KeltnerPRO - Jared Discussion

aeronthomas posted:

walteremslie posted:

stevetrade posted:
By Steve, are you talking to me? Keltner has nothing to do with me. I'm just a customer. I have equity alerts on my accounts and as soon as I get one I check the account. As soon as I saw my accounts I thought "fat finger" and then I checked Bloomberg. As soon as I read the news I shut down all robots and started trying to close down positions. On my Keltner account I came out okay, lost a few quid but nothing to cry about.
Best regards Steve

I am referring to this Steve who also promotes Kelnerpro on his website...

https://automatedtradingsoftware.co.uk/perfect-ea-really-exist/

Steve is just an affiliate marketing for the product, he's not responsible for its performance. He was one of the lucky ones who profited due to being on a good broker feed Pepperstone, seems like this broker and Synergy FX were the ones that did well, and Actitrades were okay. If you were on FX Choice you were shot

"If you were on FX Choice you were shot" Just my luck... figures!

ricki72 posted:

Xamarass posted:

ricki72 posted:

aeronthomas posted:
Another account that didn't seem to get the poor trades on CHF either https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ricki72/rickis-keltnerpro/947997

Yes, i am very sorry for you guys who lost 😭 (and happy that i didn´t).
My broker is activtrades (London) and i promise i didn´t do anything manually (how could i, i was @work).
But i don´t really trust this EA anymore...

__________________

Hi Ricky, why you don't really trust K anymore ? you were trading the USDCHF and K didn't catch the trades ? in that case is a broker issue.......
cheers
Xam

No, i am confused why everybody has different results. A few people made some hundreds % in one day and many others lost their money. But as it seems it depends on the brokers.
Jared didnt trade manually.

I agree with Ricki72; I cannot trust Keltner anymore because I'm in the USA and cannot use Synergy, Pepperstone, etc. Also, next time it may go other way for those brokers. I had other trades a couple weeks back that were opposite Jared's where again he made money and mine lost. Some other times he lost but I did not get in the trade. I would only use Keltner if I could use same broker Jared is. Too much difference, I am sticking with Rev Trader Pro only as only have experienced subtle differences not using Synergy. Wish I could use Synergy and Keltner but since I cannot Keltner is now useless to me. I also have the Entry Filter set to "True". Why did that not prevent the trades from being entered in the first place? Sounds like that doesn't even work. Keltner should also have a max spread setting too. For the price of this EA should have simple settings like that and more.

Jared ... to clear things up, and prove to everyone that your results are true and honest... Especially last weeks usdchf... Post your investor password here in the forum for your followers to log in via investor login to see if your DEMO account results are real or FAKE... im sure that should clear things up here.....

bigtraderapp posted:

ricki72 posted:

Xamarass posted:

ricki72 posted:

aeronthomas posted:
Another account that didn't seem to get the poor trades on CHF either https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ricki72/rickis-keltnerpro/947997

Yes, i am very sorry for you guys who lost 😭 (and happy that i didn´t).
My broker is activtrades (London) and i promise i didn´t do anything manually (how could i, i was @work).
But i don´t really trust this EA anymore...

__________________

Hi Ricky, why you don't really trust K anymore ? you were trading the USDCHF and K didn't catch the trades ? in that case is a broker issue.......
cheers
Xam

No, i am confused why everybody has different results. A few people made some hundreds % in one day and many others lost their money. But as it seems it depends on the brokers.
Jared didnt trade manually.

I agree with Ricki72; I cannot trust Keltner anymore because I'm in the USA and cannot use Synergy, Pepperstone, etc. Also, next time it may go other way for those brokers. I had other trades a couple weeks back that were opposite Jared's where again he made money and mine lost. Some other times he lost but I did not get in the trade. I would only use Keltner if I could use same broker Jared is. Too much difference, I am sticking with Rev Trader Pro only as only have experienced subtle differences not using Synergy. Wish I could use Synergy and Keltner but since I cannot Keltner is now useless to me. I also have the Entry Filter set to "True". Why did that not prevent the trades from being entered in the first place? Sounds like that doesn't even work. Keltner should also have a max spread setting too. For the price of this EA should have simple settings like that and more.

