To use chat, please login.
Back to contacts

Sakura FX Trading Review Scores


Overall score: 1.8 / 5

Total votes: 5
Profitability
1
Platform
1
Pricing
1
Customer service
1
1 - Worst 5 - Best

Sakura FX Trading Discussion

8 posts
Sorry but my other fund managers apply the hwm correctly. Yours is not applied correctly. So you end up taking a larger profit share than the investor.
29 posts
Hello deltraders,

We charge 25% profit and not 30%, as you calculate over the full time period in the example on our website and we calculate per month then you always get a different end result and there for you

We do the same way any other money mangers do this with the high water mark calculation.

Best regards,
Mark

8 posts
your website talks about 25% performance fee and I can see that in the posted account by one of your followers. However the example shown on website has a total profit of $2500 over three months and a performance fee of $750. That's a 30% fee as the true HWM method is not used. HWM method does not drop the HWM level in a month when there's a loss! That means your client pays for the month of a loss and no consideration the following month when a profit is made. Bit unfair.
29 posts
Hello Vontogr,

Yes this is correct as this is a managed forex account and we charge profit share we not want that the trades are public on myfxbook live or seen on a MT4 platfrom from the investors.

We do this to protect the trader of his income else it is very easy to copy the trades as we only do one trade per day with preset SL and TP and entries around the same time in the morning, this is why we show one account without open trade tab on MFB so our live clients can see that get the same trades and this is also used as verified track record for new clients: https://www.myfxbook.com/members/SakuraTrading/sakura-fx-copy-account/1859280

Best regards,
Mark
4862 posts
SakuraTrading posted:
Hello Vontogr,

You ask this the same to our other live client but our live clients only receive statements of there trades after the are closed.

The reason for this is else everybody can copy our trades for free.

We explain this in this discussion before with others and there for our clients have no MT4 investor password to link there system to MFB.


Best regards,
Mark

OK so your clients do not see trades executed by you on their accounts?
29 posts
Hello Vontogr,

You ask this the same to our other live client but our live clients only receive statements of there trades after the are closed.

The reason for this is else everybody can copy our trades for free.

We explain this in this discussion before with others and there for our clients have no MT4 investor password to link there system to MFB.


Best regards,
Mark
4862 posts
swedoc posted:
Hello all,
I dont trust so many in the Forex market, there are so many fake people trying to fool you and take your money. Its always a risk to take when investing in Forex. Im really not sure why I came to try Sakura, I think it was because I trusted MyFxbook. There is nothing sure in this world, sometimes one have to take a leap and I did that when trusting Sakura. Up until now, I have had nothing to complain about. The return has been as expected from the results on myfxbook. I did withdraw money, 5000 USD, two days ago and they money was on my account one day later, that is yesterday.
So, until now, things are actually what they seem to appear! Sakura Fxtradiing delivers what they say. What happens in the future, nobody can say. But hey, tomorrow one can get a brick in the head and die! I trust in what I can see, and right now I have nothing but positive things to say about Sakura. They have delivered on what they say.
And hey, Im NOT bought by anyone! So please, dont reply in that matter!
Here are they trading account on Sakura, my personal details removed. And my bank account, with the transfer registered extremely fast!! I have highlighted the transfer of 5000 USD in red, and you can see it in SEK on my account.
Regards
/Pierre

@Pierre
Why dont you publish your account here on your MFB profile
13 posts
Hello all,
I dont trust so many in the Forex market, there are so many fake people trying to fool you and take your money. Its always a risk to take when investing in Forex. Im really not sure why I came to try Sakura, I think it was because I trusted MyFxbook. There is nothing sure in this world, sometimes one have to take a leap and I did that when trusting Sakura. Up until now, I have had nothing to complain about. The return has been as expected from the results on myfxbook. I did withdraw money, 5000 USD, two days ago and they money was on my account one day later, that is yesterday.
So, until now, things are actually what they seem to appear! Sakura Fxtradiing delivers what they say. What happens in the future, nobody can say. But hey, tomorrow one can get a brick in the head and die! I trust in what I can see, and right now I have nothing but positive things to say about Sakura. They have delivered on what they say.
And hey, Im NOT bought by anyone! So please, dont reply in that matter!
Here are they trading account on Sakura, my personal details removed. And my bank account, with the transfer registered extremely fast!! I have highlighted the transfer of 5000 USD in red, and you can see it in SEK on my account.
Regards
/Pierre

Attachments:

29 posts
Hello all,

From now the open trade tab on our verified track record page show the same trade and details as the screenshot of our MT4 platform and account, see a screenshot attached.

Best regards,
mark

Attachments:

29 posts
Hello all,

Hereby upload a screenshot of the entry and open position with stops on the MT4 platfrom of the MT4 account show in myfxbook verified track record page.

It is not in my hands or under my control when also myfxbook will show this same trade in the open trade tab as the update it every 30 min, as soon i will see it i will also make a screenshot of this so you all can see the same details.

