Vortex Trader PRO (bei vortextraderpro)

Gewinn : +2131.88%
Drawdown 27.67%
Pips: 2247.4
Trades 474
Gewonnen:
Verloren:
Typ: Real
Hebel: 1:200
Trading: Automatisiert

Vortex Trader PRO Diskussion

Feb 03, 2015 at 01:56
50,671 Angesehen
1,168 Replies
Mitglied seit Jan 07, 2015   39 Posts
Nov 26, 2015 at 01:07
i have realized one thing in life and this occurs with everything....

if you become someone who sells something, or someone famous like an actor, singer or anything else...even a friend to many people, not everyone is going to love you or like you....there will always ALWAYS be someone who will dislike you, criticize you, bag you out...

i have accepted this as a fact of life...and sometimes, maybe more often than sometimes the negative is heard more louder than the positive

because i have accepted this as a fact of life, and a part of life, when i do hear a negative, i most often dismiss it or ignore it because of the above reasons...there will always be someone negative....always

Mitglied seit Jun 22, 2015   15 Posts
Nov 27, 2015 at 09:38
There is no more profitable industry than the EA industry...this is a fact. Do you wanna win? I assure you that you don't need win more than 50% of times. What you need is risk management. Simple like that. This and price action. Nothing more.
Mitglied seit Jun 12, 2014   11 Posts
Dec 04, 2015 at 14:58
The last to trades close at 1.09069 and 1.08951 on my end both of them close in a negative trade. Why is that lag? i can see there is some time diffrents to.

Mine:
5058315 2015.12.04 09:15:03 buy 0.18 eurusd 1.09067 1.07869 1.09239 2015.12.04 15:18:02 1.08916 0.00 0.00 0.00 -24.96
5058309 2015.12.04 09:15:03 buy 0.18 eurusd 1.09067 1.07966 1.09266 2015.12.04 15:18:03 1.08916 0.00 0.00 0.00 -24.96

Yours:
12.04.2015 09:15 12.04.2015 15:16 EURUSD Buy 3.00 -110.00 20.00 1.09066 1.09069 0.3 9.00 6h 1m 0.01%
12.04.2015 09:20 12.04.2015 14:15 EURUSD Buy 3.00 -110.00 20.00 1.08929 1.08951 2.2 66.00 4h 55m 0.08%
Don_Corleone
forex_trader_274697
Mitglied seit Sep 15, 2015   3 Posts
Dec 13, 2015 at 08:10
@bracker Very silly comments like yours might mislead people who are trying to learn how to trade the right way....Your comment shows that you know nothing about Forex.You are one of those guys who believe that all you have to do is just trust your account to some EA and sit back and enjoy profits.... You assure that you don't need to win more than 50% of times?-yes,I agree that even if you have 49% you can still be in profits if your R/R is 1:2,1:3 etc which is not the case for this EA and many others.
'What you need is risk management' -this and price action-nothing more' -makes me rofl as well:)Well,we all were new at some point,but I am just gonna say this:
Money management does not make a difference,unless you have a smooth equity curve.Unless you are a consistently profitable trader,money management really does not make any difference in your trading.
GL with your trading guys and don't listen to people who have no idea about trading.
Mitglied seit Oct 20, 2013   136 Posts
Dec 14, 2015 at 21:32
you have to have a plan,strategy, system, risk management and most of all discipline
Time is Money
Mitglied seit Dec 15, 2015   2 Posts
Dec 15, 2015 at 08:12
bracker posted:
There is no more profitable industry than the EA industry...this is a fact. Do you wanna win? I assure you that you don't need win more than 50% of times. What you need is risk management. Simple like that. This and price action. Nothing more.

Hey, I'm relatively new here but I've browsed these boards for a while and thought I'd finally jump in on the conversation.

I'm not new to trading, but would consider myself new to EA's and automated trading systems...and in the last year I've been some what of an 'emotional roller coaster'; in the last year I've tried at least 10 to 15 EA's on the Metatrader platform and wasted countless hours of research and not to mention, money.

It doesn't take a genius to work out the EA industry and their clever tactics. Any of these sites or vendors promoting automated trading systems will have glossy performance equity curves (which I've since learned are bogus), and even if these EA's work for a short period of time, they eventually blow up as market conditions change (I've learned that system coders curve-fit their systems to current market conditions).

