trades were done for 'educational purposes' is a bit dodgy...especially last Friday, a day where making pips was ridiculously easy if you sat in front of the computer.

As for making trades private, nothing wrong with that. To be honest, in his shoes I'd make 'em all private for 6mo and only reveal them afterwards...not in the mood of providing leechers free advice ;)

I can't be bothered with this crap, it's all going the same toxic way as Babypips, my reason for partaking in a forum is to help others, and since most just want to slag off and be childish, there's no point.

Bye kids.

pp_forex posted:
I can't be bothered with this crap, it's all going the same toxic way as Babypips, my reason for partaking in a forum is to help others, and since most just want to slag off and be childish, there's no point.

Bye kids.

I wouldn't get wound up by it if I were you.Anyone who's read your stuff knows you're straight up so what does it matter what a load of doom mongers say or think?

pp_forex posted:
I can't be bothered with this crap, it's all going the same toxic way as Babypips, my reason for partaking in a forum is to help others, and since most just want to slag off and be childish, there's no point.
Bye kids.

You can certainly be bothered to submit all these wonderful platitudes & flood the threads with boasts & praise.
But as soon as you're asked to back it up with hard evidence, you het into a strop, make your usual excuses & disappear for a while.

The truth is neither you or any other of these 'large number' of successful traders can show any evidence whatsoever of posting a consistent & verifiable track record using this guys material.

It's all hot air.

TT01 posted:

pp_forex posted:
I can't be bothered with this crap, it's all going the same toxic way as Babypips, my reason for partaking in a forum is to help others, and since most just want to slag off and be childish, there's no point.
Bye kids.

You can certainly be bothered to submit all these wonderful platitudes & flood the threads with boasts & praise.
But as soon as you're asked to back it up with hard evidence, you het into a strop, make your usual excuses & disappear for a while.

The truth is neither you or any other of these 'large number' of successful traders can show any evidence whatsoever of posting a consistent & verifiable track record using this guys material.

It's all hot air.

To be fair to this bloke, my trading was profitable before I had studied his stuff and when I tweaked it with a few of his techniques it made a massive difference.Unfortunately I didnt get long enough to study his concepts in a lot of depth as he 'did one' and took his videos with him soon after !! LOL. It's not such a big deal, but I'd liked to have seen more of this guys material.He seriously knows his stuff however theres something not quite right in his situation right now. He posted up a set of 'rules' before he started the 'challenge' and, as far as I can see, these have yet to be met.I still wouldn't be surprised if this circus flipped and he started showing a ridiculous profit.Thing is, you won't have a clue how he's done it thus rendering the whole exercise irrelevent. I'll keep looking in now and again anyway!

PJ he may have inspired you to improve your trading, and that's great.
If you read old Gann books you will find plenty and more about S/R breakouts etc.

But the irrational hubris needs to be backed up with results.
All these followers bragging on behalf of someone else *before* results is really noob.
And insulting anyone who dares question the messiah non result is even worse.
I am a trader, I make educated bets.
The odds are way way on my side that trading those methods he will NOT make 20-50% per month with small DD on a long timeframe.
I will bet against that any day of the week, it's well proven that my chances of winning that bet are OVER 99%.
It's a great trade to make, and so I called out that post from some dumb noob.

So how about ICT and PP proving me WRONG and make me eat humble pie and praise your result?
Go ahead...make my day.

pp_forex posted:
I can't be bothered with this crap, it's all going the same toxic way as Babypips, my reason for partaking in a forum is to help others, and since most just want to slag off and be childish, there's no point.Bye kids.

The account is now closed, away you go and take your Inner Circle Trading scam with you.

There is a lesson here, if you trade you need to learn to lose. And this is not how.
Admit your losses, take them head on, change what your doing.
Or Admit to your losses, you believe in your system and keep trading hoping that the market will come back. Accepting that it may never come back and/or you lose your money before it does.

Welcome to trading real money instead of babyshits gentleman.

I don't need to prove anything to anyone, Swing Trader, you're just a loser, a frustrated trader that thinks he knows better than anyone, enjoy your loses, you will never succeed, you have just rubbished tried and tested methods that work universally, you wouldn't know what a buy and sell profile was if it came labelled on your chart in big bold letters.

You're a waste of time, and that's the last of the time I'm going to waste on you, it's just a shame that you interrupt the learning process for decent people that really want to learn.

jenx posted:
theres something not quite right in his situation right now. He posted up a set of 'rules' before he started the 'challenge' and, as far as I can see, these have yet to be met.

Thing is, you won't have a clue how he's done it thus rendering the whole exercise irrelevent.

Exactly Paul.
If this guy is genuine & has actually been trading successfully for the number of years he maintains, then there should be nothing surprising about his results at all.
    
I used to frequent a password locked Paltalk FX room 10-12 years ago run by 4 ex-bank dealers/traders.
The major difference between those types of professional traders & this guy is the fact their approaches were very quickly & easily transferrable. No grey areas or second guessing.
Just 3 simple rules that quickly & accurately identified high quality set ups & trades.

Back then they were accurate & very easy to replicate & they're still valid in today's marketplace.
Certainly none of this multi-layered rubbish he & others like him churn out on these forums.
Its little wonder most of those guys over on Babypips are struggling to put it into practice.

They're being stunned with analysis paralysis.
LOL

Yeah, guess we won't be reconvening end of February then pp_forex ;)

Moral of the story (from Star Wars LOL): Don't get cocky kid!