To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Best account type for copy trading / signals

Feb 10, 2017 at 07:40
870 Views
10 Replies
Member Since Jan 21, 2017   14 posts
Feb 10, 2017 at 07:40
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?
YOLO
Member Since Feb 22, 2011   4862 posts
Feb 10, 2017 at 09:09
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

Find a broker like @FXPIG who does offer the lowest total cost.
Total cost is comission plus spread.
Also their execution and leverage are great.
Member Since Mar 14, 2016   44 posts
Feb 10, 2017 at 15:21
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

The slippage is not that much related to the spread but depends on other factors like the volume of your orders for example. The tighter the spread, the better chances you have to reach your TPs and avoid early SLs. I believe your choice of option 2 is good for long term. Why account 1 is better in your specified conditions? I didn't understand that.
When it comes to the broker, I would suggest to find one that does not trade against you but beware to read between the lines as sometimes what the broker says is different from what the regulator says 😄
Member Since Feb 12, 2016   427 posts
Feb 13, 2017 at 16:12
When choosing an account – you have to find the best one matching your strategy. Also as vontogr@ said – go for comparing the total costs. Not only commission or only spread. This will give you a better analysis for your total (possible) profit or lost.
Accept the loss as experience
Member Since Nov 25, 2015   41 posts
Feb 14, 2017 at 10:02
I am not sure but maybe there is a way also to check the account type that you will copy the trades from? Could be good to use similar settings or at least to be aware of the backend of what you are copying from.
korn6
forex_trader_349943
Member Since Aug 07, 2016   10 posts
Feb 21, 2017 at 08:07
togr posted:
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

Find a broker like @FXPIG who does offer the lowest total cost.
Total cost is comission plus spread.
Also their execution and leverage are great.


Excellent advice, you gave me ideas friend!
Member Since Aug 09, 2017   5 posts
Apr 19, 2018 at 10:54
We now have copy trading available using SignalStart, they seem to be one of the best 3rd part signal service providers. Our current strategy is ranked 7th on their website https://theforexcoach.signalstart.com/search-signals
TheForexCoach
Member Since Feb 22, 2011   4862 posts
Apr 19, 2018 at 19:33
korn6 posted:
togr posted:
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

Find a broker like @FXPIG who does offer the lowest total cost.
Total cost is comission plus spread.
Also their execution and leverage are great.


Excellent advice, you gave me ideas friend!

You are welcome
Member Since Oct 13, 2016   27 posts
Apr 30, 2018 at 06:23
togr posted:
korn6 posted:
togr posted:
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

Find a broker like @FXPIG who does offer the lowest total cost.
Total cost is comission plus spread.
Also their execution and leverage are great.


Excellent advice, you gave me ideas friend!

You are welcome
Bu what about deposit/withrawal fees ...LARGE!
“Compound interest is the 8th wonder of the world. He who understands it, earns it; he who doesn’t, pays it.”
Member Since Feb 22, 2011   4862 posts
Apr 30, 2018 at 08:15
ozzy25 posted:
togr posted:
korn6 posted:
togr posted:
khaled912 posted:
I've noticed that there are generally two broad types of accounts that brokers offer:
(1) 0 commission, large spread
(2) $3-$4 commission, tight spread

So far I've been going for (2) to try to minimize slippage; my main concern was trades not getting copied if the price difference was too high.

In some cases, however, account (1) seems to be a better deal (cases where commissions are too high, leverage is too low, or min deposit is too high), so I'm actually now revising my conclusion that (2) is better for copy trading to make sure I'm not missing something.

Any advice?

Find a broker like @FXPIG who does offer the lowest total cost.
Total cost is comission plus spread.
Also their execution and leverage are great.


Excellent advice, you gave me ideas friend!

You are welcome
Bu what about deposit/withrawal fees ...LARGE!

Can you be more specifics, what does mean large?
Member Since Nov 17, 2009   31 posts
Jun 27, 2018 at 06:30
You want to be with a broker that does allot of volume! The more they do, the faster they can execute your trade and limit your slippage. I have been using Oanda for some time and the execution is super fast. I use them via MT4, 2 separate charting packages, and also API algo trading. I have been with STPs/ECNs that cant match the execution speeds and seem to always give me worse price slippage.

Just my 2 cents. I'm sure you'll find a home soon. Hope I helped.
Topic is locked
*Commercial use and spam will not be tolerated, and may result in account termination.
Tip: Posting an image/youtube url will automatically embed it in your post!
Tip: Type the @ sign to auto complete a username participating in this discussion.