________________________________

Hi Bigtraderapp, I think we have goog points here,
Could someone explain why the max spread option (by defould setted to 3) didn't work last week ?
It should prevent to open trades with that volatility.
I think we need to undestand if we can trust in K and continue to use it with a reasonable expectancy.
As stated by Bigtraderapp, the broker here is not an option, based on the experiances done by several of us, several broker don't fit with K model. I'm using Pepperstone (razor) and it should work. Please (for K user only) share here you experiance in order we can help each other.

1 - Which borker are you managing with KLTN
2 - Is your account reflecting the master account (Jared)
3- How has gone last week with CHF pairs ?
Chhers
Xam

Form my personal prospect:
1 - Pepperstone
2 - Yes
3 - I didn't trade CHF pairs

Has anyone been able to withdraw money from alpari after they crashed?

saaedb posted:
Has anyone been able to withdraw money from alpari after they crashed?

Nope, not yet, KPMG are handling the situation

here is the statement and link to follow up on

For further information, we suggest you monitor the www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari<https://www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari> website which we will continue to update as further information becomes available

NikX posted:

saaedb posted:
Has anyone been able to withdraw money from alpari after they crashed?

Nope, not yet, KPMG are handling the situation

here is the statement and link to follow up on

For further information, we suggest you monitor the www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari<https://www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari> website which we will continue to update as further information becomes available

Do you have another link? that one doesn't work. thanks

marran posted:

NikX posted:

saaedb posted:
Has anyone been able to withdraw money from alpari after they crashed?

Nope, not yet, KPMG are handling the situation

here is the statement and link to follow up on

For further information, we suggest you monitor the www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari<https://www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari> website which we will continue to update as further information becomes available

Do you have another link? that one doesn't work. thanks

try now https://www.insolvency-kpmg.co.uk/case+KPMG+AF119D1101.html

NikX posted:

marran posted:

NikX posted:

saaedb posted:
Has anyone been able to withdraw money from alpari after they crashed?

Nope, not yet, KPMG are handling the situation

here is the statement and link to follow up on

For further information, we suggest you monitor the www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari<https://www.kpmg.com/uk/alpari> website which we will continue to update as further information becomes available

Do you have another link? that one doesn't work. thanks

try now https://www.insolvency-kpmg.co.uk/case+KPMG+AF119D1101.html

many thanks that one works! just hope the money is safe and can be refunded! the whole thing is a massive shame, i liked Alpari they were always very helpful if i had any problems, and seemed to be a very well run brokerage

da phuck!!! :-)

saaedb posted:
da phuck!!! :-)

I know.. I opened my account with them less than a week ago!!

Hi Nick which set have you choosen

Xamarass posted:
Hi Nick which set have you choosen

Hi, sorry what do you mean by set?

presets... settings of the EA

I haven't used the EA for some time, switched it off early december, will fire it back up in the next week or 2.

i just use the standard sets though.. i have a 'special edition' without trent filters. i haven't seen any benefits of using the breakeven also

thanks

Nick

NikX posted:
I haven't used the EA for some time, switched it off early december, will fire it back up in the next week or 2.

i just use the standard sets though.. i have a 'special edition' without trent filters. i haven't seen any benefits of using the breakeven also

thanks

Nick

What is a special edition ??? ???

walteremslie posted:

NikX posted:
I haven't used the EA for some time, switched it off early december, will fire it back up in the next week or 2.

i just use the standard sets though.. i have a 'special edition' without trent filters. i haven't seen any benefits of using the breakeven also

thanks

Nick

What is a special edition ??? ???

PM information :)

NikX posted:

walteremslie posted:

NikX posted:
I haven't used the EA for some time, switched it off early december, will fire it back up in the next week or 2.

i just use the standard sets though.. i have a 'special edition' without trent filters. i haven't seen any benefits of using the breakeven also

thanks

Nick

What is a special edition ??? ???

😁

PM information :)

😁😀😎

Man for the price of this EA it has probably been the most disappointing lately !