Advertisement
Forex Growth Bot
| Gain : | +2644.71% |
| Drawdown | 94.46% |
| Pips: | 8075.5 |
| Trades | 2881 |
| Won: |
|
| Lost: |
|
| Type: | Real |
| Leverage: | 1:200 |
| Trading: | Automated |
Forex Growth Bot Discussion
Mar 17, 2011 at 13:09
Hi guys, just joined myfxbook and this thread. I notice a number of you have been using this EA since the start of the year. In your experience so far would you still recommend this EA. Does it aid your trading or does it hinder it?
I notice the settings can be tweeked (advanced version) to match your own personal trading style which i like the idea of compared to a plug n play black box solution, as i dont believe in holy grails per say but do believe that disciplined trading with the right methods and setups can prove to be very profitable.
Is this EA still a go?
I notice the settings can be tweeked (advanced version) to match your own personal trading style which i like the idea of compared to a plug n play black box solution, as i dont believe in holy grails per say but do believe that disciplined trading with the right methods and setups can prove to be very profitable.
Is this EA still a go?
Mar 17, 2011 at 15:49
Hogdust posted:
it looks as if these guys may have cut and run ... no responses to any of the latest comments, and the links in the members area do not work.
not a good sign.
They are still around .. just responded to email. very helpful.
Mar 17, 2011 at 16:25
Star posted:
I am also having an issue with ea not closing trades on ATC Brokers
Same here. I've stopped using FGB on ATC. The difference is big. On FX Primus, my other ECN account almost no orphan trades whereas a good number on ATC have lost track. When the DD goes higher than 30 or 40 I begin to suspect its lost track.
forex_trader_18284
Member Since Sep 13, 2010
37 posts
Mar 17, 2011 at 22:34
Yeah, I've had the same issues with FGB on my ATC account; it looses track of most of the trades. My MB Trading account is a little better but FGB still looses track of some of those trades as well. Interestingly though, I've also got FGB running on two demo MBT accounts and it never seems to have any issues on those accounts. Unfortunately at this point, this EA just isn't something that's very usable in its current state. Hopefully the vendor can fix the execution issues because the trading method itself seems to be excellent.
Member Since Dec 20, 2010
107 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 02:40
We are still around :) . We have not stopped, we are working hard on improving trade execution. We will also release the trade copier this month for an instant solution.
Member Since Mar 16, 2011
60 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 07:49
fxgrowthbot posted:
We are still around :) . We have not stopped, we are working hard on improving trade execution. We will also release the trade copier this month for an instant solution.
It would be great to see you concentrate more on the trade execution problem as that is what people are complaining about rather than trying to get the trade copier working. A lot of people are not interested in paying extra for the trade copier when they have already paid for the bot.
Member Since Jan 29, 2011
56 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 08:45
DMFXTrader posted:
fxgrowthbot posted:
We are still around :) . We have not stopped, we are working hard on improving trade execution. We will also release the trade copier this month for an instant solution.
It would be great to see you concentrate more on the trade execution problem as that is what people are complaining about rather than trying to get the trade copier working. A lot of people are not interested in paying extra for the trade copier when they have already paid for the bot.
thats right!we suffer more loss now..
Member Since Jul 30, 2010
40 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 12:03
hi FGB
Today the bot was so unlucky with its trade... it closed it little before the market reversed...but i have seen this happened a number of times... Do you think that the firsts trade SL needs to be widen a little?
regards Nick
Today the bot was so unlucky with its trade... it closed it little before the market reversed...but i have seen this happened a number of times... Do you think that the firsts trade SL needs to be widen a little?
regards Nick
Member Since Dec 20, 2010
107 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 15:23
We are not just focusing only on the trade copier.. two different entities. The programmer, Eugene, is 100% focused on improving the robot, updating it, which we are working on, and working to improve trade execution so it works on all brokers. The trade copier is being worked on by a separate person. So don't worry attention is NOT being diverted from the robot. The robot needs to work just as well on trade copier we want to provide all options for everyone.
We are still confident in teh current settings. Though some users are tweaking them and are happy with results. In the upgraded versions you can try to adjust SL and see how it may impact results.
We are still confident in teh current settings. Though some users are tweaking them and are happy with results. In the upgraded versions you can try to adjust SL and see how it may impact results.
forex_trader_18284
Member Since Sep 13, 2010
37 posts
Mar 18, 2011 at 17:24
Thanks for your efforts fxgrowthbot. I'm looking forward to the EA updates and will probably give the trade copier service a try as well.
Mar 18, 2011 at 18:28
fxgrowthbot posted:
We are not just focusing only on the trade copier.. two different entities. The programmer, Eugene, is 100% focused on improving the robot, updating it, which we are working on, and working to improve trade execution so it works on all brokers. The trade copier is being worked on by a separate person. So don't worry attention is NOT being diverted from the robot. The robot needs to work just as well on trade copier we want to provide all options for everyone.
We are still confident in teh current settings. Though some users are tweaking them and are happy with results. In the upgraded versions you can try to adjust SL and see how it may impact results.
Thank you very much!
Member Since Mar 16, 2011
60 posts
Mar 19, 2011 at 08:28
fxgrowthbot posted:
We are not just focusing only on the trade copier.. two different entities. The programmer, Eugene, is 100% focused on improving the robot, updating it, which we are working on, and working to improve trade execution so it works on all brokers. The trade copier is being worked on by a separate person. So don't worry attention is NOT being diverted from the robot. The robot needs to work just as well on trade copier we want to provide all options for everyone.
We are still confident in teh current settings. Though some users are tweaking them and are happy with results. In the upgraded versions you can try to adjust SL and see how it may impact results.
It is good to know you are working to improve the trade execution but this has been a problem for weeks now - any idea when a fix will be available? If your programmer Eugene is having trouble with a fix there are a number of people that have offered their services that know how to fix it, maybe you could contact one of them?
Member Since Aug 20, 2009
256 posts
Mar 21, 2011 at 00:04
Hi guys,
If you are using my trailing stop EA, there is an update available over at donnaforex. It will now enter the stoploss for you.
If you are using my trailing stop EA, there is an update available over at donnaforex. It will now enter the stoploss for you.
forex_trader_18284
Member Since Sep 13, 2010
37 posts
Mar 21, 2011 at 04:26
Thanks Kenny.
Mar 21, 2011 at 10:26
if I using 4 decimel broker and 3 pips spread for EURUSD, I don't expect to get same result as your real account, but can I still get minimum 30% gain per month using your EA? this is what I concern before i purchase your EA, because you don't provide trial EA and I can't do backtest, hope can get answer or advise from you.
Member Since Aug 16, 2010
450 posts
Mar 21, 2011 at 16:56
Better change your broker. I tried on FXDD and results were worse than theirs, now I run on TF too and they are absolutely the same, which is reassuring they aren't faked.
Mar 21, 2011 at 17:04
(edited Mar 21, 2011 at 17:04)
