Advertisement
Forex Growth Bot
| Zisk : | +2644.71% |
| Čerpanie | 94.46% |
| Pipy: | 8075.5 |
| Obchodníci | 2881 |
| Vyhrané: |
|
| Prehrané: |
|
| Typ: | Reálny |
| Páka: | 1:200 |
| Obchodovanie: | Automaticky |
Forex Growth Bot Diskusia
Členom od Apr 15, 2011
97 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 13:36
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 13:38)
nexindo_pandu posted:
cunod posted:now I only have 3 trade. the last one ended with a loss just when the EUR got a bounce a moment ago.
and there is position 5 lol, FGB has been busy the last 12 hours
well, I believe in the system, but I got one mistake in the first trade that I want to recover first. then, I'll let FGB work just as it should be.
im with you on that, I feel FGB is a great system. Though I do find if I don't babysit at times things don't work out sometimes. In fact I am seeing closures on orders in myfxbook before I manually close them at times. As for the bounce you were talking about, if its what im looking at If I would not have closed the sell order early it would have wound up being about a 60 pip loss on a .06 lot which I already described is a bit to much for me if it would have held it to right now, which I don't think would have happened. FGB is good at closing a loss.
Keep in mind I am refering to the basic system, not advanced or whatever else there is.
Členom od Apr 04, 2011
14 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 13:42
the FGB close the position, but not in mine....they close in profit, but mine still have to wait...i think i have to close it manually then
Členom od Jul 21, 2010
119 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 14:15
I think they closed manually
Členom od Apr 18, 2011
33 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 14:20
my position its stil open.. now i'm in minus... that is happening???
Členom od Apr 04, 2011
14 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 14:22
hi zsolt, it happen to me too. I think we have to close it manually. try to find the best exit.
Členom od Apr 18, 2011
33 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 14:29
i think, that all the users are in similar situation.... somethime, u check, u are in nice profit, and after a while the trades ar closed in minus... plus there is no sl/ you canot use with Kennys ea!...if something its happening in the currency market, and the EA has some errors, the trade its not closed, we are losing all the money........ ..... 😡 The FGB Team needs to fix this problem! Its time to improve the EAGuys.. i know, that the stats looks nice here, but the EA has a lot of issues! Thank U!
i'm stiil keeping this time the positions open, lets see what is happening with the market... i have now 4opened positions with nice lot sizes!!!1
i'm stiil keeping this time the positions open, lets see what is happening with the market... i have now 4opened positions with nice lot sizes!!!1
forex_trader_12567
Členom od May 29, 2010
258 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 14:43
i think this EA good in opening and not in closing. i think the writer should give any confirmation, is he manually closed or not. btw, maybe one of you has the same broker with the writer of FGB? you may share here.
Členom od Jul 21, 2010
119 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 15:23
The open was the exactly same of this account, I don't believe the close can be different, we everybody had no close, different broker is just a pretext to hide that EA had problem in closing. I'm sure they closed mannually.
Členom od Jul 21, 2010
119 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 15:39
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 15:40)
I want add: I noticed that the trades has been closed after 18 hours. smartexit get a lower take profit if the take profit is not reached after 18 hours. I asked to FGB staff if dothey use this option, they answer "NO, we use the default setting" I don't think so.
There are 2 possibilities.
1-> they cheat us, they closed manually and lie us saying they don't.
2-> they have not the default config (ex: smartexit activated)
There are 2 possibilities.
1-> they cheat us, they closed manually and lie us saying they don't.
2-> they have not the default config (ex: smartexit activated)
Členom od Jan 13, 2010
13 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 15:39
aryaforex posted:
i think this EA good in opening and not in closing. i think the writer should give any confirmation, is he manually closed or not. btw, maybe one of you has the same broker with the writer of FGB? you may share here.
I'm using the same broker as FGB and the trades are opened similar to the records here. The last period I have had differences in closing, and certainly the last three which is still open and I intend to leave them for the bot to close even tho they're closed by FGB.