Best regards,
Mark

Attachments:

4862 posts
OliverFX posted:
Hello guys,

I received a notification as SakuraFX trading live client that I can now make reviews and read them on new Sakura myfxbook review page. After reading the discussion here I wanted to post also about my experience with Sakura but you can not do that unless you have an account with myfxbook first. I am not really interested in services of myfxbook but just came here to give the review because the service has been really good and thats why my account is new. People only seem to think that bad reviews are real and good reviews are seen as advertisement. If you dont believe that I am giving out my own opinion than you can see my monthly statements from last months, where you can also see withdrawals that I have made already. For privacy reasons I have blurred my name and account number.
Why on earth do you publish screenshots on website
where you can add account and all stats with a few clicks
23 posts
Ok, thats better. Keep it open for a few days. I dont know why you did not do that before, we would have had a different conversation...
29 posts
Hello all,

From now the open trade tab on our verified track record page show the same trade and details as the screenshot of our MT4 platform and account, see a screenshot attached.

Best regards,
mark

Attachments:

29 posts
Hello all,

Hereby upload a screenshot of the entry and open position with stops on the MT4 platfrom of the MT4 account show in myfxbook verified track record page.

It is not in my hands or under my control when also myfxbook will show this same trade in the open trade tab as the update it every 30 min, as soon i will see it i will also make a screenshot of this so you all can see the same details.

Best regards,
Mark

Attachments:

29 posts
hello jdsjioj,

we not worry for anybody copy our trades in this situation and short time frame!! We only don't understand why you not trust myfxbook open trades tab!! There is not reason or any proof from your side that this open trades can't be trusted as you see the same if you would had the investor password of the MT4 account as that is what myfxbook use to see the open trades.

This is the same as Signal start copy trade service, this mean that if you not trust myfxbook what is the purpose of you all looking on myfxbook for other traders and there track record and then have comments on it because we use myfxbook for our track record!!

We cant open a demo account by us and link it to the MAM system this group only provide live accounts as we are a WL of our liquidity provider and you all should know this.

All things need to come form both sides and our main trader have the last word in this and he say that he has no problem to show the open live trades on our myfxbook verified track record MT4 account this will show you the entry and the stops and later the end results in our verified track record and for our demo account holders in the member area and for our live account holders for ones and for all.

We do trust myfxbook and untill anybody show us proof that myfxbook is not to be trusted this is the way what we use to be transparent with open trades tab.

PS: i will post a msg with a screenshot and link to the open live tab when the trade is taken and open.

Best regards,
Mark

23 posts
Then open a demo on your own broker and provide investor pass for 2 days. Nobody will copy traders for 2 days and everyone will be able to see them. Is that something you can do or will you find another excuse?
29 posts
hello jdsjioj,

We can't go to everybody different request and if you not read and understand that it would not make any different how we will do it it will never get the same results, if you not trust the open trade positions and ope orders on myfxbook there is noting else i can do for you or anybody body else.

The next 2 days the open trade and order tabs are sho public on myfxbook.

best regards,
mark
23 posts
@SakuraTrading

If you are so keen to prove you are not a Ponzi, you should just set up a demo and copy trades for a week. We all know OliverFX, Megainvestor and SuperTrader are all profiles you have opened to promote your 'trading'. I mean it is kind of a strange coincidence that all those users were registered on the exact same day, within 2 hours and only comment on Sakura. It is becoming more and more obvious, you are doing this yourself.

You said your trader doesnt have time to trade a demo account. Thats ok. I will pay for a VPS and a trade copy EA for you and you can set up the account and copy the trades for a week. You can change the password, I do not need access to it. It will take you 5 min to set it up and thats all, it is that simple. If the results on demo and live account match, I will invest 10k with you right away because the results you show are by far the best on myfxbook.

You can shut us all up by simply doing what I am proposing. It should not be a big deal for you to do it as you would get rid of all the doubters and conduct your business without any distraction in the future.
4862 posts
SakuraTrading posted:
Hi everybody,

This statement of my was not only meant to you but to all the others as well (i forget to place there names in the topic) as a explanation after a couple of accusations that the person who wrote a nice review about us is a fake account and just set up and have not system!!.

That is why i explain that we just have set up this review page and notify our demo and live clients and members if they want to leaf any nice review of there experience with us, i only explain that not all of our clients or members will have a account or a system by MFB, so if they want to leave a review the need to create a MFB account first that is all what i wanted to say.

Best regards,
Mark

Mark,

leaf is the green thing on tree.
MFB user can post comment after registration.
To share the results he has to connect his account to mfb.
If user write great reviews without sharing account it is suspicious.

In other words to support your campaign here you should share the results here.

So many green leafs to you :)
29 posts
Hi everybody,

This statement of my was not only meant to you but to all the others as well (i forget to place there names in the topic) as a explanation after a couple of accusations that the person who wrote a nice review about us is a fake account and just set up and have not system!!.

That is why i explain that we just have set up this review page and notify our demo and live clients and members if they want to leaf any nice review of there experience with us, i only explain that not all of our clients or members will have a account or a system by MFB, so if they want to leave a review the need to create a MFB account first that is all what i wanted to say.

Best regards,
Mark
Please login to comment .