KeltnerPRO - Jared Diskusia

braddock posted:
this ea on longterm is the best .... dont understand why some people cry always when there is a loosing month.... this is nearly a set and forget robot .... and the bigger tp then sl always this ea will win and dont need always updates....

best is to take 2 or 3 different brokers.... 1 time one is better other time other is better...

start on each broker with 500 $ and in a few years you are happy. :)

this whats happen on 15 january with swiss, was not the fault from the ea... was the fault from the brokers.... a lot lost all the money and a lot make good wins .... no ea in the world can manage this spikes from 15 january ....this spikes was brokerdepend

hi I think this still good EA I demo with diferent brokers many months all brokers makes almost the same trades, stable pairs eurusd, gbpusd, in BT and custom analysis audusd, nzdusd, no good, usdchf risky

corre71 posted:

saaedb posted:

corre71 posted:

saaedb posted:

corre71 posted:
There is not only 1 way leading to success 😁

Does it require zero effort and lets me be lazy?

Not unfortunately there is no easy way to earn from trading. It requires a lot of work and attention, also about Automated trading. The most difficult is in discerning EAs which potentially can be profitable from craps. You have no guarantee, but splitting ur funds on several 'good' strategies You have good chances

Most of the commercial EAs are probably crap, but some are not. Keltner if you asked my opinion, i think is a very good EA.
Now what makes it dangerous? The vendor sets up high risk to get these mammoth gains to attract greed. People want to replicate the vendor's results and crank up the risk too... a couple of blows and you're out where as the vendor got lucky on his account attempt# X and made it.

So if you treat the EA right, and don't over risk/leverage yourself and allow the EA to be able to sustain a reasonable draw down... I think you could make money from certain EAs and Keltner in my books is one of those EAs.

And for Manual trading... if you have the time and skills, no EA can beat manual trading.
 

Completely agree: run Keltner with 0.01 for each 1k and u will not suffer in DD periods. If the account is small u can also run at 0.02 x 1K. If u want to earn more, do not rise the risk, but simply diversify ur EA portfolio with some other good strategy

Are you still running KeltnerPRO? I can't see it on your page?

Thanks

it seems that this system is running on a very bad period. It has always been recovering pretty well (apart from the failure on the 15th of january on the other myfxchoice live account) but this time it seems to struggle. Any thoughts from those using it or the owner?

Bloodbath today for this ea i see...

NFP is mostly like a whipsaw for any ea.....😁

Not sure NFP impact of friday Keltner's trades !
cheers

I am using FXCM with this EA on a vps and I am doing better than the master account at this time.

You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

HAHAHA 😎

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

I suppose You keep repeating this Yourself in order to sleep at night, but do You really believe in it? :)

I am in good gain with Keltner and imo the actual DD period is nothing special or to worry about. Long term BTs shows that stagnation periods can be also much longer (2 years and more). Of course none can assurde us that a strategy will continue to work, but now i do not see any sign that this strategy becane obsolete. I only see the usual jump in - jump out behaviour from the majority of the traders which stop to use a valid strategy after few losses: simply look at Wally, Diamond, Polygon, Robin Vol. When the majority of the users stop to use a strategy is usually the time it start again to deliver profits
Anyway everyone has his evaluation methods
From my side i will continue to use Keltner in my portfolio at low risk and planning to further reduce the risk introducing other good eas to further smooth my results

crashev posted:

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

I suppose You keep repeating this Yourself in order to sleep at night, but do You really believe in it? :)

SAVAGE lol

crashev posted:

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

I suppose You keep repeating this Yourself in order to sleep at night, but do You really believe in it? :)

I guess you did not watch my accounts, I am not in that tragic situation. I still can sleep. ;)

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

I suppose You keep repeating this Yourself in order to sleep at night, but do You really believe in it? :)

I guess you did not watch my accounts, I am not in that tragic situation. I still can sleep. ;)

I just looked at Your accounts, they sure can backup 'With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.'
They sure prove You can sleep well:

TD1 Cesare FX Portfolio Management Drawdown: 49.81%
TD2 Small Accounts Fx Portfolio Management Drawdown: 73.53%

Of course with big risk comes big profits, but it's for sure not sane trading and 'Good money management' unlsess You just play with silly balances and as I see You do :)

crashev posted:

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:

mendeco posted:

crashev posted:
You are all going to blow up Your accounts soon :)

With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.

I suppose You keep repeating this Yourself in order to sleep at night, but do You really believe in it? :)

I guess you did not watch my accounts, I am not in that tragic situation. I still can sleep. ;)

I just looked at Your accounts, they sure can backup 'With a good money management, unless you are hit by an absurd movement like the suisse bank chaos of mid january you cannot blow an account if an EA is not going well for a period of time like this.'
They sure prove You can sleep well:

TD1 Cesare FX Portfolio Management Drawdown: 49.81%
TD2 Small Accounts Fx Portfolio Management Drawdown: 73.53%

Of course with big risk comes big profits, but it's for sure not sane trading and 'Good money management' unlsess You just play with silly balances and as I see You do :)

The first one reached that drawdown at the beginning when I was using a martingale EA that I wanted to hedge with another EA but couldn't develop the 2nd one in time and then I just removed the first one. From then on the DD was kept below 25% (maybe even 20%) and most of the time never reached 3%. And I used a couple of EAs I bought that were not that good that raised that DD and lowered the profits (and as soon as I realized that I removed them).

The 2nd account (TD2) was hit by the suisse bank chaos in mid january (without that silly and unusual movement, right now, its performance was more than 400% with a 30% DD (more or less apart from the 1st month after its creation) and after the 15th of january the DD was kept at 30% with a very small account (and that is not easy to do that so regularly ;) )

@ mendeco..


You do not have to justify yourself... you are right. keltner is one of the best eas i ever get... all people are crying when there are some losses and they have to high risk.... and when the ea makes ione day a good profit they are happy... when there are 2 month shit they are angry.... i trade with this ea since 1 year... and for me is one of the best eas i ever saw.... with this ea you need patience....

people they think to make every month 100-200% with eas they are wrong..... they have to go in the casino... then they will double their money maybe a lot of days and in 1 day they will loose all.

braddock posted:
@ mendeco..


You do not have to justify yourself... you are right. keltner is one of the best eas i ever get... all people are crying when there are some losses and they have to high risk.... and when the ea makes ione day a good profit they are happy... when there are 2 month shit they are angry.... i trade with this ea since 1 year... and for me is one of the best eas i ever saw.... with this ea you need patience....

people they think to make every month 100-200% with eas they are wrong..... they have to go in the casino... then they will double their money maybe a lot of days and in 1 day they will loose all.

No need to go to a casino to lose all, this EA does the job as well, as the vendor has proven with his other account.. 😉

with the other account was not the fault from the ea... that was the broker issue on 15 th january.......

some brokers killed the accounts and with other brokers you made profit.... but never the fault from the ea !!!

i lost too in 1 broker this day... and with the other broker i made profit.