I have been very happy with the Growthbot so far, but if the FGB team keeps closing trades manually and the records doesn't reflect the bot's behaviour, I'm inclined to not trust it so much anymore. I really don't want to handle trades manually and be forced to be watching the bot - that's not why I bought it.
Someone also asked about a good place to go learn good manual trading, and to those who wish I can give very warm recommendations to fxbootcamp.com. I have been wih them for a while, and I think they are really professional and well worth the price.
//Mr T
Členom od Mar 08, 2010
32 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 15:58
Mine closed (paper trading) on collective fx in profit - I never intercede with the ea's trading.
Členom od Mar 20, 2011
22 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 16:10
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 16:10)
someone has the same results as on monitoring?
forex_trader_17053
Členom od Aug 21, 2010
11 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 16:43
The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...
The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.
Cheers
The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.
Cheers
Členom od Apr 15, 2011
97 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 16:43
tola posted:
I'm using the same broker as FGB and the trades are opened similar to the records here. The last period I have had differences in closing, and certainly the last three which is still open and I intend to leave them for the bot to close even tho they're closed by FGB.
I have been very happy with the Growthbot so far, but if the FGB team keeps closing trades manually and the records doesn't reflect the bot's behaviour, I'm inclined to not trust it so much anymore. I really don't want to handle trades manually and be forced to be watching the bot - that's not why I bought it.
//Mr T
Ok, I am going to give FGB the benifit of the doubt on this comment. Mind you I have no proof to back this up and it is just speculation. Can anyone confirm if this issue has occurred before the implementation of v1.4 (which I think was about a week or 2 ago). They updated it due to some verification issue when you attached it to the chart. I am aware of this because I experienced it. As a speculation could they have screwed something up in the closing procedure due to this fix.
Členom od Apr 15, 2011
97 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 16:50
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 16:52)
expat1967 posted:
The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...
The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.
Cheers
My opinion on the stealth features are they should post a TP/SL that is so out of bounds its not going to matter to the broker in the event of a win lose scenario.
For example if it buys the EURUSD set the stop loss at 1.00000 and the take profit at 2.00000
Unless there is more to a EA stealth feature, I'm not to familiar with EA scripts.
Or did you mean something else by this comment?
Členom od Jul 21, 2010
119 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 17:10
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 17:11)
I have the proof that it's not a broker issue. Look tghe screenshot, come from 1 minut chart of my platform. at 05.12.2011 10:45 they close the position at 1.41320, at the same time my broker was exactly at the same price, there's no difference. Look at the attached file.
Prílohy:
Členom od Mar 20, 2011
22 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 17:22
They are not honest to us.
Členom od Apr 15, 2011
97 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 17:25
prototipo posted:
I have the proof that it's not a broker issue. Look tghe screenshot, come from 1 minut chart of my platform. at 05.12.2011 10:45 they close the position at 1.41320, at the same time my broker was exactly at the same price, there's no difference. Look at the attached file.
FGB do you wish to comment on this?
Členom od Jul 21, 2010
119 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 17:27
expat1967 posted:
The stealth feature makes this Bot so stealth that even traders dont know whats happening... Thats a serious laps...
The developer can pull TP/SL easily out which is essential for traders to determine the trade status. It can be stealthed on chart/server accordingly upon Broker concerns.
Cheers
yeah I think the same, now I configured ASSIGN TP AND SL to True, so I can check it.
But I have a doubt, does it works with ECN broker that not accept SL and TP when opening order but only in later when the order is already open? does it work? I would please an answer from FGB staff.
Členom od Apr 15, 2011
30 príspevkov
May 12, 2011 at 17:47
(upravené May 12, 2011 at 17:48)
I am sorry that I have to say that, but at the moment I am really pissed of!!! I came at home from work a few minutes ago, switch on my PC and what I have to see?! FGB made 195.8 Pips profit in the last 3 trades and at the same three trades I have lost around 180 pips! Do you guys from FGB want to cheat me?! I had the same trades, with the same opening time, I use as well the SAME BROKER (ThinkForex) - How can this be? I am only a moment away to request refund!!! I am so angry at the moment! And you guys are not able at least to post any comment here!