I've never had success with any kind of automated system, and I've never met anyone that has so far.

As my journey continues I'm learning more and more that the best traders of our time our manual traders who apply discretion to each and every decision. Some of the greatest hedge fund traders, like those guys in the Market Wizards, traded with their instinct and were just reading the charts. As one of the guy's blogs that I've been reading says, 'The traders and investors interviewed in the market wizards books largely had a discretionary and discerning approach to the markets. In other words, when you boil it all down, they were making judgement calls in the market, and very good ones at that. They were not using ‘expert advisors’ or automated trading systems, and for good reasons.' ( You can see the original blog post: The Truth about Automated Forex Trading Systems and Robots - https://www.learntotradethemarket.com/forex-articles/truth-about-automated-forex-trading-systems-robots )

Look, I'm open to the idea that there might be some automated or mechanical systems out there that do work, however I'm sure even those good systems still need manual intervention and tweaking on a constant basis to adapt to changing market conditions. So, for me, I'd rather stick to reading the price action on the charts.

Wilson


Mitglied seit Apr 25, 2015   67 Posts
Dec 15, 2015 at 15:13
Wilson

I read that article. And at the bottom you will see an ad for the authors course in how to trade forex. I guess everyone is trying to sell something. Of course he wants you to believe auto trading systems are no good so he can better sell his course. Since following and using Dougs EAs I get exactly the same trades as his accounts. I don't believe they are faked. And I don't beleive I should rely on them solely. I have been manually trading the last three months and hope to begin trading with a proprietary firm next month. I think EAs can make a nice base to your manual trading. If you have the money management skills to not risk overagressively. You should look up Kirill eremenko. Another highly successful trader who only uses EAs. I don't beleive he sells them. He's never tried to sell me one but does teach traders how to code their strategies into an ea.
Mitglied seit Mar 30, 2015   32 Posts
Dec 16, 2015 at 07:51
Many of the comments further down the very same page should put to bed this argument
Mitglied seit Mar 30, 2015   32 Posts
Dec 17, 2015 at 07:33
Some EA's and robots do work and work very well. I'll name one that I found and like namely: Zephyn Scalper. Firstly, you will need to setup a cTrader Demo account with FXPRO, if you don't already have one (I make no money in this). Install the Zephyn Scalper CBot, set your risk and click to start. It's not difficult, but once you have it set right, you will be very happy with the results..... I have backtested this many times just to make sure I had it set right, and right now, I'm forward testing on a demo account. I'll be interested to learn how other members find this robot.
Mitglied seit Mar 02, 2013   238 Posts
Dec 17, 2015 at 19:32
@Martin
many scalpers work great on demo, but not on a real account.
Try with a real account (maybe a cent account) and then you can tell us if this scalper works good or not.
The differenece between who your are and who you would like to be be is what you do
Mitglied seit Mar 30, 2015   32 Posts
Dec 18, 2015 at 09:35
For every positive comment you will always get a negative response. Conversely, for every negative comment you will always get a positive response
Mitglied seit Dec 15, 2015   2 Posts
Dec 21, 2015 at 07:43
Dionysus231 posted:
Wilson

I read that article. And at the bottom you will see an ad for the authors course in how to trade forex. I guess everyone is trying to sell something. Of course he wants you to believe auto trading systems are no good so he can better sell his course. Since following and using Dougs EAs I get exactly the same trades as his accounts. I don't believe they are faked. And I don't beleive I should rely on them solely. I have been manually trading the last three months and hope to begin trading with a proprietary firm next month. I think EAs can make a nice base to your manual trading. If you have the money management skills to not risk overagressively. You should look up Kirill eremenko. Another highly successful trader who only uses EAs. I don't beleive he sells them. He's never tried to sell me one but does teach traders how to code their strategies into an ea.

You're right that most of these people are selling something, but it looks like the guy you mentioned is also selling a bunch of things. You said you 'dont believe he sells them', but I looked at this site briefly and saw several courses for sale. There is nothing wrong with a trader selling a course or information provided it's actually going to help people gain knowledge, I certainly needed help and I am glad there are intelligent people out there offering it. None of that is my point though... My point is that EA's fail over time and if you read the article i linked to last post you'll see why I feel that way.
Mitglied seit Nov 01, 2015   120 Posts
Dec 22, 2015 at 11:40
Wilsontrader888 posted:
Dionysus231 posted:
Wilson

I read that article. And at the bottom you will see an ad for the authors course in how to trade forex. I guess everyone is trying to sell something. Of course he wants you to believe auto trading systems are no good so he can better sell his course. Since following and using Dougs EAs I get exactly the same trades as his accounts. I don't believe they are faked. And I don't beleive I should rely on them solely. I have been manually trading the last three months and hope to begin trading with a proprietary firm next month. I think EAs can make a nice base to your manual trading. If you have the money management skills to not risk overagressively. You should look up Kirill eremenko. Another highly successful trader who only uses EAs. I don't beleive he sells them. He's never tried to sell me one but does teach traders how to code their strategies into an ea.

You're right that most of these people are selling something, but it looks like the guy you mentioned is also selling a bunch of things. You said you 'dont believe he sells them', but I looked at this site briefly and saw several courses for sale. There is nothing wrong with a trader selling a course or information provided it's actually going to help people gain knowledge, I certainly needed help and I am glad there are intelligent people out there offering it. None of that is my point though... My point is that EA's fail over time and if you read the article i linked to last post you'll see why I feel that way.

 EA's fail over time is what you said, but if fails after you turned 7k into 70k then it isn't a failure. Many people take for granted what these EA's can do. Clearly the manager of this account has done very well and his followers are all making money, but the reality is when ever you are following someone and you make a few doubles you should withdraw right away.
Mitglied seit Mar 30, 2015   32 Posts
Dec 26, 2015 at 20:28
With everything in life you will find good and bad, EAs are no different. Its wrong to blanket all EA's the same. I have found with EA's and robot, to get the best from them you must monitor them daily and make minor changes when needed. Don't blindly leave them running and expect them to make you money otherwise, for sure the will crash your account.
Mitglied seit Sep 08, 2014   27 Posts
Dec 27, 2015 at 07:32
rob559 posted:
would you please answer that

Just another faked Synergy FX account statement. If you go through the trades and sort them by ticket number there isn’t a single gap between the deposit on 21 April 2013 and the last withdrawal on 11 December 2014. Even the five withdrawals have consecutive ticked numbers.

None of this should be possible unless either the account statement or the account itself is a fake

https://www.donnaforex.com/forum/index.php?topic=13856.0



I purchased this EA. The result is real but just that results in recent months are not promising. I am still observing this EA.
Mitglied seit Mar 30, 2015   32 Posts
Jan 04, 2016 at 18:36
What a waste of money this has turned out to be. After a very good start with around 90% return within 3 month on my account, then nothing since.
Mitglied seit Sep 10, 2014   138 Posts
Jan 06, 2016 at 04:17
Martin101 posted:
What a waste of money this has turned out to be. After a very good start with around 90% return within 3 month on my account, then nothing since.

If you got 90% return, than how was this EA a waste of money? Unless you account size was small....
Mitglied seit Sep 04, 2013   33 Posts
Jan 13, 2016 at 12:53
Doug, 6 months of disappointment with this vortex...
about the same thing with the channel...
we all paid good money for your services.
what is going on?
Mitglied seit Apr 25, 2015   67 Posts
Jan 13, 2016 at 14:23
Yea seems like the trend changed from uptrend to downtrend on the hour chart and the software thought it was just a pullback. However, the euro had been the strongest currency since Friday and the dollar was 4th. As far as relative strength. So I was surprised it got stopped out.
Mitglied seit Jan 14, 2016   8 Posts
Jan 15, 2016 at 08:10
durendal posted:
Doug, 6 months of disappointment with this vortex...
about the same thing with the channel...
we all paid good money for your services.
what is going on?

Same here. For what we have paid I was expecting far more this . Does makes you wonder especial as I was offered yet another trading system soon after paying good money for the VTP system.
Anmelden / Registrieren to comment
You must be connected to Myfxbook in order to leave a comment
*Kommerzielle Nutzung und Spam werden nicht toleriert und können zur Kündigung des Kontos führen.
Tipp: Wenn Sie ein Bild/eine Youtube-Url posten, wird diese automatisch in Ihren Beitrag eingebettet!
Tipp: Tippen Sie das @-Zeichen ein, um einen an dieser Diskussion teilnehmenden Benutzernamen automatisch zu vervollständigen.